separate facts, opinions and possible exaggerations in Leo Africanus’s description of Timbuktu, and explain how Songhai’s conquests shaped the city.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Read these two sentences. “The salt cost 80 gold coins.” “The people were exceedingly rich.” Which one could you check with evidence? Why?
Leo Africanus said some of the king's gold plates and scepters weighed 1,300 pounds. What should a historian do with that claim?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Songhai rises. Songhai began as a kingdom around the city of Gao on the Niger River. In 1468, its ruler Sonni Ali conquered Timbuktu. Askia Muhammad, who took power in 1493, expanded the empire and supported Islamic scholars. Songhai became the largest empire in West African history.
Conquest and its results. Songhai’s armies won control of trade cities and the routes between them. The empire grew rich from taxing trade, as Ghana and Mali had. Conquest also brought war captives and hardship for defeated peoples. Much later, in 1591, an invading army from Morocco, armed with guns, defeated Songhai.
Sorting a source. A fact can be checked: a camel-load of salt sold for 80 ducats. An opinion is a judgment: the people were “exceeding rich.” An exaggeration stretches the truth: scepters of 1,300 pounds would be too heavy for anyone to hold.
Worked example 1: sorting. Kai sorts three claims. “Salt came from Tagaza: fact, and UNESCO’s Timbuktu page agrees that salt came from Teghaza. Most stately temple: opinion. 1,300-pound scepters: probably an exaggeration, or a mistake in the translation.”
Worked example 2: what society looked like. DeShawn notes the details about women. He writes, “Women sold food in the market, so they had an important economic role. Servant women were treated differently, which shows that society had ranks.” He adds that the king marrying his daughters to merchants shows how important trade families had become.
Whose eyes? Leo Africanus was an outsider who wrote for readers in Europe. He was impressed by wealth and learning. We use his account, but we test it.
Use the reading and the challenge quotation. Sort each claim as fact, opinion or possible exaggeration.
Write a “Can we trust it?” card for the story map.
Write a short card for visitors about Leo Africanus. Include one fact we can trust, one opinion, one possible exaggeration, and one sentence about how Songhai's conquest shaped Timbuktu.
Even eyewitnesses need checking. Next time we follow something no one wanted to trade: a deadly disease.
Exit ticket: how is checking an old travel account like checking a post you see online today?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 9, mini lesson 9, sorting practice 11, card 6.
Accuracy: Leo Africanus (al-Hasan al-Wazzan, born in Granada, raised in Fez) visited Timbuktu around 1510-1513; his book appeared in Italian in 1550 and in Pory’s English in 1600. Sonni Ali’s capture of Timbuktu (1468), Askia Muhammad’s rise (1493) and the Moroccan victory at Tondibi (1591) are basic established history. The challenge quotation is copied exactly from the Boston University page, including “kings” without an apostrophe. “Maidservants” may include enslaved women; say “servant women” and explain that some were likely enslaved.
Likely misconceptions: that an eyewitness is always right; that one exaggeration makes the whole source false.
Supports: three-color highlighters for fact, opinion, exaggeration. Stretch: compare Leo Africanus’s view of Timbuktu with UNESCO’s (lesson 2.05).
Answer guide: the quotation mixes fact (scholars were paid by the king) with judgment (“great store,” “bountifully”).
Boston University African Studies Center, Kingdom of Songhay: Primary Source Documents · Public domain text (John Pory's 1600 English translation of Leo Africanus, The History and Description of Africa), presented by Boston University's African Studies Center. Retold in our own words; short quotation copied exactly
Leo Africanus was a traveler from North Africa. Early in the 1500s he visited Timbuktu, which was then part of the Songhai Empire, and later wrote about it. The page uses an English translation printed in 1600, so the spelling is old-fashioned.
He describes a grand stone temple, meaning a mosque, and a palace built by a skilled worker from Granada in Spain. There were many shops of craftspeople and merchants, especially weavers of linen and cotton cloth. Merchants from North Africa brought cloth from Europe.
He says that women of the region, except servant women, covered their faces and sold food. The people, especially foreigners living there, were very rich. The king had married his two daughters to two rich merchants.
Grain, cattle, milk and butter were plentiful, but salt was scarce. It came from Tagaza, about 500 miles away, and he saw one camel-load sold for 80 ducats, a gold coin. He claims the king had gold plates and scepters, some weighing 1,300 pounds, and 3,000 horsemen.
He also describes many doctors, judges, priests and learned men paid by the king, and says handwritten books from North Africa sold for more than any other goods.
“Here are great store of doctors, judges, priests and other learned men, that are bountifully maintained at the kings cost and charges.” (Leo Africanus, English translation of 1600)
Source: Boston University African Studies Center, Kingdom of Songhay: Primary Source Documents (bu.edu)