
judge whether a presentation’s media element carries information the narration does not, and plan the non-text element of my own capstone so that it does.
Instruction
9-10.SL.2.C contains one word that decides everything: strategic. Not decorative, not supportive — strategic. A media element is strategic when removing it would cost the audience information.
The test, and it is blunt. Play your presentation with your eyes shut. What did you lose? If the answer is nothing, your visuals are wallpaper. Then do it the other way: show the visuals with the sound off. If a viewer can get the structure of your argument, the visual is carrying real load.
Most failed presentation media fails in one of three ways. Bullet-point echo: the slide says what the speaker is saying, so the audience reads ahead and stops listening. Mood image: a photograph that sets a tone and conveys no information. Data dump: a table too dense to read in the time it is on screen, which conveys only that data exists.
What works instead is media doing a job prose is bad at:
- Relationship: a diagram of how two things connect — a comparison matrix, a flow, a map of influences. Prose describes relationships one pair at a time; a diagram shows all of them at once.
- Proportion: a timeline drawn to scale, or Lesson 4.1’s proportion map. “Years compressed into a clause” is a sentence; a bar showing it is an argument.
- Evidence you cannot paraphrase: a page of a manuscript, a recording of a voice, a photograph of the actual object.
The 9-10.RI.3.A / 9-10.RI.1.C half: comparing accounts across media. For this lab, find two accounts of the same material in different mediums — a chapter of the Narrative and a public-domain audio recording of it; a poem on the page and a recorded performance; a documented event in print and in a photograph. Run the three questions from English 9A’s media lab: what does each emphasize, what did each have to add, and what is absent.
Then add one for this unit: what does each medium make it easy to believe? A voice reading Douglass aloud makes the sentences sound like speech, which they were designed to resemble — and that ease is itself an effect worth naming. A photograph makes a moment look inevitable because it excludes everything that might have happened instead.
Deliverable. Post your media plan for the capstone: what non-text element you will use, what information it will carry, and — the part that is scored — what your narration will therefore not have to say. Reply to two classmates: apply the eyes-shut test to their plan and say honestly whether it passes, then suggest one alternative that would carry more. Use the Unit 2 reply structure: summarize the agreement, name the divergence, qualify or justify.
📖 Before this lesson, read: Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, Chapter 10
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reading: Media lab set: two accounts of the Covey fight, a worked comparison, media failures, a proportion bar and a worked plan
Frederick Douglass, Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave (1845), Project Gutenberg #23; Frederick Douglass, My Bondage and My Freedom (1855), Project Gutenberg #202; retrieved 26 September 2026 · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Douglass, 1845 and 1855)
Read both accounts and answer the four questions yourself before you read the worked comparison. The comparison, the proportion bar, the plan and the reply model are written by SLS; the accounts are copied from the sources named.
The lab asks you to judge whether a media element carries information that the narration does not, to compare two accounts of the same material, and to plan the non-text element of your capstone. Below are two accounts of the same event by the same author, a worked comparison, the three ways media most often fails with an example of each, a worked media plan with a proportion bar drawn from real counts, a model reply, and the criteria.
1. Two accounts of one event
Frederick Douglass described his fight with the overseer Covey twice: in the Narrative (1845) and in the longer My Bondage and My Freedom (1855). Here is how each account names what the fight meant.
Account A: the Narrative (1845), Chapter X.
This battle with Mr. Covey was the turning-point in my career as a slave. It rekindled the few expiring embers of freedom, and revived within me a sense of my own manhood. It recalled the departed self-confidence, and inspired me again with a determination to be free. The gratification afforded by the triumph was a full compensation for whatever else might follow, even death itself. He only can understand the deep satisfaction which I experienced, who has himself repelled by force the bloody arm of slavery. I felt as I never felt before. It was a glorious resurrection, from the tomb of slavery, to the heaven of freedom. My long-crushed spirit rose, cowardice departed, bold defiance took its place; and I now resolved that, however long I might remain a slave in form, the day had passed forever when I could be a slave in fact.
Account B: My Bondage and My Freedom (1855).
Well, my dear reader, this battle with Mr. Covey—undignified as it was, and as I fear my narration of it is—was the turning point in my “life as a slave.” It rekindled in my breast the smouldering embers of liberty; it brought up my Baltimore dreams, and revived a sense of my own manhood. I was a changed being after that fight. I was nothing before; I WAS A MAN NOW. It recalled to life my crushed self-respect and my self-confidence, and inspired me with a renewed determination to be A FREEMAN.
Douglass, Narrative (1845), Project Gutenberg eBook #23; Douglass, My Bondage and My Freedom (1855), Project Gutenberg eBook #202; both retrieved 26 September 2026. Both accounts are printed. The method below applies equally to a printed text and a recording of it, or a poem on the page and a performance of it.
2. The comparison, worked (SLS original)
| Question | Account A (1845) | Account B (1855) |
|---|---|---|
| What does it emphasize? | The result as a rekindling of freedom, and a general rule: “He only can understand the deep satisfaction which I experienced, who has himself repelled by force the bloody arm of slavery.” | The change in the man: “I was a changed being after that fight.” |
| What does it add? | A sense of the triumph as complete in itself: it claims “a full compensation for whatever else might follow, even death itself.” | A direct address to the reader (“Well, my dear reader”), an apology for the narration (“undignified as it was, and as I fear my narration of it is”), and a link back to an earlier episode (“it brought up my Baltimore dreams”). |
| What is absent? | Any acknowledgment that the writing might fail the event. | The general rule about who can understand. |
| What does it make easy to believe? | That the fight was a private, inward victory. | That it was the start of a new self, told by someone who is present in the telling and a little embarrassed by it. |
A device that stands in for a voice. Account B prints “I WAS A MAN NOW” in capitals and “A FREEMAN” in capitals. Print has no volume, and capital letters are the printed equivalent of raising one’s voice. A recording would carry this with the voice itself and would need no capitals. A reader of the page has to be told.
3. How media fails, and what works instead (SLS original)
| Failure | Example | Eyes-shut test |
|---|---|---|
| Bullet-point echo | A slide lists the three points the speaker is about to make. | Removing the slide costs nothing; the audience heard the same points. |
| Mood image | A photograph of a nineteenth-century farm while the narrator describes the setting. | Removing it costs a mood and no information. |
| Data dump | A table too dense to read in the time it is on screen. | The audience learns only that data exists. |
| Strategic | A timeline drawn to scale showing that four years of a memoir take one paragraph and one afternoon takes four pages. | Removing it costs information the narration never states in numbers. |
4. A worked media plan (SLS original)
The non-text element. A proportion bar for the Narrative, drawn to scale from the counts in the table below (each block is about 2% of the book).
| Chapter | Share of the book | Bar |
|---|---|---|
| Chapter I | 6% | ███ |
| Chapter II | 6% | ███ |
| Chapter III | 4% | ██ |
| Chapter IV | 4% | ██ |
| Chapter V | 5% | ██ |
| Chapter VI | 4% | ██ |
| Chapter VII | 7% | ███ |
| Chapter VIII | 5% | ██ |
| Chapter IX | 6% | ███ |
| Chapter X | 35% | ██████████████████ |
| Chapter XI | 15% | ███████ |
| Appendix | 5% | ███ |
Counted from the Project Gutenberg text of the Narrative (about 36,170 words for the eleven chapters and the appendix).
The information it carries. That Chapter X alone takes about a third of the book, and that Chapters X and XI together take about half of it.
What the narration therefore does not have to say. The narration does not recite percentages. It says: “Look at Chapter X.” The bar makes the claim that the book is unevenly weighted, and the narration says why.
Eyes-shut test. With the visual removed, the audience loses the fact that the proportions are uneven, which no sentence in the narration states. It passes. With the sound removed, a viewer can read the shape of the book from the bars alone, which shows that the visual carries real load.
5. A reply that follows the structure (SLS original)
The reply to a classmate’s plan has three parts: summarize the agreement, name the divergence, and qualify or justify. It also applies the eyes-shut test and suggests one alternative.
Model. “We agree that a mood photograph would not pass the eyes-shut test. Where I differ is on your choice of a map of the plantation. Removing it costs the audience a picture of where things were, and I could not find a sentence in your narration that states that in words, so I think it passes. But I doubt it carries as much as it could. My suggestion: put the scene and the summary on one timeline, drawn to scale, so the map’s spatial information and the proportion of time are visible together. I would qualify this: if the plantation layout matters to your argument, keep the map. If it does not, the timeline is stronger.”
6. What your plan post needs (criteria, SLS original)
| Part | Meets it when |
|---|---|
| The non-text element | You name it and describe what it shows. |
| The information it carries | You state something the audience learns from the element alone. |
| What the narration will not say | You list at least one thing the narration leaves to the element. This is the scored part. |
| Comparison of two accounts | For two accounts of the same material, you say what each emphasizes, adds and omits, and what each makes easy to believe. |
| Replies | Each of the two replies applies the eyes-shut test, says honestly whether the plan passes, and suggests one alternative that would carry more. |
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which capstone media element is strategic rather than decorative?
Putting your key points on the slides helps the audience follow your argument.
Post your capstone media plan: the non-text element you will use, the information it will carry, and what your narration will therefore not have to say. Then compare your two chosen accounts across mediums — what each emphasizes, adds and omits, and what each makes it easy to believe.
How confident are you that you can apply the eyes-shut test to my own presentation and change a visual that fails it?
Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, Chapter 10
Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, Chapter 10 so far Bridge summary — not the primary text
A recap of what you have already read, written for this course, so the reading check below does not require re-opening every earlier popover.
Chapter 10 is the longest in the book. In Part 1, Douglass spends 1833 with Edward Covey, who works and whips him until he feels “broken in body, soul, and spirit”; after a beating in August and a refused appeal to Thomas Auld, he fights Covey for nearly two hours and is never whipped by him again, calling the fight the turning point of his life in slavery. In Part 2, a year with the milder William Freeland brings a secret Sabbath school and a five-man escape plot for Easter 1835 that is betrayed; after time in jail he is sent back to Baltimore, beaten by white apprentices in a shipyard, and finally learns to caulk, earning wages that he must hand over to Hugh Auld every Saturday.