present our Trade Routes Story Map to a real audience, answer visitors’ questions with evidence, and explain how the routes connected people and who benefited.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Our story map opens today. Reread the museum essay from lesson 2.15 on how the western Sudan grew rich. You now know far more than when you first read it. Write the one sentence you will say to a visitor who asks, “How did Mali get so rich?”
Write your one-sentence answer to the unit puzzle, with one piece of evidence.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Today you are the guides. Families, neighbors and younger students will walk the story map. Each team stands at its route panel. Visitors may stop for only a minute or two, so lead with your big idea.
A strong guide talk has three moves. First, the big idea in one sentence. Second, one piece of evidence and its source. Third, one connection to another route or to life today. Then invite a question.
Worked example 1: Kofi’s talk. “Mali grew rich because it controlled gold and salt trade across the Sahara. A writer in Egypt reported that so much gold arrived in 1324 that its value fell for about twelve years. Europeans knew of this gold too, which is why a 1375 map shows Mansa Musa holding gold. What would you like to know?”
Worked example 2: Emma answers a hard question. A visitor asks, “Was he the richest man ever?” Emma says, “Many websites say so, but no one counted his wealth. The sources show he was one of the richest rulers of his time.” She separates fact from claim, just as we practiced.
When you don’t know. It is honest and strong to say, “Our sources don’t tell us that. Here is what they do tell us.” Write down visitors’ questions on the question card for our reflection.
Show respect. Speak about enslaved people, conquered peoples and Native nations as real people. No acting, costumes or role-play. Point to the map and let the evidence speak.
Rehearse with a partner before visitors arrive.
During the opening.
Record three visitor questions and how you answered each. Mark any you could not answer.
After the opening, explain one cause and one effect your panel showed visitors.
Today our evidence reached a real audience. That is what historians do.
Exit ticket: what did a visitor learn from you today? How do you know?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 6 minutes, mini lecture 5, rehearsal 9, opening 17, closure 3. If families visit after school, run rehearsal in class and the opening at the event.
Likely misconceptions: that a guide must know everything; that a longer talk is better; that a dramatic act is more engaging than evidence. Keep presentations to explanation and pointing at the map.
Supports: cue cards with the three moves; a visitor question card at each panel; let quieter students take the greeter or question-recorder role first. Invite families, neighbors or younger classes from our school.
Answer guide: warm-up sentences should name gold and salt trade or control of trade routes, with one source. Cause-effect answers should link one cause (for example, monsoon winds, safe roads, control of gold) to a result shown on the panel. Collect question cards for 2.27.
The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History, The Empires of the Western Sudan (2000) · Copyright The Metropolitan Museum of Art; Met terms allow limited noncommercial educational use with credit. Summarized in our own words with a link
This is the museum essay we read when we began building. It explains the answer to our unit puzzle in a few big ideas.
Ghana, Mali and Songhai, the great empires of the western Sudan, were built mainly on control of the gold and salt trade across the Sahara. Gold came from mines in the south of West Africa. Salt came from Saharan mines such as Taghaza and was needed in the south for health and for keeping food. The kingdoms sat between the two, so they grew rich by taxing goods coming in and going out.
Trade across the savanna is old. People there probably traded long before camel caravans began crossing the Sahara around the A.D. 200s or 300s. From the 600s, Arab and Berber merchants expanded the desert trade and linked West Africa with the Islamic world.
Camels made the crossing possible, and horses helped rulers control the routes. Much of what we know comes from Arab writers, so we still read their accounts carefully, as we did with al-Umari’s report of Mansa Musa’s 1324 visit to Cairo.
Source: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History, The Empires of the Western Sudan (2000) (metmuseum.org)