
produce a 1,000-1,200 word argument on how seminal documents and the Douglass Narrative address a shared theme, and deliver a three-minute public address on that theme for a civic audience.
Instruction
This is the unit’s summative assessment and the third of the semester’s four formal pieces.
The prompt. Choose a theme carried across the unit’s texts — liberty, consent of the governed, equality before the law, or membership in the political community. Argue how two or more seminal U.S. documents and the Douglass Narrative address it, and what changes when a later text takes up an earlier one’s own language.
Requirements. 1,000-1,200 words. A precise claim about the relationship between the texts, not a comparison of their content. A delineation of at least one document’s argument, separating premise from evidence, in your own analytical prose. The shared-premise structure from Lesson 3.7, if it fits your claim — and if it does not, say in a sentence why not. A counterclaim developed fairly with its strength named, and one honest limitation of your own reading. Evidence from at least two seminal documents and the Narrative (the Preface through Chapter 9, the chapters you have read), quoted, embedded and cited in MLA. At least one passage where a document’s stated argument and its historical practice diverge, handled as evidence rather than as accusation. A conclusion that follows from the argument.
The oral component, where 9-10.SL.2.A / 9-10.SL.2.B is assessed. Write and record a three-minute public address on the same theme — not a summary of your essay. The audience is civic: a school board, a town meeting, an assembly. That change of audience makes real demands, and you must meet them: a citation that works on a page does not work aloud, a subordinate clause that a reader can re-read will lose a listener, and a claim that an academic audience will wait for must arrive early for a civic one.
Submit a transcript and a short note naming two specific register decisions the change of audience required — what you changed and what the change cost. A student who prefers not to record may deliver live to the instructor in a scheduled session; both routes earn full credit.
On handling this material. These texts describe enslavement, violence and the legal denial of personhood, and Douglass wrote his account to be read by people who would rather not have read it. Write about it precisely. Precision here means quoting accurately, naming what a text does rather than reaching for the strongest available adjective, and not using a person’s testimony as a device. If any part of this reading is difficult for you to work with, you may build your essay on other passages from the Preface through Chapter 9 instead — the choice is yours and carries no penalty.
Academic honesty. The argument must be yours; the documents and the Narrative are the only texts you may reproduce, marked and cited. Text generated by a language model may not appear in the essay or the address.
📖 Before this lesson, read: Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, Chapters 6-9
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reading: Key assignment set: prompt, located key passages, four-level rubric, model thesis and outline, sample paragraphs and an address
Declaration of Independence (1776), Project Gutenberg #1; Abraham Lincoln, Gettysburg Address (1863), Project Gutenberg #4; Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Declaration of Sentiments (1848), https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Declaration_of_Sentiments; Frederick Douglass, “What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July?” (oration, Rochester, 5 July 1852), https://en.wikisource.org/w/index.php?title=What_to_the_Slave_Is_the_Fourth_of_July%3F&action=render; Frederick Douglass, Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave (1845), Project Gutenberg #23; Roger B. Taney, opinion of the Court, Dred Scott v. Sandford, 60 U.S. 393 (1857), https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/60/393; all retrieved 26 September 2026 · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Declaration, 1776; Stanton, 1848; Lincoln, 1863; Douglass, 1845 and 1852; Taney, 1857)
Use the located passages as your quoting source. The prompt restatement, rubric, thesis, outline, sample paragraphs and address are written by SLS; every quoted passage is copied from the source named.
This assignment refers to key passages, a rubric and a model. This reading puts all of them in one place. First the prompt and its requirements, then the passages you may quote, each with its location in the work so you can cite it, then the rubric at four levels, then a model thesis and outline, sample paragraphs, and a sample opening for the public address with its register note.
1. The prompt
Essay, 1,000 to 1,200 words. Choose a theme carried across the unit’s texts: liberty, consent of the governed, equality before the law, or membership in the political community. Argue how two or more seminal U.S. documents and Frederick Douglass’s Narrative address that theme, and what changes when a later text takes up an earlier one’s own language.
- A precise claim about the relationship between the texts, not a comparison of their content.
- A delineation of at least one document’s argument in your own words, separating premise from evidence.
- The shared-premise structure from Lesson 3.7, if it fits your claim. If it does not, say in a sentence why not.
- A counterclaim developed fairly with its strength named, and one honest limitation of your own reading.
- Evidence from at least two seminal documents and the Narrative, quoted, embedded and cited in MLA.
- At least one passage where a document’s stated argument and its practice diverge, handled as evidence and not as an accusation.
- A conclusion that follows from the argument.
Public address, three minutes. The same theme, for a civic audience. It is not a summary of your essay. Submit a transcript and a register note naming two decisions the civic audience required and what each cost. Live delivery is an equal-credit alternative.
2. Key passages, with their locations
Declaration of Independence (1776). Second paragraph, the premise:
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness. That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed,
Final paragraph, the conclusion:
We, therefore, the Representatives of the United States of America, in General Congress, Assembled, appealing to the Supreme Judge of the world for the rectitude of our intentions, do, in the Name, and by the Authority of the good People of these Colonies, solemnly publish and declare, That these United Colonies are, and of Right ought to be Free and Independent States;
Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Declaration of Sentiments (1848). Second paragraph, the sentence that reuses the premise:
We hold these truths to be self-evident; that all men and women are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness; that to secure these rights governments are instituted, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed.
Abraham Lincoln, Gettysburg Address (1863). First paragraph:
Four score and seven years ago, our fathers brought forth upon this continent a new nation: conceived in liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal.
Last paragraph:
It is for us the living, rather, to be dedicated here to the unfinished work which they who fought here have thus far so nobly advanced. It is rather for us to be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us. . .that from these honored dead we take increased devotion to that cause for which they gave the last full measure of devotion. . . that we here highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain. . . that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom. . . and that government of the people. . .by the people. . .for the people. . . shall not perish from this earth.
Frederick Douglass, “What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July?” (1852). The opening section, in the paragraph beginning “Fellow Citizens, I am not wanting in respect”:
Fellow Citizens, I am not wanting in respect for the fathers of this republic. The signers of the Declaration of Independence were brave men. They were great men too—great enough to give fame to a great age. It does not often happen to a nation to raise, at one time, such a number of truly great men. The point from which I am compelled to view them is not, certainly, the most favorable; and yet I cannot contemplate their great deeds with less than admiration. They were statesmen, patriots and heroes, and for the good they did, and the principles they contended for, I will unite with you to honor their memory.
The paragraph beginning “But, such is not the state of the case”:
The rich inheritance of justice, liberty, prosperity and independence, bequeathed by your fathers, is shared by you, not by me. The sunlight that brought life and healing to you, has brought stripes and death to me. This Fourth July is yours, not mine. You may rejoice, I must mourn.
Under the heading “THE CONSTITUTION,” the paragraph beginning “Now, take the constitution”:
Now, take the constitution according to its plain reading, and I defy the presentation of a single pro-slavery clause in it. On the other hand it will be found to contain principles and purposes, entirely hostile to the existence of slavery.
Douglass, Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave (1845). Chapter VI, Mr. Auld forbids the lessons (the sentence that does not use the slurs):
telling her, among other things, that it was unlawful, as well as unsafe, to teach a slave to read.
Chapter VI, what he understood:
I now understood what had been to me a most perplexing difficulty—to wit, the white man’s power to enslave the black man. It was a grand achievement, and I prized it highly. From that moment, I understood the pathway from slavery to freedom.
Chapter VII, what he said to the white boys who taught him in the street (an appeal to a premise they shared):
“You will be free as soon as you are twenty-one, but I am a slave for life! Have not I as good a right to be free as you have?”
Chapter VIII, the valuation of his old master’s estate:
We were all ranked together at the valuation. Men and women, old and young, married and single, were ranked with horses, sheep, and swine.
Roger B. Taney, Dred Scott v. Sandford (decided 1857), for a counterclaim. The opinion of the Court, paragraph 49:
The general words above quoted would seem to embrace the whole human family, and if they were used in a similar instrument at this day would be so understood. But it is too clear for dispute, that the enslaved African race were not intended to be included, and formed no part of the people who framed and adopted this declaration; for if the language, as understood in that day, would embrace them, the conduct of the distinguished men who framed the Declaration of Independence would have been utterly and flagrantly inconsistent with the principles they asserted; and instead of the sympathy of mankind, to which they so confidently appealed, they would have deserved and received universal rebuke and reprobation.
Sources, all retrieved 26 September 2026: Declaration, Project Gutenberg eBook #1; Gettysburg Address, Project Gutenberg eBook #4 (the transcription there marks pauses with ellipses); Douglass, Narrative, Project Gutenberg eBook #23; Douglass, oration, and Stanton, Declaration of Sentiments, on Wikisource; Taney, Cornell Law School’s Legal Information Institute.
3. The rubric at four levels (SLS original)
| Criterion | 4 Exemplary | 3 Proficient | 2 Developing | 1 Beginning |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claim (9-10.W.2.A) | A precise claim about how the texts relate that could be denied. | A clear claim about the relation, slightly broad. | A claim that compares content. | A topic, not a claim. |
| Delineation (9-10.RI.2.D) | One document’s argument separated into premise and evidence in the writer’s own prose, with the link named. | Premise and evidence separated; link implied. | Summary with the premise named. | Paraphrase. |
| Documents in relation (9-10.RI.3.B / 9-10.RI.3.C) | Shows what changes when the later text takes up the earlier one’s language, with words from both. | Shows a change with words from one text. | Says the texts are related. | Treats the texts separately. |
| Counterclaim and limitation (9-10.W.2.A) | Counterclaim’s strength named and answered; a specific limitation stated without hedging. | Both present; one is general. | Counterclaim is thin or the limitation is a disclaimer. | Missing. |
| Divergence as evidence | The gap between principle and practice is analyzed and used to support the claim. | The gap is noted and used once. | The gap is described as hypocrisy and left there. | Not addressed. |
| Public address (9-10.SL.2.A, 9-10.SL.2.B, 9-10.SL.2.C) | Claim arrives early; language fits a listener; register note names two decisions and their costs; transcript supplied. | Adapted; the note names decisions without costs. | The essay read aloud with light edits. | No adaptation. |
4. A model thesis and outline (SLS original)
Theme: membership in the political community.
Thesis. Each later text treats the Declaration’s premise as a promise it is entitled to collect on: Stanton by changing one phrase, Douglass by granting the premise in full and asking who stands inside it, and Lincoln by converting a self-evident truth into a proposition the nation must prove; the Narrative shows what the absence of the promise looks like from inside a household, in a law that makes teaching a person to read unsafe.
- Delineate the Declaration. Major premise (the second paragraph), evidence (the list of the King’s acts), conclusion (the last paragraph). Note that no evidence is offered for the premise and that the text never uses the words slave or slavery.
- Stanton changes two words and keeps the rest. Compare “all men are created equal” with “all men and women are created equal.” What does the small change accomplish?
- Lincoln changes a status. The Declaration’s truth is “self-evident”; Lincoln’s is a “proposition.”
- Douglass grants the premise. The paragraph about the signers, then the turn to “This Fourth July is yours, not mine.” This is the shared-premise structure.
- Divergence as evidence. The Narrative’s Chapter VI shows the law of a household saying the opposite of the premise. Treat it as evidence of how the premise fails in practice.
- Counterclaim. Taney reads the same words and concludes the enslaved were excluded. Name the strength (conduct is evidence of meaning), then answer it (the argument assumes the authors were consistent).
- Limitation. Say what the reading cannot absorb, for example Chapter VII, where learning to read feels for a time like “a curse rather than a blessing.”
- Conclusion. What the sequence of texts shows about a premise stated in universal terms.
5. Sample paragraphs (SLS original)
Delineation. The Declaration is an argument with three parts. Its major premise is the principle in its second paragraph: that men are equal in their rights, and that a people may alter or abolish a government that destroys them. Its evidence is a list of twenty-seven acts by the King, introduced as “a history of repeated injuries and usurpations,” and offered to prove a design to establish “absolute Tyranny.” Its conclusion is that the colonies are “Free and Independent States.” What links them is the claim that a pattern of abuse, after petitions have failed, justifies separation. Notice that the evidence is offered only for the second premise. The first is called self-evident, and so no evidence is thought to be required.
Divergence handled as evidence. The Narrative does not need to accuse anyone of hypocrisy in order to show that the Declaration’s premise was unapplied. It reports what a master said to his wife: that “it was unlawful, as well as unsafe, to teach a slave to read.” That sentence is data about what the household’s law took a person to be. Douglass then draws the conclusion for himself, in a sentence that names the mechanism: he now understood “the white man’s power to enslave the black man.” The gap between the premise and the practice is where the Narrative starts to argue.
Counterclaim and limitation. The strongest case against this thesis is Taney’s. He argues that the words “would seem to embrace the whole human family,” but that the authors’ conduct shows they did not mean them to. The strength of that argument is that conduct is real evidence of what people mean. The answer is that it needs the authors to have been consistent, and Douglass, Stanton and Lincoln all read the plain words as the promise that the authors’ conduct failed to keep. One thing this reading cannot absorb is Chapter VII of the Narrative, where Douglass admits that learning to read at times felt like “a curse rather than a blessing,” a despair that no argument from a shared premise answers.
6. A sample opening for the address, with its register note (SLS original)
Audience: a school board meeting. Theme: the same as the essay.
Opening. “In 1776 the nation wrote down that all men are created equal. In 1852 Frederick Douglass stood in a hall in Rochester and told his audience that the words were theirs, not his. My claim tonight is simple: the words were never wrong. What was missing was the people who would hold the nation to them. Tonight I want to ask what it takes to be one of those people.”
Register note. Two decisions the audience required. First, I moved the claim to the first two sentences. In the essay it arrives after a delineation of the Declaration, but a listener cannot re-read, and would have lost the thread. The cost is that I lost the setup that made the claim earn its precision. Second, I replaced the citation “(Douglass, ‘What to the Slave’)” with a spoken attribution and reduced the number of quotations from six to two. A citation does not work aloud. The cost is that the evidence is thinner, so I said explicitly that the full quotations are in the essay.
7. Works Cited forms (SLS original, MLA style)
- Douglass, Frederick. Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an American Slave. 1845. Project Gutenberg, ebook 23, gutenberg.org/ebooks/23.
- Douglass, Frederick. “What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July?” 1852. Wikisource, en.wikisource.org.
- “The Declaration of Independence.” 1776. Project Gutenberg, ebook 1, gutenberg.org/ebooks/1.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
premise
Tap to revealA proposition an argument rests on; a self-evident one is asserted rather than evidenced.
delineate
Tap to revealTo lay an argument out as claim, evidence, and the link between them.
shared premise
Tap to revealA proposition both sides accept, from which an argument can proceed without first winning agreement.
periodic sentence
Tap to revealA sentence holding its main clause until the end, building pressure through what precedes it.
verbal irony
Tap to revealSaying the opposite of what is meant, so the judgment forms in the reader.
Adapting your essay’s argument into a three-minute civic address, which change is required by the audience rather than optional?
How confident are you that you can analyze the gap between a document’s stated principle and its practice as evidence rather than as an accusation?
Submit: Seminal Documents Argument Essay (1,000-1,200 words) + Public Address
Prompt: Argue how two or more seminal U.S. documents and the Douglass Narrative address a shared theme, and what changes when the later text takes up the earlier one’s own language.
Stages open in sequence and are scored separately.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Shared-premise organizer. From Lesson 3.7: premise at its strongest, the standard it implies, four cited quotations showing the gap, the counterclaim with its strength named, and one limitation of your own reading.
- Stage 2 — Peer-reviewed rough draft (750+ words). Upload, peer-review two classmates, then submit a revision note naming one specific change and the feedback behind it.
- Stage 3 — Final revised essay (1,000-1,200 words) + Works Cited. MLA, PDF.
- Stage 4 — Recorded public address (3 minutes) + transcript + register note. The note names two decisions the civic audience required and what each cost. Live delivery in a scheduled session is an equal-credit alternative.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Claim (9-10.W.2.A) | Precise claim about the relationship between the texts, not a comparison of their content. |
| Delineation (9-10.RI.2.D) | At least one document’s argument separated into premise and evidence in the writer’s own analytical prose. |
| Documents in relation (9-10.RI.3.B / 9-10.RI.3.C) | Shows what changes when a later text takes up an earlier one’s language, with evidence from both. |
| Counterclaim and limitation (9-10.W.2.A) | Counterclaim’s genuine strength named; one specific limitation of the writer’s own reading stated without hedging. |
| Divergence handled as evidence | The gap between stated principle and practice is analyzed, not used as an accusation that ends the analysis. |
| Public address (9-10.SL.2.A, 9-10.SL.2.B, 9-10.SL.2.C) | Adapted for a civic audience; claim arrives early; register note names two decisions and their cost; transcript supplied. |
Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, Chapters 6-9
Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, Chapters 6-9 so far Bridge summary — not the primary text
A recap of what you have already read, written for this course, so the reading check below does not require re-opening every earlier popover.
In Baltimore, Hugh Auld forbids his wife to teach Douglass to read, and the boy takes his master’s fear as proof that reading is “the pathway from slavery to freedom” (Chapter 6). Over seven years he teaches himself to read and write through lessons from white boys in the street, The Columbian Orator and copied letters, learning the word abolition and resolving to run away (Chapter 7). The valuation of his old master’s estate ranks people with livestock, and his grandmother is abandoned in a hut in the woods (Chapter 8). In Saint Michael’s, Thomas Auld’s conversion makes him crueler, and he hires Douglass out to Edward Covey (Chapter 9).