use al-Bakri’s account to explain why Ghana’s king taxed and restricted trade, and compare it with a tariff conflict in United States history.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. A bridge charges a toll every time a truck crosses. Who pays the toll? Who might end up paying a little more at the store because of it?
Ghana's king charged a tax on each donkey-load of salt. Do you think he charged more for salt coming in or salt going out?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Taxing the crossroads. A tariff is a tax on goods that cross a border. A quota is a limit on how much of something can be traded. Governments use them to raise money, to protect their own producers, or to control a valuable resource. Ghana’s king did all three in his own way.
Worked example 1: the salt tax (sample numbers). Malik is a made-up trader in our sample problem. He brings 10 donkey-loads of salt into Ghana: 10 loads times 1 dinar is 10 dinars. Later he sends 4 loads onward: 4 loads times 2 dinars is 8 dinars. His total tax is 18 dinars. Charging more on salt leaving the country encouraged traders to sell salt inside Ghana, where people needed it.
The nugget rule. Keeping all nuggets for the king worked like a quota. It limited how much gold reached the market. Al-Bakri’s reason was that too much gold would lose value. We saw that exact effect in Cairo after 1324.
A society in the source. The account also shows how Ghana was organized. Muslim merchants and officials worked beside a king who followed a traditional religion. The throne passed to the son of the king’s sister, which shows that family ties through women mattered.
Worked example 2: taxes on trade can divide regions. Sofia compares Ghana with the spice trade of the 1400s. Pepper and other spices from India and Southeast Asia reached Europe mostly through Egypt, whose rulers taxed them, and then through merchants of Venice, who resold them at high prices. Kingdoms farther west, such as Portugal, paid the most. Portugal looked for a sea route around Africa to get around those taxes and middlemen, and in 1498 Vasco da Gama’s ships reached India. Sofia writes, “A tax on trade helps the region that collects it and costs the regions that pay it, so it can turn trading partners into rivals.”
The big idea. From Ghana to the spice routes, people have argued about who should pay for trade and who should be protected. Historians explain these choices; they do not need to pick a side to understand them.
Use the reading and your notes. Show your math when you calculate.
Write a short comparison for our story map.
Write a paragraph comparing Ghana's salt tax and the taxes on spices that passed through Egypt and Venice. In each case, who gained and who paid more? Use at least one detail from each.
Taxes on trade made Ghana’s king rich and powerful. Next time we follow the gold to Mali and the city of Timbuktu.
Exit ticket: explain the difference between a tariff and a quota in your own words.
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 10, mini lesson 10, guided practice 12, closure 4.
Accuracy: the Boston University page dates al-Bakri’s Book of Routes and Realms to 1057; many sources give 1068. Both fall in the 1000s. The 200,000-soldier figure is his claim from informants and is likely too large; use it in lesson 2.13 as an example to test. The spice-route example (taxes and resale through Mamluk Egypt and Venice, Portugal’s search for a sea route, Vasco da Gama reaching Calicut in 1498) is basic established history; keep it general.
Nonpartisan note: present trade-tax disputes as real disagreements with costs and benefits. Do not connect them to present-day parties or candidates.
Likely misconceptions: that the trader pays the whole tax and buyers never do; that the king’s religion meant Muslims were excluded (they held high offices).
Supports: a two-row tax table (in, out). Stretch: ask why a higher tax on salt leaving might help people in Ghana.
Answer guide: reasons: raise revenue, keep salt in the country, control the gold supply. Spices: Egypt’s rulers and Venetian merchants gained; buyers farther west, such as Portugal, paid more and looked for another route. Quiz math: 6 loads in = 6 dinars.
Boston University African Studies Center, Kingdom of Ghana: Primary Source Documents · Boston University African Studies Center teaching page; excerpted translation from Levtzion and Hopkins, Corpus of Early Arabic Sources (Cambridge University Press, 1981). Retold in our own words, not quoted
Al-Bakri was a Muslim geographer in Spain in the 1000s. He never traveled to West Africa. He gathered information from merchants and other visitors who had.
He described Ghana’s capital as two towns about six miles apart. One was home to Muslim merchants and had twelve mosques, with scholars and teachers. The other was the king’s town, with his court and with sacred groves for the king’s own religion. The king’s interpreters, his treasurer and most of his ministers were Muslims. The next king would be the son of the king’s sister.
The king taxed trade. For every donkey-load of salt brought into the country, he took one gold dinar, a coin. For every load sent out, he took two. Copper and other goods were taxed too.
The best gold came from a town eighteen days’ travel away. Al-Bakri says the king kept every gold nugget for himself and let the people keep only gold dust. Without this rule, he explains, people would collect so much gold that it would lose its value. He also claimed the king could call up an army of 200,000.
Source: Boston University African Studies Center, Kingdom of Ghana: Primary Source Documents (bu.edu)