
write a 1,500-1,800 word argument about how the Fourteenth Amendment’s promise was defined between 1868 and 1924, deliver a recorded address, and evaluate classmates’ reasoning and rhetoric.
Instruction
This essay asks you to enter a constitutional argument that is still alive. Birthright citizenship, equal protection and the meaning of “subject to the jurisdiction thereof” are debated in courts and legislatures now. Your job is to understand how the argument was made between 1868 and 1924.
The question. How was the Fourteenth Amendment’s promise of citizenship and equal protection defined, narrowed or enlarged between 1868 and 1924 — and which document or voice most shaped its meaning? You might argue that the Court’s opinions narrowed it until dissenters and writers made the narrowing visible; that Wong Kim Ark enlarged it in a way Plessy could not undo; or that for Native Americans it did not reach at all until 1924.
Precise claims (11-12.W.2.A). Name the specific clause you are arguing about. “The Fourteenth Amendment” is too broad; “the equal protection clause as read in Plessy” is precise.
Delineate at least one opinion. Quote the constitutional text and show, step by step, how the opinion reasons from it. Then evaluate a premise.
Formal style (11-12.W.2.A). Use the legal vocabulary from Lesson 3.2 accurately. Write about racial exclusion with precision, not euphemism. When a source uses offensive terms, quote only what your analysis needs and attribute it.
Conclusion (11-12.W.3.A.a). End with a section that follows from your argument and considers its significance: what the history you have traced suggests about how constitutional promises change.
The address (11-12.SL.2.A / 11-12.SL.2.B / 11-12.SL.2.C). Record three minutes presenting your argument: a precise claim, a logical sequence of claim, counterclaim and evidence, and at least two rhetorical devices used deliberately. Speak to a general audience of fellow citizens, not only to your classmates.
Evaluating classmates (11-12.SL.1.B). You will evaluate two classmates’ addresses: their stance, premises, links among ideas, word choice, points of emphasis and tone. Name one premise each speaker relies on and whether their evidence supports it. Evaluations are specific and respectful; you are assessing reasoning, not the person. A live address is an equal-credit alternative to recording.
A note on sensitive material. This unit discusses racial exclusion that some students’ families experienced directly. No one will be asked to share personal or family history. Discussion rules from the seminar apply.
Reading: Key Assignment packet: prompt, key passages, rubric and a model thesis
Constitution, Amendment XIV, National Archives; Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) and United States v. Wong Kim Ark (1898), Wikisource; Du Bois, The Souls of Black Folk (1903), Project Gutenberg #408. Retrieved 26 September 2026. Fetchable texts: https://www.archives.gov/founding-docs/amendments-11-27; https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Plessy_v._Ferguson/Dissent_Harlan; https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/United_States_v._Wong_Kim_Ark/Opinion_of_the_Court; https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/United_States_v._Wong_Kim_Ark/Dissent_Fuller; Project Gutenberg #408 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/408). · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain
Passages are quoted exactly; the rubric, thesis, outline and exemplar are SLS original.
The full prompt
How was the Fourteenth Amendment’s promise of citizenship and equal protection defined, narrowed or enlarged between 1868 and 1924, and which document or voice most shaped its meaning? Take a position. Delineate the reasoning of at least one Supreme Court opinion or dissent, quoting the constitutional text. Integrate at least two voices from outside the courts, including one visual or other non-print source. Develop a counterclaim fairly. 1,500 to 1,800 words, MLA style. Then deliver a three-minute recorded address and evaluate two classmates’ addresses.
Key passages
All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
— Fourteenth Amendment, Section 1
The white race deems itself to be the dominant race in this country. And so it is in prestige, in achievements, in education, in wealth and in power. So, I doubt not, it will continue to be for all time if it remains true to its great heritage and holds fast to the principles of constitutional liberty. But in view of the Constitution, in the eye of the law, there is in this country no superior, dominant, ruling class of citizens. There is no caste here. Our Constitution is color-blind, and neither knows nor tolerates classes among citizens. In respect of civil rights, all citizens are equal before the law.
— Justice Harlan, dissenting, Plessy v. Ferguson (1896)
The foregoing considerations and authorities irresistibly lead us to these conclusions: the Fourteenth Amendment affirms the ancient and fundamental rule of citizenship by birth within the territory, in the allegiance and under the protection of the country, including all children here born of resident aliens, with the exceptions or qualifications (as old as the rule itself) of children of foreign sovereigns or their ministers, or born on foreign public ships, or of enemies within and during a hostile occupation of part of our territory, and with the single additional exception of children of members of the Indian tribes owing direct allegiance to their several tribes. The Amendment, in clear words and in manifest intent, includes the children born, within the territory of the United States, of all other persons, of whatever race or color, domiciled within the United States.
— Justice Gray, United States v. Wong Kim Ark (1898)
In other words, the Fourteenth Amendment does not exclude from citizenship by birth children born in the United States of parents permanently located therein, and who might themselves become citizens; nor, on the other hand, does it arbitrarily make citizens of children born in the United States of parents who, according to the will of their native government and of this Government, are and must remain aliens.
— Chief Justice Fuller, dissenting, Wong Kim Ark (1898)
It is a peculiar sensation, this double-consciousness, this sense of always looking at one’s self through the eyes of others, of measuring one’s soul by the tape of a world that looks on in amused contempt and pity. One ever feels his twoness,—an American, a Negro; two souls, two thoughts, two unreconciled strivings; two warring ideals in one dark body, whose dogged strength alone keeps it from being torn asunder.
— Du Bois, The Souls of Black Folk (1903), Chapter I
Native citizenship. Justice Gray’s list of exceptions includes “children of members of the Indian tribes owing direct allegiance to their several tribes.” The Indian Citizenship Act of 1924, which you may cite as a statute, ended that exception by statute; find and cite it. Ask what that sequence shows about the amendment’s reach.
Rubric at four levels
| Criterion | 4: Exemplary | 3: Proficient | 2: Developing | 1: Beginning |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claim | Names the exact clause; distinguishes its position from alternatives | Precise claim about the amendment | Broad claim about civil rights | No claim |
| Legal reasoning | Delineates an opinion from the text step by step; evaluates a premise | Delineates an opinion accurately | Summarizes the outcome | Misstates the holding |
| Sources | Two outside voices integrated, one visual, discrepancies explained | Two outside voices integrated | One outside voice | None |
| Counterclaim | Developed fairly and answered | Stated and answered | Mentioned | Absent |
| Style and conclusion | Legal terms exact; conclusion states significance | Terms accurate | Terms loose | Errors change meaning |
| Address and evaluations | Logical, with deliberate devices; evaluations name and test a premise | Clear address; specific evaluations | General | Unclear |
Model thesis, outline and exemplar (SLS original)
Thesis. The equal protection clause was narrowed by Plessy and enlarged, for a different group, by Wong Kim Ark, but what most shaped its meaning was the dissent: Harlan’s “color-blind” principle and Du Bois’s account of what the line felt like became the standards by which later readers measured the Court, even as Harlan’s own passage on the Chinese shows how far the principle had still to go.
- The text of Section 1 and its four clauses.
- Plessy delineated: Brown’s premise that separation implies no inferiority.
- Wong Kim Ark: Gray’s history against Fuller’s allegiance.
- Counterclaim: Du Bois and Pokagon, for whom the line held.
- Conclusion: what a constitutional promise needs to be kept.
Exemplar paragraph (SLS original). Brown’s opinion rests on one premise: that enforced separation does not imply inferiority. He writes that the injury exists only because the plaintiff “put[s] that construction upon it.” Harlan answers that the law’s purpose was plain to everyone. Because the Fourteenth Amendment speaks of equal protection of “any person,” the question is whether a law’s meaning is its authors’ purpose or its targets’ reading, and Harlan’s answer is the more faithful to the text.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
equal protection
Tap to revealA state must apply its laws equally to all persons.
jus soli
Tap to revealCitizenship by place of birth.
holding
Tap to revealThe rule a decision establishes.
double-consciousness
Tap to revealSeeing oneself through a contemptuous world’s eyes.
separate but equal
Tap to revealThe doctrine upheld in Plessy.
Which is the most useful evaluation of a classmate’s address?
How confident are you that you can argue a constitutional question from primary legal texts and outside voices?
Submit: Argument Essay (1,500-1,800 words) + 3-minute address + two peer evaluations
Task: Argue how the Fourteenth Amendment’s promise of citizenship and equal protection was defined, narrowed or enlarged between 1868 and 1924, and which document or voice most shaped its meaning.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Organizer. Claim, reasons, counterclaim from a non-court source, source-integration table (from Lesson 3.4).
- Stage 2 — Peer-reviewed draft. A partner checks your delineation of the opinion against the text; submit a revision note.
- Stage 3 — Final essay. 1,500-1,800 words, constitutional text quoted, one opinion delineated, two voices outside the courts including one visual or non-print source, MLA.
- Stage 4 — Address and evaluation. Three-minute recorded or live address; written evaluations of two classmates.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Claim (11-12.W.2.A) | Precise clause named; position distinguished from alternatives. |
| Legal reasoning (11-12.RI.2.D) | One opinion or dissent delineated from the constitutional text; a premise evaluated. |
| Sources (11-12.RI.3.A / 11-12.RI.1.C) | Two voices outside the courts integrated, including one visual or non-print source, with discrepancies noted. |
| Counterclaim (11-12.W.2.A) | Developed fairly and answered. |
| Style and conclusion (11-12.W.2.A, 11-12.W.3.A.a) | Legal vocabulary accurate; formal, precise tone; conclusion states significance. |
| Address (11-12.SL.2.A / 11-12.SL.2.B / 11-12.SL.2.C) | Logical sequence; deliberate rhetorical devices; suited to a general audience. |
| Evaluations (11-12.SL.1.B) | Premises, evidence and rhetoric of two addresses assessed specifically and respectfully. |