put the unit’s events in order, explain what changed and what stayed the same, and locate the places where ideas began, traveled and landed.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Write the numbers 2026 and 431. You just used an idea that traveled from India to Pennsylvania over more than a thousand years. Read how the numerals made that journey.
Which event happened first?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Review lab: you are the experts now. Today the class finishes the Routes of Ideas Map Wall and Timeline, and each of you checks your own understanding before the checkpoint.
Reading B.C. and A.D. As in 1.02, years before year 1 are B.C., and they count down: 431 B.C. is earlier than 130 B.C. Years after are A.D., and they count up. Some books write B.C.E. and C.E. for the same years. To find about how long ago a B.C. event happened, add its date to this year: 431 B.C. was about 2,450 years ago.
Worked example 1: Zara orders the unit. Zara places her cards: Ashoka conquers Kalinga, about 262 B.C.; Han trade opens the Silk Road, 130 B.C.; Cai Lun reports papermaking, A.D. 105; Constantine calls the Council of Nicaea, A.D. 325; Severus Sebokht writes about Indian numerals, A.D. 662; Fibonacci’s book, A.D. 1202; the Second Bank is built in Philadelphia, 1819–1824. She checks that every B.C. card sits left of every A.D. card.
Worked example 2: Luis maps a route. Luis draws the numerals’ route on the world map: India → Baghdad (in today’s Iraq) → Spain → Pisa, Italy. Then on the United States map he locates where classical styles landed: Philadelphia on the Delaware River near the Atlantic coast, Washington, D.C., on the Potomac River, and Pittsburgh on the Appalachian Plateau, where the Allegheny and Monongahela Rivers meet to form the Ohio.
Change and continuity. The numerals’ shapes changed, and so did the way people used them. The core idea, nine signs and zero with place value, stayed. Look for the same pattern in Buddhism, Christianity and classical buildings.
A document as evidence. The Codex Vigilanus is a document that proves the numerals had reached Spain by 976. When we say an idea arrived “by” a date, an artifact like this is our evidence.
Work at the Map Wall and Timeline stations in rotation.
Self-check for the checkpoint.
Write one sentence about what came before and one about what came after the Silk Road opened in 130 B.C., using events from our Timeline.
Explain one thing that changed and one thing that stayed the same in the story of an idea from our unit.
Every number you write is a short trip along the routes of ideas.
How confident are you that you can I am ready to show what I know about time, place and change.
Exit ticket: which skill from today do you want one more practice round on before the checkpoint?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 7, station rotations 16, self-check 6, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: that larger B.C. numbers are later; that Arabic numerals were invented in Arabia; that an idea arrives everywhere at once. The MacTutor page dates the Baghdad visit to 776 and names Caliph al-Mansur, whose reign ended in 775, so we write “the 770s.”
Supports: provide a number line labeled with B.C. and A.D. and a printed outline map of Afro-Eurasia and one of the United States. Flex lesson: regroup students by the skill they missed on the exit tickets from 1.15–1.22. Stretch: calculate how many years passed between Severus Sebokht (662) and Fibonacci (1202): 540 years.
Answer guide: before 130 B.C.: Ashoka’s Kalinga war (about 262 B.C.) or Pericles’ speech (about 431 B.C.); after: Cai Lun (A.D. 105), Nicaea (A.D. 325). Change answers: shapes or new languages; continuity: the place-value system or core beliefs. Maps need three labeled stops in order.
MacTutor History of Mathematics, University of St Andrews, The Arabic numeral system (J J O'Connor and E F Robertson) · CC BY-SA 4.0 (MacTutor, University of St Andrews); retold in our own words
The numerals we write, 1 through 9 plus zero, are often called Arabic numerals, but they began in India. In A.D. 662 a Christian bishop named Severus Sebokht wrote that Indian calculation is done with nine signs. He was impressed by how well it worked.
In the 770s, an Indian visitor brought an astronomy book to the caliph, the ruler, in Baghdad, and it was translated into Arabic. It may have been the work of the Indian mathematician Brahmagupta, written in 628. The scholar al-Khwarizmi later wrote about Indian numerals. His Arabic book is lost, but a Latin translation gave us the word “algorithm.” The oldest surviving Arabic book on the system was written in the mid-900s.
The shapes of the numerals changed as scribes copied them. The idea reached Europe through Spain. The oldest surviving European document with these numerals, the Codex Vigilanus, was copied in Spain in 976. In 1202 Leonardo of Pisa, known as Fibonacci, published a book explaining the system, which he had learned in Bugia in North Africa. Change was slow. Many merchants kept counting on their fingers, and in the 1400s Europe still had not fully switched.
Source: MacTutor History of Mathematics, University of St Andrews, The Arabic numeral system (J J O'Connor and E F Robertson) (mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk)