
quote verse correctly with line breaks and act-scene-line citation, and write about a playwright’s choice rather than about a character as though they were a person.
Instruction
Writing about drama has its own conventions, and getting them wrong is the fastest way to look as though you have not read a play before. There are three to learn, and one habit of mind that matters more than all of them.
1. Quoting verse. Shakespeare wrote in lines, and the line breaks are part of the meaning — a thought that runs past a line ending feels different from one that stops at it. So you preserve them.
- Fewer than four lines: run it into your sentence and mark the line breaks with a slash, with a space on each side. Macbeth admits he has “no spur / To prick the sides of my intent, but only / Vaulting ambition” (1.7.25-27).
- Four lines or more: set it as a block quotation, indented, with the line breaks preserved as written and no quotation marks.
2. Citing. Act, scene and line, in arabic numerals separated by periods: (1.7.25-27). Not page numbers — editions differ. Name your edition once in the Works Cited entry and cite by line thereafter. If a line number is missing from your edition, say so in a note rather than inventing one.
3. Naming the speaker, not the author, for spoken words. Shakespeare says life is a walking shadow is wrong: Macbeth says it, in Act V, after his wife’s death, in a state the play has spent five acts producing. Attributing a character’s despair to the playwright erases the entire structure that made the despair mean something.
And now the habit of mind. The most common weakness in essays about drama is writing about characters as though they were people whose motives could be investigated. “Macbeth was probably traumatized by the battle” is not a claim about a play; there is no evidence about the character outside the words on the page, because the character is made of those words.
The fix is a small grammatical move with a large effect: make Shakespeare the subject of your analytical sentences.
- Character-as-person: Macbeth feels guilty after the murder, which shows he still has a conscience.
- Playwright’s choice: Shakespeare gives Macbeth the play’s most self-aware language at the moment he is least defensible, which keeps the audience inside a mind they are also being asked to judge.
The second sentence can be argued about, evidenced, and disagreed with. The first cannot, because it is a guess about a person who does not exist.
What you submit today is Stage 1 of the key assignment: a thesis about whether the play presents Macbeth’s fall as chosen or determined, five quotations formatted correctly, and four topic sentences of which at least three take Shakespeare as their subject. Expect your thesis to move — the dagger soliloquy and the Act I persuasion scene pull in opposite directions, and finding that out now is better than finding it out at Stage 3.
📖 Before this lesson, read: Macbeth, Acts 3-4
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reading: Writing about drama: a mentor paragraph, verse-quotation practice with a key, and a model organizer
William Hazlitt, Characters of Shakespear’s Plays (1817), via Project Gutenberg #5085; William Shakespeare, Macbeth (Globe text, 1864), via Open Source Shakespeare; retrieved 26 September 2026; Macbeth full text (Globe edition): https://www.opensourceshakespeare.org/views/plays/play_view.php?WorkID=macbeth&Scope=entire&pleasewait=1&msg=pl; retrieved 26 September 2026 · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Hazlitt, 1817; Shakespeare, 1864 text)
Read the mentor passages for the grammar of the sentences before the rules. Then do the practice set before you look at the key.
This workshop has four parts: a mentor paragraph from a public-domain critic, the rules for quoting verse with a set to practice on, a model of the Stage 1 organizer, and the criteria the organizer is scored against. The practice quotations all come from Act I scene vii, lines 1 to 28 (printed in full in Lesson 1.1), so the line numbers are checked and you can copy the format exactly. The text is the Globe edition (Clark and Wright, 1864).
1. A mentor paragraph, and a contrast
William Hazlitt, Characters of Shakespear’s Plays (1817), writing about Macbeth. In the first passage Hazlitt makes the playwright the subject of his sentences:
Shakespeare excelled in the openings of his plays: that of Macbeth is the most striking of any. The wildness of the scenery, the sudden shifting of the situations and characters, the bustle, the expectations excited, are equally extraordinary. … the mind is prepared for all that follows.
Look at the grammar. The subject of the first sentence is Shakespeare; the verb is excelled; and the claim can be argued with (is the opening of Macbeth really the most striking?) and tested against the play. Now the same critic in the other mode, treating Macbeth as a person:
Macbeth himself appears driven along by the violence of his fate like a vessel drifting before a storm: he reels to and fro like a drunken man; he staggers under the weight of his own purposes and the suggestions of others; he stands at bay with his situation; and from the superstitious awe and breathless suspense into which the communications of the Weird Sisters throw him, is hurried on with daring impatience to verify their predictions, and with impious and bloody hand to tear aside the veil which hides the uncertainty of the future. He is not equal to the struggle with fate and conscience. He now ‘bends up each corporal instrument to the terrible feat’; at other times his heart misgives him, and he is cowed and abashed by his success. ‘The deed, no less than the attempt, confounds him.’ His mind is assailed by the stings of remorse, and full of ‘preternatural solicitings’.
Hazlitt was writing in 1817, when this was the normal way to write about a play. Modern literary analysis asks for the other habit, for the reason given in the mini-lecture: everything we know about Macbeth is what Shakespeare put on the page, so a claim about what Macbeth feels is really a claim about what the playwright did. Your sentences should make Shakespeare (or the playwright, or the play) the subject.
2. Quoting verse: the three rules with a set to practice
Fewer than four lines: run them in with spaced slashes, and cite act.scene.line. Model, using lines 25 to 27:
Macbeth admits he has “no spur / To prick the sides of my intent, but only / Vaulting ambition” (1.7.25-27).
Four lines or more: a block quotation, indented, with the line breaks kept as printed, no quotation marks, and the citation after the final punctuation. Model, using lines 1 to 5:
If it were done when ’tis done, then ’twere well
It were done quickly: if the assassination
Could trammel up the consequence, and catch
With his surcease success; that but this blow
Might be the be-all and the end-all here,
(1.7.1-5)
Name the speaker, not the author, for spoken words. Macbeth says these lines; Shakespeare wrote them.
Practice set (with the answer key below). Format each of these correctly, with slashes for short quotations and a block for four lines or more. All are from 1.7.
- Lines 3 to 4
- Lines 15 to 17
- Lines 20 to 22
- Lines 6 to 10
- Line 28
Key.
- “Could trammel up the consequence, and catch / With his surcease success; that but this blow” (1.7.3-4)
- “Who should against his murderer shut the door, / Not bear the knife myself. Besides, this Duncan / Hath borne his faculties so meek, hath been” (1.7.15-17)
- “The deep damnation of his taking-off; / And pity, like a naked new-born babe, / Striding the blast, or heaven’s cherubim, horsed” (1.7.20-22)
- A block quotation of five lines, no marks, each on its own line: But here, upon this bank and shoal of time,
We’ld jump the life to come. But in these cases
We still have judgment here; that we but teach
Bloody instructions, which, being taught, return
To plague the inventor: this even-handed justice (1.7.6-10) - “And falls on the other.” (1.7.28)
3. A model Stage 1 organizer (SLS original)
Thesis (Shakespeare as subject): By giving Macbeth the play’s clearest reasons against the murder and then having him act anyway, Shakespeare presents his fall as a choice that the prophecy tempts but does not compel.
Five quotations, formatted, with what each proves:
- “We still have judgment here; that we but teach / Bloody instructions, which, being taught, return” (1.7.8-9), he understands that violence comes back on the one who begins it, so he knows what he risks.
- “To our own lips. He’s here in double trust; / First, as I am his kinsman and his subject, / Strong both against the deed; then, as his host,” (1.7.12-14), he names his duties as kinsman, subject and host, so the choice is not made in ignorance.
- “So clear in his great office, that his virtues / Will plead like angels, trumpet-tongued, against / The deep damnation of his taking-off;” (1.7.18-20), he grants Duncan’s virtue and what the deed would cost him in the world’s eyes.
- “To prick the sides of my intent, but only / Vaulting ambition, which o’erleaps itself” (1.7.26-27), the only motive he can find is ambition, and he calls it a fault.
- “And falls on the other.” (1.7.28), he sees that ambition destroys itself.
One quotation that cuts against the thesis: “Thou marshall’st me the way that I was going;” (2.1, the dagger soliloquy; add the line number from your edition). It suggests he is being led by the vision. Plan: argue that the vision is what Macbeth’s own mind produces after he has already decided, so it shows how he talks himself into the act, not who compels him.
Four topic sentences:
- Shakespeare opens the play’s central soliloquy with a reasoned argument against the murder, so the audience learns that Macbeth knows the price.
- Shakespeare gives Lady Macbeth the plan and the pressure, but keeps the decision in Macbeth’s own hands by having him say he is settled.
- Shakespeare places the dagger after the decision, not before it.
- Macbeth’s later commitment (“I am in blood”) shows a pattern of choosing to go on.
Three of the four take Shakespeare as their subject, which meets the requirement. The fourth takes Macbeth, and needs rewriting for the final essay.
4. A before-and-after revision (SLS original)
| Character as a person | Playwright’s choice |
|---|---|
| Macbeth feels guilty after the murder, which shows he still has a conscience. | Shakespeare gives Macbeth the play’s most self-aware language at the moment he is least defensible, so the audience stays inside a mind it is also asked to judge. |
| Lady Macbeth is a strong woman who pushes her husband because she is ambitious. | Shakespeare puts the plan in Lady Macbeth’s mouth, so the audience sees the crime organized before Macbeth has accepted it. |
| Macbeth is probably afraid of the witches. | Shakespeare opens the play with the witches and lets Macbeth’s first line echo theirs, so the audience hears him already speaking in their words. |
5. Criteria for Stage 1 (what it is scored on)
| Criterion | Not yet | Meets |
|---|---|---|
| Thesis | States a topic or a fact about the plot. | Takes a position on chosen or determined, with Shakespeare as subject and a claimed effect. |
| Quotations | Fewer than five, or the line breaks are lost. | Five quotations, slashes or blocks as the length requires, each cited act.scene.line and followed by a one-line note on what it proves. |
| Counter-quotation | Absent, or a weak scene. | A scene that really pulls against the thesis, with a plan for handling it. |
| Topic sentences | Character as a person; plot order. | Four sentences, at least three with the playwright as subject. |
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which is correctly formatted for a three-line verse quotation run into a sentence?
“Shakespeare says that life is a walking shadow” is an acceptable way to introduce that quotation.
Which sentence is arguable as literary analysis?
Submit Stage 1: (1) your thesis on whether the play presents Macbeth’s fall as chosen or determined, with Shakespeare as the subject of the sentence; (2) five quotations formatted correctly with act-scene-line citations, each with a one-line note on what it proves; (3) one quotation that cuts against your thesis and how you plan to handle it; (4) four topic sentences, at least three taking Shakespeare as their subject.
How confident are you that you can rewrite a sentence about a character into a sentence about a playwright’s choice?
Macbeth, Acts 3-4
Macbeth, Acts 3-4 so far Bridge summary — not the primary text
A recap of what you have already read, written for this course, so the reading check below does not require re-opening every earlier popover.
In Act 3, King Macbeth fears Banquo, whose descendants the witches promised would reign; he hires murderers who kill Banquo but let Fleance escape, and at the royal banquet Banquo’s ghost twice takes Macbeth’s seat, visible only to him, until Lady Macbeth sends the guests away. In Act 4, Macbeth seeks out the witches, whose apparitions warn him against Macduff but promise that no man born of woman can harm him and that he is safe until Birnam Wood comes to Dunsinane; learning that Macduff has fled to England, he has Macduff’s wife and children murdered. In England, Malcolm tests Macduff’s loyalty, the two prepare to invade with an English army, and Macduff learns of his family’s deaths and vows revenge.