
organize a comparative analysis point by point so each section builds on the last, write transitions that clarify relationships, and control complex sentences in standard grammar.
Instruction
Comparison essays fail in a predictable way: the writer discusses the play for half the essay, then the story for the other half, and adds a paragraph saying they are similar and different. That structure — sometimes called block comparison — rarely produces an argument. This workshop teaches a structure that does. 11-12.W.2.A asks you to organize complex ideas so that each new element builds on what precedes it to create a unified whole.
Step 1 — A comparative thesis. Your thesis must say something about the two versions that neither alone could show. Weak: Trifles and “A Jury of Her Peers” tell the same story in different ways. Strong: Glaspell’s play makes its audience complicit in the women’s silence by never letting us inside their minds, while the story, by narrating Martha Hale’s guilt, turns the same silence into an act of conscience — so the story explains what the play dares us to judge.
Step 2 — Point-by-point organization. Organize by aspects, and discuss both versions in every section:
- How each version handles the men’s mockery of “trifles” (establishes the conflict).
- How each version handles the discovery of the bird (the turn).
- How each version handles the decision to hide it (the moral choice).
- What each version’s ending asks of us (the argument).
Each section depends on the one before: you cannot evaluate the ending until the reader has seen the conflict, the turn and the choice.
Step 3 — Bring in a third text. Your essay must connect Glaspell to Gilman, Chopin or Sui Sin Far. Use the third text where it sharpens a point, not in a separate section at the end. If your point 3 is about women reading signs the men cannot see, Gilman’s narrator reading the wallpaper is a powerful — and darker — parallel.
Step 4 — Transitions that name the relationship (11-12.W.3.A.d). Comparison lives in its transitions: whereas, by contrast, in the same way, what the play leaves to silence, the story, this difference matters because. A transition should say how two ideas relate, not just that another idea is coming.
Grammar under pressure (11-12.W.3.A.c). Comparative sentences are long and easy to break. Watch three things. Parallel structure: The play shows the discovery; the story narrates it — not The play shows the discovery, and in the story it is narrated. Clear pronoun reference: when both versions have a Mrs. Hale, “she” must be unambiguous; write “the story’s Martha Hale.” Subject-verb agreement across intervening phrases: The silence of the two women in both versions is — the subject is silence.
Evidence (11-12.RL.1.A). Six paired quotations: for each section, one line from the play and one from the story, plus one performance moment from the staged reading, described precisely.
Plan for revision (11-12.W.3.A). At Stage 2 your partner will read only your topic sentences and transitions. If they cannot reconstruct your argument from those alone, your organization needs work — and it is far easier to fix at that stage than after the final.
Reading: A mentor paragraph, a point-by-point model and the criteria
W. E. B. Du Bois, The Souls of Black Folk (Chicago: A. C. McClurg, 1903), Chapter III, Project Gutenberg #408; Glaspell, Trifles (1916) and ‘A Jury of Her Peers’ (1917) as cited in Lesson 2.3. Retrieved 26 September 2026. Fetchable texts: Project Gutenberg #408 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/408); https://en.wikisource.org/w/index.php?title=Trifles_%28play%29; Project Gutenberg #20872 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/20872). · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Du Bois, 1903; Glaspell, 1916 and 1917)
Quoted passages are exact. The model, revision table and criteria are SLS original.
Mentor paragraph (public domain): a paragraph in which each sentence builds on the last
W. E. B. Du Bois, comparing his own view of the moment with Booker T. Washington’s, does not list points. Each sentence adds a condition (“Moreover,” “Again,”) and each depends on the one before it.
Mr. Washington represents in Negro thought the old attitude of adjustment and submission; but adjustment at such a peculiar time as to make his programme unique. This is an age of unusual economic development, and Mr. Washington’s programme naturally takes an economic cast, becoming a gospel of Work and Money to such an extent as apparently almost completely to overshadow the higher aims of life. Moreover, this is an age when the more advanced races are coming in closer contact with the less developed races, and the race-feeling is therefore intensified; and Mr. Washington’s programme practically accepts the alleged inferiority of the Negro races. Again, in our own land, the reaction from the sentiment of war time has given impetus to race-prejudice against Negroes, and Mr. Washington withdraws many of the high demands of Negroes as men and American citizens. In other periods of intensified prejudice all the Negro’s tendency to self-assertion has been called forth; at this period a policy of submission is advocated. In the history of nearly all other races and peoples the doctrine preached at such crises has been that manly self-respect is worth more than lands and houses, and that a people who voluntarily surrender such respect, or cease striving for it, are not worth civilizing. In answer to this, it has been claimed that the Negro can survive only through submission.
— W. E. B. Du Bois, The Souls of Black Folk (Chicago: A. C. McClurg, 1903), Chapter III, Project Gutenberg #408
What to notice: the topic sentence states the claim; the next sentences add conditions in order; the last states the consequence. A comparative essay uses the same structure across sections, not within one paragraph.
The evidence for a point-by-point plan (paired quotations, exact)
Well, women are used to worrying over trifles.
— Hale, in Trifles (1916)
The young attorney set his lips. “I guess before we’re through with her she may have something more serious than preserves to worry about.” “Oh, well,” said Mrs. Hale’s husband, with good-natured superiority, “women are used to worrying over trifles.” The two women moved a little closer together. Neither of them spoke.
— The same moment in ‘A Jury of Her Peers’ (1917)
Student model: one point-by-point body paragraph (SLS original)
Both versions open the conflict with the same insult, but they position the reader differently toward it. In the play, Hale’s line that “women are used to worrying over trifles” is followed only by a direction: “The two women move a little closer together.” The audience must decide what that movement means. In the story, the narrator adds that “Neither of them spoke,” so the silence is reported and interpreted for us. Whereas the play makes the audience read the women’s bodies, the story makes it read their restraint, and this difference matters because it shapes how complicit each audience feels in what follows.
Before and after (SLS original)
| Block draft (weak) | Point-by-point revision (strong) |
|---|---|
| Paragraph 2 discusses the play. Paragraph 3 discusses the story. Paragraph 4 says they are similar and different. | Section 1: how each version handles the men’s mockery. Section 2: how each handles the discovery of the bird. Section 3: how each handles the decision to hide it. Section 4: what each ending asks of us. Every section quotes both versions and ends by pointing to the next. |
Criteria for the Stage 1 organizer (SLS original)
- The comparative thesis makes a claim that neither version alone could support.
- Four sections in point-by-point order, each building on the one before it.
- For each section, one line from the play and one from the story, plus one described performance moment.
- A topic sentence and a transition for each section that names the relationship (“whereas,” “by contrast,” “this difference matters because”).
- The point where a third text (Gilman, Chopin or Sui Sin Far) enters.
Grammar check (worked). “The silence of the two women in both versions is powerful.” The subject is silence, so the verb is singular. In a comparison keep the parts parallel: “the play shows the discovery; the story narrates it.”
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which organization best supports a comparative argument?
‘The silence of the two women in both versions are powerful’ is grammatically correct.
Submit Stage 1: your comparative thesis; a four-section point-by-point outline with a topic sentence and a transition for each section; six paired quotations (play and story) and one performance moment; and the point where your third text (Gilman, Chopin or Sui Sin Far) enters.
How confident are you that you can organize a comparison so that each section builds on the last?