source a Roman history, compare two points of view about Roman rule, and give and use specific feedback on exhibit drafts.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. In 1.10 we asked who Pericles left out. Today we ask the same question about Rome. When Rome took over Britain, did Britons gain something, lose something, or both? Read a retelling of a Roman history, then decide.
Who wrote the angry speech against Rome that you will read about?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Every source has a point of view. Tacitus was a Roman senator writing about his own family member. He wanted to honor Agricola. Yet he also questioned what Rome did. One source can hold more than one view.
Culture can change under conquest. Latin, the toga, baths and Roman-style towns spread in Britain. That is cultural change, and it shows up in the land: archaeologists still find Roman roads, baths and towns there. But Tacitus reminds us that it came with Roman rule that Britons had not chosen.
Worked example 1: Hana sources the speech. Who? Tacitus, a Roman. When? About A.D. 98, years after the battle. Why? To honor Agricola and to make readers think about empire. Limit: no Briton wrote the speech down. Hana’s card says “words Tacitus gives to Calgacus,” not “Calgacus said.”
Worked example 2: Owen compares two views. Owen writes: “To Agricola, Roman towns, baths and Latin brought Britain into the Roman world. To Calgacus, as Tacitus tells it, Rome brought theft and killing. Both views help visitors see that Roman law and roads came with conquest.” He puts the two views side by side on the Rome panel.
Watch the word “civilisation.” The 1877 translation uses it. Our exhibit does not call one people civilized and another uncivilized. Britons had their own farms, leaders, metalwork and beliefs before Rome arrived.
Gallery critique: kind, specific, helpful. Teams post their drafts. Visitors leave sticky notes in three colors: I notice (a strength), I wonder (a question), and Try this (one specific change linked to a criterion). Feedback is about the work, never the person.
Practice sourcing and comparing before the gallery walk.
Respond to your feedback.
Read the notes on your panel. Choose the two most useful Try this notes. Write the change you will make for each and why.
Write two sentences for your panel that show two different points of view about your team's idea, such as who gained from it and who was left out or harmed. Name a source for each.
Rome spread law, roads and Latin. Our job is to show visitors what that meant to the people who lived under it.
Exit ticket: what is the most important change your team will make before Prove It, and which criterion does it serve?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 8 minutes, mini lecture 7, career note 2, guided practice 7, gallery walk 12, response 4.
Likely misconceptions: that Calgacus’ speech is a word-for-word record; that Roman culture simply replaced British culture; that critique means criticism of a person. The Fordham page gives Tacitus’ text (chapters 21 and 30) and dates the work about A.D. 98. That historians think Tacitus composed the speech is established knowledge, as is the archaeology of Roman Britain. The challenge quotation is copied exactly from the Fordham page.
Supports: model one note of each color before the walk. Provide sentence stems. Address the translation’s word “civilisation” directly so students do not adopt civilized-versus-uncivilized framing. No role-play of Romans or Britons. Stretch: compare this source with Pericles’ speech from 1.10. Who is left out of each?
Answer guide: Try this notes should be specific and tied to a criterion (for example, “Add B.C. to your date” for accurate). Two-viewpoint sentences should name each perspective and cite a source. Career facts come from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Occupational Outlook Handbook page on archivists, curators and museum workers.
Internet Ancient History Sourcebook, Fordham University, Tacitus: The Life of Cnaeus Julius Agricola (trans. Church and Brodribb) · 1877 translation in the public domain; Fordham permits educational copying with credit
Tacitus was a Roman historian. Around A.D. 98 he wrote a short life of his father-in-law, Agricola, a Roman officer who later governed the province of Britain. A province was a region ruled by Rome.
Tacitus says Agricola encouraged the Britons to build temples, courts and houses, and had the sons of British leaders taught Roman learning. Soon, Tacitus says, Britons wanted to speak Latin well and began to wear the toga, Roman formal clothing. They enjoyed Roman baths and fancy banquets. Tacitus then adds a sharp comment: the Britons called this progress, but it was really part of their loss of freedom.
Later, Tacitus describes a battle in northern Britain. Before it, he writes, a British leader named Calgacus gave a speech. In it, Calgacus says the Romans rob and kill, call it empire, and leave the land empty, then call that peace. The speech also says Britons’ children were taken away to be enslaved elsewhere. Historians think Tacitus wrote these words himself, since no Briton recorded the speech. So a Roman writer gives us both Rome’s view and a strong attack on Rome. We have to ask whose voice we are really hearing.
“To robbery, slaughter, plunder, they give the lying name of empire; they make a solitude and call it peace.” — words Tacitus gives to Calgacus
Source: Internet Ancient History Sourcebook, Fordham University, Tacitus: The Life of Cnaeus Julius Agricola (trans. Church and Brodribb) (sourcebooks.fordham.edu)