The Trade Routes Story Map
How did trade routes across the Sahara, the Silk Roads, the Indian Ocean and the Americas connect people before 1500, and who benefited?
The mystery: Mansa Musa, the ruler of Mali, traveled to Mecca in 1324 with so much gold that people wrote about it for centuries. How did a West African empire become so rich?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
analyze how European mapmakers pictured Mansa Musa, separate accurate information from inaccurate images, and sort our questions by trade network.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Think of a map in a video game or a theme park. Does it show everything exactly as it is? What does it make bigger or more exciting?
A mapmaker on the island of Majorca drew Mansa Musa in 1375. Had the mapmaker probably met him?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Maps are sources too. A map is made by a person, at a time, for a reason. The Catalan Atlas was a costly, hand-painted book of charts. It showed what its maker believed about the world, based on reports from sailors and merchants.
Four networks on our story map. We will study four great trade networks before 1500: (1) the trans-Saharan routes linking West Africa and North Africa, (2) the Silk Roads across Asia, (3) the Indian Ocean routes linking East Africa, Arabia, India and China, and (4) the networks of the Americas, including the Maya, the Aztec capital Tenochtitlan and the Inca roads.
Fact, opinion and inaccuracy. A fact can be checked with evidence. An opinion is a belief or judgment, such as “the noblest ruler.” An inaccuracy is something that is simply wrong, like drawing a West African king as a European.
Worked example 1: sorting a caption. Mei reads the 1529 caption. She sorts it: “Salt was traded for gold: fact, supported by other sources. He is no less wise than powerful: opinion. The white-skinned picture: inaccurate.” One source can contain all three.
Worked example 2: what the map tells us anyway. Tyler says the maps are useless because of the mistakes. Fatima disagrees. She writes, “Even with mistakes, these maps prove that Europeans in the 1300s knew Mali was rich in gold. That tells us trade news traveled far.” A flawed source can still be evidence about its maker.
Cooperation along the routes. No one could cross a desert or an ocean alone. Rulers, merchants, guides and sailors from many lands had to cooperate, and rulers made agreements to keep roads and ports safe. Watch for that cooperation, and for conflict, in every network.
Use the reading. Then sort our Wonder Board into the four networks.
Begin your story map planning sheet.
Make a T-chart for the Catalan Atlas: “What it shows accurately” and “What it shows inaccurately or as opinion.” List at least two items in each column.
Our visitors will see a copy of the Catalan Atlas on our story map. Write a two-sentence caption that tells them who made it and why it matters.
We have four networks to explore. Next time we cross the Sahara and meet the empire of Ghana.
Exit ticket: can a source with mistakes still be useful evidence? Explain with one example from today.
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 10, mini lesson 8, guided practice and Wonder Board sort 13, closure 5.
Image: project the Catalan Atlas detail of Mansa Musa (Paris, Bibliotheque nationale de France, MS. Espagnol 30) if available. Do not mock the inaccurate 1529 image; discuss why a European artist might picture a ruler as European.
Likely misconceptions: that a source with errors is worthless; that “old” means “true”; that the mapmaker visited Mali.
Supports: color-code the caption sort (green fact, yellow opinion, red inaccurate). Stretch: ask what the Catalan Atlas suggests about who Majorcan mapmakers talked to.
Answer guide: accurate: gold in Mali, salt traded for gold, tibr (gold dust), camels and caravans. Inaccurate or opinion: white-skinned portrait, “noblest” and “richest” as judgments. Exit tickets should say that flawed sources still show what people believed.
British Library, Medieval Manuscripts blog, African kings on medieval and Renaissance maps · Copyright British Library Board; no reuse license stated for the text. Retold in our own words, not quoted
The British Library explains that Mansa Musa ruled the empire of Mali from about 1312 to 1337. His 1324 pilgrimage brought so much gold into Egypt that its price stayed low there for years. Stories of this ruler impressed people in Europe, and mapmakers began to draw him on fancy, illustrated maps.
The oldest surviving example is the Catalan Atlas of 1375. It is credited to Abraham Cresques, a Jewish mapmaker on the island of Majorca. It shows Musa on a throne with a gold crown and a scepter, holding a round gold object. Its caption calls him the richest and noblest ruler of the region because of the gold in his lands.
Later maps copied the idea. A map made in Italy around 1529 shows Musa with white skin and European clothes, which is not accurate. Yet its caption holds real information. It uses tibr, an Arabic word for gold dust, and it names salt as one of the main goods traded for gold. A later map from Sicily shows camels and riders near a Black ruler holding gold rings, a hint at the caravan trade.
These maps show both what Europeans knew and what they imagined.
Source: British Library, Medieval Manuscripts blog, African kings on medieval and Renaissance maps (bl.uk)