write a claim-evidence-reasoning paragraph comparing how the Inca and the Aztecs moved goods, using UNESCO’s description of the Qhapaq Nan.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Pittsburgh is famous for hills, rivers and bridges. Think of one way people here have built roads or bridges to deal with the land. Now picture building roads across mountains more than four miles high.
The Inca road network in South America was about how long?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Two empires, two systems. The Aztecs moved many goods through markets, where people bought and sold with cacao, cloth and barter. The Inca state moved much of its goods a different way. People paid the state mainly with labor, called mit’a: farming state fields, building roads, weaving cloth or serving in the army. The state stored food and cloth in storehouses and gave it out to workers, soldiers and people in need.
Records without writing. The Inca kept records on khipu, knotted cords that recorded numbers, such as how much was stored or owed. Runners carried messages in relays along the roads.
Conquest built the road’s reach. In the 1400s, Inca rulers such as Pachacuti expanded the empire quickly by war and by agreements with local leaders. Some peoples resisted. The state sometimes moved whole communities to new places to control them, which matches UNESCO’s note about groups of up to 40,000 people.
Worked example 1: a CER paragraph. Arjun writes: “Claim: The Inca used roads and storage, not markets, to move many goods. Evidence: UNESCO says roadside buildings were used for storage and lodging, and they held food, cloth and military supplies. Reasoning: Storing goods along roads lets a government send them where it wants, instead of letting buyers and sellers decide.”
Worked example 2: a fair comparison. Grace writes, “Both empires collected goods from conquered peoples. The Aztecs took tribute and also had busy markets. The Inca took labor and stored goods.” She shows a similarity and a difference, which is what a strong comparison needs.
Achievements and hardships. The road was an engineering triumph. It also carried armies and forced moves. Our story map should show both.
Use the reading and your notes from lesson 2.09. Work in pairs, then share a claim with the class.
Write a full claim-evidence-reasoning paragraph.
Answer in a CER paragraph: Which empire's system would better reach people in remote mountain villages, the Inca roads and storehouses or the Aztec markets? Use at least one piece of evidence from today and one from lesson 2.09.
Not every economy used markets and money the same way. Next time we compare all the forms of payment on our map.
Exit ticket: explain how the Andes Mountains shaped the way the Inca built their roads.
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 9, mini lesson 9, guided practice 10, CER writing 8.
Accuracy: 30,000 km is about 18,600 miles. Mit’a, khipu, storehouses (qollqa), relay runners (chasqui) and Pachacuti’s expansion from about 1438 are basic established knowledge; the Inca did not use money or large markets the way the Aztecs did, though local exchange existed. Spanish conquest began in 1532, after our period.
Likely misconceptions: that an economy without money is “behind”; that the Inca built every road themselves (UNESCO credits Andean communities over centuries).
Supports: CER frame: “I claim ___. The reading says ___. This shows ___ because ___.” Stretch: add a counterclaim.
Answer guide: strong CER responses cite storage, roads or labor for the Inca and markets or cacao for the Aztecs, and reason about who decides where goods go. Exit ticket: bridges, stairs, ditches and paving solved steep and varied land.
UNESCO World Heritage Centre, Qhapaq Nan, Andean Road System (World Heritage List no. 1459) · UNESCO World Heritage Centre page; the page marks its descriptions CC BY-SA IGO 3.0. Retold in our own words, not quoted
The Qhapaq Nan is the Inca road system of the Andes Mountains in South America. It is a network of roads and buildings covering more than 30,000 kilometers. Andean communities built it over several centuries, and it reached its greatest size in the 1400s, when the Inca state, called Tawantinsuyu, was at its height.
Four main roads began at the central square of Cusco, the capital. Smaller roads branched off and connected towns, farms, workshops and holy places. UNESCO calls the network the lifeline of the empire.
The roads were used by caravans, travelers, messengers and armies, and even by whole groups of people being moved, sometimes up to 40,000 at a time. They crossed snowy peaks more than 6,600 meters high, hot rainforests, fertile valleys and deserts. Builders solved these problems with bridges, stairs, ditches and stone paving.
Buildings along the roads were used for trade, storage and lodging. They show the goods that moved: precious metals, spondylus shell, food, military supplies, feathers, wood, coca leaves and cloth. Today, local communities still care for parts of the road and keep traditions and languages connected to it alive.
Source: UNESCO World Heritage Centre, Qhapaq Nan, Andean Road System (World Heritage List no. 1459) (whc.unesco.org)