explain the causes and results of the Black Death’s spread along trade routes and write a claim about who benefited from the crossroads and who paid the cost.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. In 2020, a new disease spread around the world in months. What helped it travel so fast? Could something similar have happened before airplanes?
Scientists studied gravestones and DNA from teeth to find where the Black Death began. Where did the evidence point?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
An unwanted traveler. Trade routes carried goods, ideas and faiths. They also carried disease. Fleas on rats and other animals rode with caravans and ships, and sick travelers carried infection from town to town.
The path. From Central Asia, plague moved west along Silk Road routes. By 1346 it struck the trading port of Caffa on the Black Sea. In 1347 ships carried it to Sicily, Constantinople and Egypt. Cairo, the city that welcomed Mansa Musa, lost a huge share of its people. Plague also spread through North Africa and Southwest Asia.
Worked example 1: a cause-and-effect chain. Liam builds a chain: “Traders and animals moved along connected routes, so the disease spread quickly from Central Asia to Europe and Africa. Many workers died, so in parts of Europe surviving workers could demand higher pay.” Each link uses so to show cause and result.
Worked example 2: hypothesis or proof? Sofia notices the word suggest. She writes, “The DNA and dated gravestones are strong evidence about where an early outbreak happened. That it spread from there along trade routes is the scientists’ best explanation, a hypothesis that fits the evidence.”
A look ahead. After 1492, ships crossing the Atlantic carried diseases such as smallpox to the Americas, where Native peoples had no immunity. Millions died. Connection could bring both exchange and disaster.
Making sense of the crossroads. We have now studied four networks. Rulers who taxed trade, merchants and many city dwellers benefited. Miners, carriers, conquered peoples and enslaved people often paid the cost. Your claim today becomes the main message of our story map.
Use the reading and your notes from the whole unit so far.
Write the main message for our story map.
Answer our driving question in a CER paragraph: Who benefited from the trade routes before 1500, and who paid the cost? Use evidence from at least three different networks we studied.
Choose one group whose viewpoint we have heard least, such as miners, camel drivers or enslaved people. What question would you ask a source to hear their side?
Part 1 is done. We have evidence from four networks. In Part 2 each team will build one route panel (Across the Sahara, the Silk Roads, the Indian Ocean or the Americas) for our community night, and the class will judge every panel as accurate, fair, clear and complete.
Exit ticket: name one good thing and one harmful thing that traveled the crossroads. Which should visitors remember most, and why?
Pacing: Do Now 4 min, reading 9, mini lesson 9, guided practice 10, CER 8.
Accuracy: the article reports the 2022 Nature study (Spyrou and others). The researchers’ claim that this was the origin is strong but not final; some scientists say the question is not settled. Caffa (1346), the 1347 arrivals and higher wages for surviving workers in parts of Europe are basic established knowledge. Smallpox in the Americas after 1492 is a preview of a later course.
Care: some students lost family members during COVID-19. Keep the Do Now general and let students pass.
Likely misconceptions: that the Black Death hit only Europe; that the plague was caused by bad air (people believed this then).
Supports: a chain organizer with four boxes. Stretch: a counterclaim about whether ordinary farmers benefited from trade.
Answer guide: strong CER answers cite at least three networks, such as Ghana’s taxes, Kilwa’s wealth, the Swahili trade in enslaved people, Inca labor or the plague, and weigh both benefits and costs.
Smithsonian Magazine, Where Did the Black Death Start? Thanks to Ancient DNA, Scientists May Have Answers · Copyright Smithsonian Magazine (Smithsonian Institution); no reuse license stated. Facts retold in our own words, not quoted
The Black Death was a deadly outbreak of bubonic plague in the mid-1300s. It swept across Europe and Asia and killed tens of millions of people, including an estimated 30 to 50 percent of Europe’s population. Victims had painful swellings, fevers and dark spots on the body.
For a long time, no one knew where it began. In 2022, researchers published a study in the journal Nature. They studied a medieval cemetery near Lake Issyk Kul, in the foothills of the Tian Shan mountains in today’s northern Kyrgyzstan. Gravestones there were dated 1338 and 1339 and said people died of “pestilence,” an old word for a deadly disease. That was seven or eight years before the plague reached Europe.
Scientists tested DNA from the teeth of three women buried there. They found an ancient form of the bacterium that causes plague. Fleas on marmots, a kind of large ground squirrel, carry a related strain in the area today, so the team thinks marmots may have passed it to people. The researchers suggest the disease then spread to Europe along trade routes.
Today, plague is rare and can be treated with antibiotics.
Source: Smithsonian Magazine, Where Did the Black Death Start? Thanks to Ancient DNA, Scientists May Have Answers (smithsonianmag.com)