compare how Athens, Rome, the Mauryan Empire and Han China were governed and explain one lasting contribution of each.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Think of three ways a group can make decisions: one person decides, a few leaders decide, or everyone votes. Which do you use at home, in class, or on a team?
In Han China, how did many people become government officials?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A comparison chart. Historians compare societies by asking the same questions of each. Who held power? How were leaders chosen? Who was left out? What lasting idea did they leave?
| Society | Who held power | Lasting contribution |
|---|---|---|
| Athens (c. 450s-320s B.C.) | Adult male citizens in the assembly; women, metics and enslaved people excluded | Direct democracy |
| Roman Republic (from 509 B.C.), then Empire (from 27 B.C.) | Elected officials and the senate; later an emperor | Written law, republic, senate |
| Mauryan Empire (c. 321-185 B.C.) | An emperor and his officials | Ashoka’s public edicts on right conduct |
| Han China (206 B.C.-A.D. 220) | An emperor and Confucian-educated officials | Government by trained officials; paper |
Similar and different. All four had powerful leaders, armies and enslaved or unfree people. They differed in how many people had a say and in how officials were chosen: by vote, by birth and wealth, by an emperor’s choice, or by education.
Worked example 1: a fair comparison. Isabella writes, “Athens and the Han both used many officials, but Athenian citizens voted directly, while Han officials were chosen for their education in Confucian writings.” She compared the same question for both.
Worked example 2: avoiding a ranking. Tyler first writes, “Athens was the only advanced government.” He revises: “Each society solved the problem of governing a large population in its own way, and each left ideas that lasted.” Historians compare; they do not rank peoples as better or worse.
Ideas that reach us. The United States uses a republic with a senate, protects the vote, and hires many government workers through tests and qualifications. Each idea has a long history in more than one place.
Use the reading and the comparison chart. Fill in your own copy of the chart as you go.
Compare two.
Choose two of the four societies. Write a paragraph comparing who held power and one lasting contribution of each. Use the words “both” and “but.”
Every government left people out. Next we look closely at the people classical societies enslaved, and at their lives.
Exit ticket: name one idea from today that still shapes how the United States is governed, and where it came from.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 8, mini lesson 10, chart practice 10, paragraph 7.
Sources: Met, Han Dynasty; Met, The Roman Republic and The Roman Empire; Met, Mauryan Empire; Met, The Art of Classical Greece.
Accuracy: the A.D. 166 visitor is reported in Chinese records; historians debate whether he was an official envoy or a merchant. The Han examination system was early and limited compared with later dynasties; say “educated officials,” not “civil service exams for all.” The U.S. federal merit system began in 1883; do not claim it copied China directly.
Likely misconceptions: that one society was “more civilized”; that emperors ruled alone without officials.
Supports: partly filled chart; sentence frame “Both ___ and ___ ___, but ___.” Stretch: add the Gupta dynasty as a fifth row.
Answer guide: most students should argue Athens gave the most people a direct voice, while noting it excluded most residents; accept a well-argued case for the Roman Republic’s elected offices.
The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History, Han Dynasty (206 B.C.-220 A.D.) · Copyright The Metropolitan Museum of Art; Met terms allow limited noncommercial educational use with credit. Summarized in our own words with a link
After the death of China’s first emperor in 210 B.C. and a civil war, the Han dynasty reunited China. The borders set by the Qin and kept by the Han roughly outline China even today. The Western Han capital, Chang’an, had palaces, neighborhoods and two busy markets.
Under Emperor Wu (141-87 B.C.), poetry, literature and philosophy flourished. The historian Sima Qian wrote the Historical Records, which set the pattern for later official histories. Emperor Wu made Confucian teaching the basis of good conduct and of schooling. Government officials came from a highly educated class trained in Confucian writings. That system shaped how China was governed for many centuries.
Emperor Wu’s armies expanded the empire into southern China, northern Vietnam and Korea, and gained control of trade routes in Central Asia. Later, the Eastern Han ruled from Luoyang. Envoys arrived from Central Asia and Japan, and in A.D. 166 Chinese records report a visitor sent from the Roman emperor.
Source: The Metropolitan Museum of Art, Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History, Han Dynasty (206 B.C.-220 A.D.) (metmuseum.org)