show what I have learned about trade routes before 1500, the people and places they connected, the economics of trade and how historians research.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Take a slow breath. You have worked like historians, geographers and economists for weeks. Read the passage first. It is about a place in the Americas, and you will use it as evidence on the checkpoint.
How confident are you that you can I am ready to use evidence from the reading and from our unit.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
How the checkpoint works. Part A has short questions. Part B asks you to explain your thinking in two to four sentences with evidence. Use the reading, your story map panel and your notes from the whole unit.
Strong answers have three parts. Make a clear claim, give specific evidence and explain how the evidence supports the claim. Name sources when you can.
Worked example 1: Andre’s evidence sentence. Question: How did people at Chaco adjust to their environment? Andre writes: “Chaco had little rain and short growing seasons, so people may have shared food across the region when the climate failed. The Park Service lists this as an open question, so I say ‘may have.’”
Worked example 2: Chloe’s economics answer. Question: Why might macaws come from far away? Chloe writes: “Macaws do not live in the high desert. Raising them there would cost much more than trading for them, so they came from distant lands, if the trade happened as researchers think.”
Take your time. Read each question twice. If you are stuck, move on and come back. Careful thinking matters more than speed.
Part A. Choose the best answer.
Part B. Answer each question in 2 to 4 sentences with evidence.
1. Using the reading, explain how people at Chaco depended on or adjusted to their environment. Then describe one way people on our routes earned a living, and explain why that work grew up near a resource.
2. Choose one claim from the unit that is a legend or uncertain (for example, Ibn Majid and da Gama, or Mansa Musa as the richest person ever). Explain how you separated fact from legend and what conclusion the sources support.
3. Explain how one belief or religion spread along a trade route, and how trade or a new invention changed where or how people lived.
4. Describe how women's roles or the structure of society differed in one place on our routes. Name the source and whether it is primary or secondary.
5. Explain one cause and one effect of the Mongol conquests, and one way trade routes or alliances helped groups cooperate.
6. Explain how specialization made two places interdependent, and trace how goods, services and resources flowed between them.
7. Name two forms of payment used before 1500, and explain why a traveler must exchange currency to buy goods in another country.
8. Explain why a government might tax or limit trade, using Ghana's salt tax or the Ming limits on sea trade, and explain how taxes on spices passing through Egypt and Venice caused rivalry between regions.
Look back through your answers. Add evidence wherever you can.
Which answer best shows your growth as a historian? Why?
How confident are you that you can I can explain how trade routes connected people before 1500 and who benefited.
Pacing: reading 6 minutes, directions and examples 4, Part A 10, Part B 17, closure 3. Allow extended time; Part B may be split across two sittings.
Evidence map: Part A: opinion 8.1.6.C:1a; Cairo result 8.1.6.C:2a; research question 8.1.6.D:1a; primary source 8.1.6.D:2a; cacao 6.1.6-8.M:1a; exchange 6.4.6-8.B:1a; spice taxes 6.1.6-8.K:2a. Part B: Q1 7.4.6.A:1a, 7.3.6.D:1a, 7.3.6.D:2a; Q2 8.1.6.D:3a and 8.1.6.C:1a; Q3 8.4.6.C:1a and 8.4.6.C:2a; Q4 8.4.6.C:3a and 8.1.6.D:2a; Q5 8.4.6.D:1a and 8.4.6.D:2a; Q6 6.1.6-8.L:1a and 6.2.6-8.A:1a; Q7 6.4.6-8.A:1a and 6.4.6-8.B:1a; Q8 6.1.6-8.K:1a and 6.1.6-8.K:2a.
Supports: read aloud, allow oral responses, provide sentence frames and a blank world map. Chaco is sacred to living Pueblo and Navajo peoples; remind students that descendants are part of this story today.
Answer guide (3 points each): 3 = correct answer, specific evidence and clear reasoning; 2 = correct with limited evidence; 1 = partly correct or unsupported. Q1: little rain and short seasons; roads, trade or possible food sharing; work such as Taghaza salt mining near salt. Q2: names the source and labels the claim. Q3: Islam across the Sahara or Indian Ocean, Buddhism on the Silk Roads; chinampas, caravanserai towns or ports. Q4: Walata’s inheritance through the mother’s brother or respected women (Ibn Battuta, a primary source written by an outsider), or merchants’ rise under the Mongols. Q5: armies and destruction; protected trade and shared knowledge. Q6: silk and horses, salt and gold. Q7: cowries, gold, salt, cacao, coins; local sellers want local currency. Q8: income and control; spice taxes helped Egypt’s rulers and Venice and cost buyers farther west, so Portugal sought a sea route.
National Park Service, Chaco Culture National Historical Park, History and Culture · U.S. government work, public domain
Chaco Canyon, in today’s New Mexico, is high desert with long winters, short growing seasons and little rain. Yet about a thousand years ago it was the center of a thriving ancestral Puebloan culture.
Chacoan culture began in the mid-800s and lasted more than 300 years. Builders planned huge stone Great Houses, some several stories tall with hundreds of rooms. Pueblo Bonito is one of them. Many were lined up with the sun, the moon and the directions.
By 1050, Chaco was the center of ceremony, government and trade for the San Juan Basin. Roads connected its Great Houses to more than 150 others across the region. Pueblo descendants describe Chaco as a gathering place where many peoples and clans shared ceremonies and knowledge. It is also important in the origins of several Navajo clans.
Researchers still ask questions. Was Chaco the hub of a turquoise trade that brought in macaws, copper bells and shells from distant lands? Did it share food when the climate failed? In the 1100s and 1200s, building slowed and people moved and reorganized. Their descendants are today’s Pueblo and other Southwest Native peoples.
Source: National Park Service, Chaco Culture National Historical Park, History and Culture (nps.gov)