tell primary sources from secondary sources, use both to research a stop on our story map, and ask questions a source can answer.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. A map is a source too. In 1375, mapmakers on an island in the Mediterranean Sea drew a king of West Africa on their map. They had never been to Mali. As you read, ask: how could they know about him?
Where was the Catalan Atlas made, according to the reading?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Historians sort their sources. A primary source was made at the time we are studying, by people who saw or took part in events, or who lived then. A secondary source was made later by someone who studied primary sources. Both are useful, and good research uses both.
The Catalan Atlas is a primary source. It was made in 1375, about 50 years after Mansa Musa’s journey. It tells us what some Europeans of that time knew and believed about West Africa. The website that describes it is a secondary source, written by scholars in 2019.
Primary does not mean perfect. The mapmakers on Majorca never met Mansa Musa. They likely learned about him from merchants and travelers. So the map is strong evidence of what Europeans believed, and weaker evidence of exactly how Mansa Musa looked.
Worked example 1: Priya sorts her sources. Priya lists three sources for the Timbuktu stop: the 1375 atlas (primary), today’s website (secondary) and the Met essay from lesson 2.15 (secondary). Next to each she writes who made it and when. Now she can see that most of her facts come from scholars who studied older sources.
Worked example 2: Connor asks the source a question. Connor first asks the atlas, “How much gold did Mansa Musa own?” The map cannot answer that. He revises: “What did European mapmakers in 1375 believe about Mali’s wealth?” The map can answer this one, because the caption tells us.
Corroborate across sources. Many books say the map shows Mansa Musa holding a gold nugget. The Northwestern site calls it a golden orb. Both agree he holds gold. When small details differ, we write the part the sources agree on.
Use the reading and the worked examples.
Start your research log.
Write two research questions for your panel: one a primary source could answer and one that needs a secondary source. Explain your choices.
Draft a 40-word stop card about the Catalan Atlas. Include who made it, when, and what it shows people believed.
Every source has a maker, a time and a purpose. Knowing them tells us how far to trust it.
Exit ticket: what does the Catalan Atlas tell us about how Europeans saw West Africa in 1375? What can it not tell us?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 9, guided practice 12, research log 8, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that primary sources are always true; that secondary sources are less valuable; that a map is not a source. Note that Majorca, not mainland Spain, is where the atlas was made, and that the maker is uncertain.
Supports: provide a two-column sorter (primary, secondary) and the image of the Mansa Musa panel from the source page. Stretch: ask why a European king might want a map showing African gold.
Answer guide: exit tickets should say Europeans saw West Africa as rich in gold and its ruler as powerful; the map cannot show his real appearance, how much gold he owned, or how Malians saw themselves. Stop cards should name 1375, Majorca, a possible maker and the gold caption.
Caravans of Gold, Fragments in Time (Northwestern University), Atlas of Maritime Charts (The Catalan Atlas) · Copyright the authors, Northwestern University (2019). Retold in our own words with a link to the source
The Catalan Atlas was made in 1375 on Majorca, an island in the Mediterranean Sea that is part of Spain today. It is painted on parchment, a writing surface made from animal skin, and mounted on six wooden panels. Today it is kept at the National Library of France.
The atlas is often credited to Abraham Cresques, a Jewish mapmaker, but experts say he only possibly made it. It may have been ordered by the King of Aragon as a gift for Charles V, King of France. Those are clues about who the map was made for.
On one panel, a ruler sits on a throne and holds a golden orb, or ball. He is Mansa Musa. The writing beside him calls him the lord of Guinea, a name Europeans used for West Africa. It says he is the richest and most distinguished ruler of the whole region because so much gold is found in his lands.
The website explains that the atlas shows how interested Europeans were in world trade. It also shows how important West Africa was in the networks that moved goods between continents.
Source: Caravans of Gold, Fragments in Time (Northwestern University), Atlas of Maritime Charts (The Catalan Atlas) (caravans.library.northwestern.edu)