explain how Athenian citizens governed themselves and use evidence to identify who was excluded.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Imagine our school says, “Everyone gets a vote on the new playground,” but then only eighth-grade boys may vote. Is that still “everyone”? Write one sentence.
Could a woman born in Athens vote in its assembly?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
How Athenian democracy worked. Athens practiced direct democracy. Citizens did not elect representatives to vote for them. They gathered in the assembly and voted themselves on laws, war and peace. Many officials were chosen by lottery, and large juries of citizens decided court cases.
Who counted as a citizen? Only free adult men with Athenian families. Three large groups were shut out: women, metics (free foreigners who lived and worked in Athens, sometimes for their whole lives) and enslaved people. The Carlos Museum at Emory University estimates that between 450 and 320 B.C., about 80,000 to 100,000 people in Athens were enslaved, about one in four inhabitants.
Worked example 1: evidence of exclusion. Priya uses today’s reading. She writes, “The Met says a woman in Classical Athens lacked any rights of citizenship, so she could not vote in the assembly, even though the city called itself a democracy.”
Worked example 2: a careful comparison. Marcus wants to say “Athens was not a real democracy.” His teammate suggests a stronger, more exact claim: “Athens shared power widely among adult male citizens, more than most governments of its time, but it excluded most of the people who lived there.” Exact claims are easier to defend with evidence.
A lasting contribution. Athenians gave the world the word and an early model of democracy. Later peoples, including the writers of the United States Constitution, studied Greek ideas, and they too argued about who should be included. The idea grew as more people demanded a voice.
Exhibit task. Our exhibit label on Athens must tell both halves of the story: what citizens built and who was left out.
Sort the people of Athens using the reading and the mini lesson. Each team makes a two-column chart: could vote / could not vote.
Draft an exhibit label.
Write a 3-4 sentence museum label titled “Athens: Rule by the People.” Include one thing citizens did and two groups who were excluded, with evidence from today's sources.
Athens shared power widely among some and denied it to many. Next we travel to Rome, where a different kind of government grew: a republic with written laws.
Exit ticket: why is “who could vote?” an important question to ask about any democracy?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, sort and practice 10, label 7.
Sources: Met, Women in Classical Greece; Met, The Art of Classical Greece (adult male citizens in the assembly); Michael C. Carlos Museum, Confronting Slavery in the Classical World (enslaved population estimate).
Accuracy: population figures are estimates. The Met’s essay describes elite Athenian ideals; poorer women often worked outside the home. Do not claim the U.S. founders copied Athens directly; they read Greek and Roman history and drew more on the Roman Republic.
Likely misconceptions: that “democracy” always meant everyone; that the excluded had no lives worth studying.
Supports: provide the two-column chart and sentence frames. Stretch: compare Athenian exclusions with U.S. voting rights before the 19th Amendment.
Answer guide: labels should name an action of citizens (voting in the assembly, serving on juries) and at least two excluded groups (women, metics, enslaved people). Dowry answer: a limited protection, not political power.
The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History, Women in Classical Greece · Copyright The Metropolitan Museum of Art; Met terms allow limited noncommercial educational use with credit. Summarized in our own words with a link
In Classical Greece, girls usually grew up in the care of a nurse and spent much of their time in the women’s rooms of the house, often upstairs. Women spun thread, wove cloth, raised children and managed the household.
Women did leave the house for some tasks. Getting water at the public fountain was a chance to meet other women. Women visited family tombs, could attend public speeches and took part in religious festivals, some just for women. In public, a young woman was expected to stay quiet and cover her head.
Most girls married at about fourteen or fifteen. A bride did not have to agree to the marriage. She passed from her father’s protection to her husband’s. The museum states that a young woman in Classical Athens lacked any rights of citizenship. She could only be described as the wife of a citizen.
One protection was the dowry, money or goods a bride brought to the marriage. Her husband could not spend it, and if the marriage ended, it was returned to her father. The average woman lived to about forty.
Source: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History, Women in Classical Greece (metmuseum.org)