revise my route panel against our criteria, adding evidence about how society and women’s roles varied along the routes and checking each claim with sources.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Look at your panel. Whose voices are missing? Most panels so far talk about kings and merchants. Read what Ibn Battuta saw in the trading town of Walata, and notice what surprised him.
In Walata, who did Ibn Battuta say were a person's heirs?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Revision is where good becomes great. Today every team revises its panel using critique notes, review-lab notes and one new source. We check each card against our four criteria: accurate, fair, clear and complete.
Societies were organized differently. In Walata, family lines and inheritance passed through the mother’s brother. Women were respected and moved freely in public. Under Mongol rule in China, merchants rose in status. In Tenochtitlan, craftspeople worked in organized city sections. Trade routes linked societies with very different structures.
Source the outsider. Ibn Battuta’s account is a primary source, but he was a visitor who judged Walata by the customs of his own home. His shock tells us that women’s roles there differed from what he expected. It does not mean the people of Walata were wrong. A fair panel says whose eyes we are seeing through.
Worked example 1: Ryan revises a card. Ryan’s old card said, “Walata was a desert town where merchants traded.” His revision adds: “Family lines passed through the mother’s brother, and women were highly respected. (Ibn Battuta, a Moroccan visitor, 1352.)” Now the card is more complete and shows its viewpoint.
Worked example 2: Mia checks payment. Mia’s Sahara panel said people paid only with gold. Her new evidence shows salt pieces and cowrie shells used as money too. She revises the How People Paid card and lists both sources.
Revision checklist. Every claim has a source. Every estimate says “about.” Legends are labelled. At least two viewpoints appear. Each stop card is 60 words or fewer. No people are drawn as cargo or game pieces.
Use the reading and the revision checklist.
Finish your revisions.
Write or revise a Daily Life card for your route that describes women's roles or how society was organized in one place. Name the source and its viewpoint.
List every source on your panel. Mark each primary or secondary, and check that each claim has at least one.
A map that includes more voices tells a truer story.
Exit ticket: what is the most important change your team made today, and which criterion did it improve?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 7 minutes, mini lecture 7, guided practice 9, team revision 15, closure 2.
Likely misconceptions: that one society’s customs are the normal ones; that an eyewitness is always neutral; that revising means recopying. Tracing families through the mother’s side is called matrilineal descent.
Source note: omit passages of the original that rely on outdated or offensive language. The retelling keeps Ibn Battuta’s reactions only where they help students source his viewpoint.
Supports: print the revision checklist. Pair teams to swap one card each. This is a flex revision lesson.
Answer guide: Daily Life cards should describe a role or structure (inheritance through the mother’s brother, respected women, merchants’ rising status, craft sections) and name the source’s viewpoint. Source lists should show at least one primary and one secondary source.
Internet Medieval Sourcebook (Fordham University), Ibn Battuta: Travels in Asia and Africa 1325-1354, translated by H. A. R. Gibb (1929) · Copying permitted for educational and personal use (Fordham Internet History Sourcebooks). Retold in our own words with a link to the source
In 1352 Ibn Battuta reached Walata, the northernmost province of the Mali Empire, after two months of travel from Sijilmasa. Merchants left their goods in an open square, where local people guarded them, and then met the sultan’s deputy.
Ibn Battuta described how families were organized. People there traced their family line through the mother’s brother, not the father. A man’s heirs were his sister’s sons, not his own sons.
He was surprised by women’s roles. He wrote that women in Walata were shown more respect than men and did not veil their faces. Women and men had friends outside their own families. Ibn Battuta, a scholar from Morocco, found these customs shocking. His reaction tells us about his own beliefs as well as about the people he met.
He also praised the safety of the land. He wrote that there was complete security in the country, and that travelers did not need to fear robbers. Farther east, at Gao, and in the city of Mali, people bought and sold with cowrie shells.
Source: Internet Medieval Sourcebook (Fordham University), Ibn Battuta: Travels in Asia and Africa 1325-1354, translated by H. A. R. Gibb (1929) (sourcebooks.fordham.edu)