compare Pericles’ description of Athenian democracy with evidence about who was excluded, and write a claim with evidence and reasoning.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A team captain gives a speech after a hard season: “Our team is the best, and everyone gets a fair chance.” A player who sat on the bench all year hears it. Would they agree? Why might the captain say it anyway?
A leader gives a speech praising his city at a funeral for soldiers killed in war. What kind of picture will he paint?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Two kinds of evidence. Today we compare a proud speech with evidence about who was left out. Both are true in different ways. Our job is to decide how a museum label can be honest about both.
| Source | What it says |
|---|---|
| Pericles’ Funeral Oration (reported by Thucydides) | Power belongs to the many; equal justice; ability matters more than class; poverty is no bar. |
| Met, The Art of Classical Greece | All adult male citizens took part in the assembly. |
| Met, Women in Classical Greece | A young woman in Classical Athens lacked any rights of citizenship. |
| Carlos Museum, Emory University | About 80,000 to 100,000 people, about one in four, were enslaved in Athens, 450-320 B.C. |
Read the words closely. Pericles keeps saying a man. He is speaking about male citizens. His “many” is many compared with rule by a few nobles, not everyone who lived in Athens.
Worked example 1: a one-sided answer. Zoe writes, “Athens gave equal justice to all, because Pericles said so.” She trusted one source and ignored its purpose and the other evidence.
Worked example 2: a balanced answer. Luis writes, “Claim: Athens shared power more widely than most states of its time, but its democracy left out most residents. Evidence: Pericles says power belongs to the many, yet the Met says women had no citizenship rights, and the Carlos Museum estimates one in four people were enslaved. Reasoning: a funeral speech was meant to inspire pride, so it highlights strengths; other sources show who was not included.”
Point of view is not lying. Pericles may have believed every word. A source can be sincere and still leave people out.
Use the reading and the table. Check each answer against the sources.
Write your own response.
Write a claim, evidence and reasoning paragraph: Should our exhibit quote Pericles' words “called a democracy”? Use at least two sources, and write the label sentence you would put beside the quotation.
We compared a leader’s proud words with the people his words left out. Next we compare four governments: Athens, Rome, the Maurya and the Han.
Exit ticket: how did knowing the speech's purpose change how you read it?
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 10, mini lesson 8, practice 7, writing 10.
Sources checked: Fordham Internet Ancient History Sourcebook, Pericles’ Funeral Oration; Met, The Art of Classical Greece; Met, Women in Classical Greece; Michael C. Carlos Museum, Confronting Slavery in the Classical World.
Accuracy: the Fordham page does not name its translator; the wording matches Richard Crawley’s 1874 translation, which is public domain. Thucydides says he reports speeches as closely as he could, so treat it as his version. The speech dates to the winter after the war’s first year, 431/430 B.C.
Supports: highlight “a man” in the excerpt; CER frame. Stretch: compare Pericles’ “pattern to others” with how later democracies used Athens as a model.
Answer guide: accept answers that quote the speech with context, such as “Pericles praised Athens as a democracy run by the many; at the time, only adult male citizens could vote.” Responses should name the speech’s purpose and corroborate with at least one other source.
Fordham University, Internet Ancient History Sourcebook, Pericles' Funeral Oration from Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War, Book 2.34-46 · Classic English translation (Crawley, 1874), public domain; electronic text copyright Paul Halsall, copying permitted for educational use
Thucydides was an Athenian who lived from about 460 to about 400 B.C. He wrote a history of the Peloponnesian War between Athens and Sparta. In it, he reports the speech Pericles gave at a public funeral for Athenians killed in the war’s first year. Thucydides wrote the speech in his own words, based on what he remembered or learned, so it is not an exact recording.
In the speech, Pericles says Athens does not copy other states’ laws; instead, others copy Athens. He says power is in the hands of the many, not the few, and that is why it is called a democracy. He claims the laws give equal justice to all in private disputes. He says a man can rise in public life because of his ability, not his social class, and that being poor does not stop a man who can serve.
Pericles also praises the freedom of daily life in Athens, its festivals and its beautiful homes. He asks citizens to respect officials and the laws, including unwritten rules of right and wrong.
“Its administration favours the many instead of the few; this is why it is called a democracy.”
Source: Fordham University, Internet Ancient History Sourcebook, Pericles' Funeral Oration from Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War, Book 2.34-46 (sourcebooks.fordham.edu)