
integrate and evaluate sources in different forms — essay, protest pamphlet and cartoon — to develop claims and counterclaims, noting where sources disagree.
Instruction
Court opinions are not the only texts that define citizenship. The people the courts ruled about wrote back — in essays, pamphlets, speeches and pictures. Your argument essay must integrate at least two of these voices, including one source in a visual or other non-print form. 11-12.RI.3.A / 11-12.RI.1.C asks you to integrate and evaluate multiple sources presented in different media or formats; 11-12.SL.1.C asks you to evaluate their credibility and accuracy and note discrepancies.
Du Bois, 1903. W. E. B. Du Bois, a Harvard-trained historian and sociologist, published The Souls of Black Folk seven years after Plessy. Its first chapter describes the experience of being treated as “a problem” and names it double-consciousness: seeing oneself through the eyes of a contemptuous world, feeling oneself both American and Black with no way yet to be both fully. The passage is not a legal argument. It is evidence of what the separate-but-equal regime meant from the inside — the very “construction” Justice Brown dismissed as a choice.
Pokagon, 1893. Simon Pokagon, a Potawatomi writer and leader, printed a small booklet on birch bark, The Red Man’s Greeting, for the World’s Columbian Exposition held in Chicago to mark four hundred years since Columbus. In substance (our paraphrase), he declares that his people have no spirit to celebrate: the fair stands on land that was theirs, and the four centuries it honors have brought them loss. The material form is part of the argument: birch bark, a Native writing surface, carries a Native answer into a fair celebrating conquest. Remember that under the law of the time, many Native people were not citizens; Pokagon writes from outside the circle the amendments drew.
Nast, 1871. Thomas Nast, the most influential political cartoonist of the era, drew “The Chinese Question” for Harper’s Weekly: Columbia, the female symbol of the nation, shields a Chinese man from an angry mob, while insults used against Chinese immigrants are posted on the wall behind. Public-domain scans of the cartoon are held in library collections, including the Library of Congress’s. Read it as an argument. What does it claim? Columbia protects the immigrant — but he is shown as passive, rescued rather than speaking. Compare with Wong Kim Ark, who went to court himself.
Evaluating sources in different forms. For each source ask: who made it, for whom, and when? What can this form do that prose cannot (a cartoon persuades at a glance; a birch-bark booklet is itself a symbol)? What can it not do? Where does it disagree with another source, and which is more credible on that point? Nast’s image and the Chinese Exclusion Act, passed eleven years later, disagree sharply about the nation’s attitude: note the discrepancy and explain it rather than ignoring it.
Counterclaims (11-12.W.2.A). Use a source to build your strongest counterclaim, not just your claim. If you argue that the Fourteenth Amendment was steadily enlarged, Du Bois and Pokagon are your counterclaim: from inside, the color line held. Develop it fairly, then answer it.
Cohesion (11-12.W.3.A.d). When you move from a court to a cartoon, your transition must name the relation: What the Court described as a choice, Du Bois describes as a condition.
Reading: Du Bois, Pokagon and Harper, with a worked source-integration table
W. E. B. Du Bois, The Souls of Black Folk (Chicago: A. C. McClurg, 1903), Chapters I and II, Project Gutenberg #408; Simon Pokagon, The Red Man’s Rebuke (Hartford, Mich.: C. H. Engle, 1893), Project Gutenberg #66563; Frances Ellen Watkins Harper (1866), Knowledge for Freedom seminar, Dickinson College. Retrieved 26 September 2026. Fetchable texts: Project Gutenberg #408 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/408); Project Gutenberg #66563 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/66563); https://awpc.cattcenter.iastate.edu/2017/03/21/we-are-all-bound-up-together-may-1866/. · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Du Bois, 1903; Pokagon, 1893; Harper, 1866)
Quotations are exact. The tables, models and transitions are SLS original. The Nast cartoon is described, not reproduced.
Three voices from outside the courts, each in its own form, then a worked source-integration table and a model for moving between them. All quotations are exact.
W. E. B. Du Bois, The Souls of Black Folk (1903)
The problem of the Twentieth Century is the problem of the color-line.
— Du Bois, The Souls of Black Folk, Chapter II
It is a peculiar sensation, this double-consciousness, this sense of always looking at one’s self through the eyes of others, of measuring one’s soul by the tape of a world that looks on in amused contempt and pity. One ever feels his twoness,—an American, a Negro; two souls, two thoughts, two unreconciled strivings; two warring ideals in one dark body, whose dogged strength alone keeps it from being torn asunder.
— Du Bois, The Souls of Black Folk, Chapter I
Simon Pokagon (Potawatomi), The Red Man’s Rebuke (1893), later titled The Red Man’s Greeting
My object in publishing the “Red Man’s Rebuke” on the bark of the white birch tree, is out of loyalty to my own people, and gratitude to the Great Spirit
— Pokagon, opening note “By the Author”; the booklet was printed on birch bark
In behalf of my people, the American Indians, I hereby declare to you, the pale-faced race that has usurped our lands and homes, that we have no spirit to celebrate with you the Great Columbian Fair now being held in this Chicago city, the wonder of the world.
No; sooner would we hold high joy-day over the graves of our departed fathers, than to celebrate our own funeral, the discovery of America.
— Pokagon, 1893
Frances Ellen Watkins Harper, 1866
You white women speak here of rights. I speak of wrongs.
… We are all bound up together in one great bundle of humanity, and society cannot trample on the weakest and feeblest of its members without receiving the curse in its own soul.
— Harper, Eleventh National Woman’s Rights Convention
The visual source
Thomas Nast’s cartoon “The Chinese Question” (Harper’s Weekly, 1871) is held in public-domain collections such as the Library of Congress’s; find and cite the scan you use. Ask of it: who made it, for whom, and what does it claim? Where does the picture speak and where is a person shown as silent? Compare who is speaking in the cartoon with who is speaking in Pokagon’s and Harper’s words.
Worked source-integration table (SLS original)
| Source | Maker and form | Purpose | What the form can do | Discrepancy with another source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Du Bois | Scholar; essay in a book | To describe the inner cost of the color line | Shows how the line is felt, not only how it is enforced | Brown (1896) says the injury is the plaintiff’s “construction”; Du Bois describes it as a condition. |
| Pokagon | Potawatomi writer; birch-bark booklet | To answer a fair that celebrated 1492 | The material is itself a Native answer | Fair boosters treated the exposition as progress; Pokagon calls it “our own funeral.” |
| Harper | Poet and lecturer; speech | To argue that rights cannot be divided | Spoken argument with personal examples | The Fifteenth Amendment protected race but not sex, though she argued the two were bound together. |
| Nast (visual) | Cartoonist; magazine cartoon | To persuade at a glance | Compresses a claim into one image | Compare its picture of protection with the Chinese Exclusion Act eleven years later; note and explain the gap. |
Model counterclaim (SLS original)
Claim: The Fourteenth Amendment was steadily enlarged between 1868 and 1898. Counterclaim from a non-court source: Du Bois writes in 1903 of a “double-consciousness” that the law had not touched, so from the inside the color line held. Answer: Wong Kim Ark enlarged the reach of citizenship; it did not end the experience Du Bois describes, so the enlargement was legal and incomplete.
Transitions for moving between courts and voices (SLS original)
- What the Court described as a choice, Du Bois describes as a condition.
- Where Brown finds no injury in the law, Harper finds it on the street car.
- Pokagon writes from outside the circle the amendments drew, so his evidence answers a different question.
Criteria for the Stage 1 organizer. A claim; three reasons; a counterclaim built from a source outside the courts; a table of four sources (one visual) with maker, form, purpose, what the form can and cannot do, and one discrepancy; two transitions.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
What does the birch-bark form of Pokagon’s booklet contribute to its argument?
When a cartoon and a law from the same period disagree about national attitudes, the best move is to leave one out.
How do Du Bois’s two central ideas — double-consciousness and the color line — relate?
Submit Stage 1: your claim; three reasons; your strongest counterclaim built from a source outside the courts; and a source-integration table with four sources (at least one visual), listing for each its maker, form, purpose, what the form can and cannot do, and one discrepancy with another source. Add two transitions you will use to move between legal and non-legal sources.
How confident are you that you can integrate sources in different media and use them to build a fair counterclaim?