revise an exhibit panel against our criteria, explaining what an artifact or building teaches and showing both achievements and hardships.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Read about a plaster model that helped bring a Roman temple to Virginia. As you read, ask: what can a model teach a historian that a drawing cannot?
Which Roman building did Clérisseau persuade Jefferson to use as a model?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Revision is re-seeing. Today you look at your panel the way a visitor will. Check it against each criterion, one at a time, and fix what you find.
| Criterion | What it means |
|---|---|
| Accurate | Every claim traces to a named source. Dates use B.C. and A.D. and say “about” when they are estimates. Legends are labeled as legends. |
| Fair | Each society appears with its achievements and its hardships, including slavery and conquest where our sources show them. We include more than one viewpoint. |
| Clear | A neighbor can read it without help. Hard words are explained. |
| Complete | The panel answers six questions: Where did the idea begin? Who shaped it? How did it travel? How did it change? What work and trade helped it spread? Where do we see it today, including in Pennsylvania? |
| Constraints | One panel per team, with a route map, at least two sources, one artifact or document card and an honest note on who was left out or harmed. Main label of 100 words or fewer. No costumes or role-play. No copied text without credit. |
Artifacts teach. Fouquet’s model shows how a Roman temple’s form crossed an ocean and became a guide for builders in Virginia. The paint layers show it was cared for and changed over time. An object card should say what the object is, who made it, when, and what it teaches.
Worked example 1: Jasmine revises for fairness. Her draft says, “Thomas Jefferson loved Roman ideas of liberty and brought them to Virginia.” She remembers our fair criterion. Historians know Jefferson enslaved hundreds of people during his life. She revises: “Jefferson admired ideas of liberty and designed Virginia’s Capitol as a temple to it, yet he enslaved hundreds of people.” The panel now shows a real contradiction.
Worked example 2: Kai revises for accuracy and completeness. Kai’s China panel says, “Women in China could not do anything important.” His evidence from 1.20 says otherwise. He revises: “Han society expected women to obey, yet Ban Zhao completed an official history and argued that girls should be educated.” He also adds the missing “how did it change?” answer.
Check your constraints. Count your main label words (100 or fewer). Make sure every quotation has quotation marks and a credit.
Use the revision checklist on your own panel.
Finish your revisions.
Revise your object or document card so it says what the object is, who made it, when, and what it teaches about the past.
Add or revise one sentence about women's roles or the structure of society connected to your team's idea. Name your source.
Good revision does not erase hard truths. It makes them clear.
Exit ticket: what is the single biggest improvement you made today, and which criterion does it meet?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 8, checklist and guided practice 12, independent revision 11, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that revision means recopying neatly; that fairness means leaving out hard facts; that admiring liberty and enslaving people cannot both be true of one person. That Jefferson enslaved hundreds of people is established knowledge (Monticello’s records count more than 600 over his lifetime); it is not on the Library of Virginia page.
Supports: a printed checklist with one row per criterion; partner read-aloud for clarity. Flex lesson: teams that finish early may extend by adding a second “where we see it today” example from Pennsylvania. Stretch: compare the Second Bank (Greek model) with the Virginia Capitol (Roman model).
Answer guide: object cards need what, who, when and what it teaches. Women’s-roles sentences should cite Ban Zhao, Pericles’ speech or another named source. Exit tickets should name a criterion and a concrete change.
Library of Virginia, Jefferson's Capitol exhibition, Design · Library of Virginia; retold in our own words with a link to the source
In 1785, Thomas Jefferson was the American minister, or official representative, in France. Leaders in Virginia asked him to design a new Capitol for Richmond, on Shockoe Hill above the falls of the James River. Years before, he had sketched a capitol shaped like a giant temple.
Jefferson studied Greek and Roman temples. A famous French draftsman, Charles-Louis Clérisseau, persuaded him to base the design on the Maison Carrée, an ancient Roman temple in Nîmes, France. Jefferson thought of the Capitol as a temple to liberty or justice.
A skilled modelmaker, Jean-Pierre Fouquet, built a plaster model at a scale of one inch to five feet, with iron rods inside for strength. It arrived in Richmond in 1786. Jefferson wrote that a model was “absolutely necessary for the guide of workmen not very expert in their art.” The model guided the builders. Over the years it was repainted many times and now has up to fifteen layers of paint. Jefferson’s drawings were later lent out in 1791 to help plan Washington, D.C.
Source: Library of Virginia, Jefferson's Capitol exhibition, Design (old.lva.virginia.gov)