
write a 1,800-2,500 word researched argument with an annotated bibliography, answering my own question about the year’s reading, and present it with digital media.
Instruction
This is the longest piece of writing in English 11, and the one that shows what you can do on your own. It asks you to answer your own question about American literature, using the year’s texts, primary documents and scholars, and to take a position others could dispute.
From question to claim. By now your research should have produced an answer. State it as a precise claim in your introduction, and establish why it matters. A capstone claim is often qualified: Early reviewers read Gatsby as a story about a bootlegger’s vulgarity; they missed that the novel’s sharpest judgment falls on Tom and Daisy’s class, which later readers recognized once Nick’s narration was read as unreliable.
Structure for a long argument. Plan six to eight sections, each advancing the claim. Place your strongest counterclaim where it arises naturally, not automatically at the end. Use headings sparingly, if at all; let topic sentences carry the structure.
Integrating research (11-12.W.1.A). Synthesize, do not stack. A paragraph that summarizes Source A and then Source B is a list. A paragraph that shows where A and B agree, where they differ, and what your literary evidence adds is research.
Literary evidence (11-12.RL.1.A). Your argument must rest on close reading of the literary texts, quoted precisely. Secondary sources support and challenge your reading; they do not replace it.
Conventions (11-12.W.3.A.c). In a long essay, small errors accumulate. Proofread in a separate pass for agreement, pronoun reference and parallelism, and read the final aloud.
Routine and extended writing (11-12.W.2.A). The capstone is written over three weeks. Keep your proposal, bibliography, drafts and revision notes: the process is assessed as well as the product.
The presentation (11-12.SL.2.A, 11-12.SL.2.B, 11-12.SL.2.C). Six to eight minutes, for an audience of classmates and invited guests. Present your question, your claim, your best evidence and your answer to the strongest counterclaim. Use digital media strategically: a passage displayed while you analyze it, a primary document or image you discuss, a simple timeline — not slides of your essay’s text. Every image must be public domain or openly licensed and credited. Take questions for two minutes. A recorded presentation with written responses to questions is an equal-credit alternative.
Integrity. Every idea you did not have yourself is cited. AI tools may not write your essay; if you use one to brainstorm search terms, disclose how you used it in a note. Your proposal, bibliography and drafts are the record of your thinking.
📖 Before this lesson, read: The Great Gatsby, The whole novel (Chapters 1-9)
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reading: The Researched Capstone: key passages, rubric and a model
F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby (New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons, 1925), text of Project Gutenberg eBook #64317 (released 17 January 2021), https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/64317, retrieved 26 September 2026; Anzia Yezierska, “America and I,” in Children of Loneliness (1923), text of Project Gutenberg eBook #71361 (released 7 August 2023, scanned from a HathiTrust copy), https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/71361, retrieved 26 September 2026; Calvin Coolidge, First State of the Union Address (message to Congress, delivered 6 December 1923), Wikisource, https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Calvin_Coolidge%27s_First_State_of_the_Union_Address, retrieved 26 September 2026; a work of the U.S. federal government; Immigration Act of 1924, 43 Stat. 153 (chapter 190, Public No. 139, approved 26 May 1924), a work of the U.S. federal government; text of the Statutes at Large, volume 43, at https://archive.org/download/sim_united-states-united-states-statutes-at-large_december-1923-march-1925_43/sim_united-states-united-states-statutes-at-large_december-1923-march-1925_43_djvu.txt, checked against the official page images at govinfo.gov (package STATUTE-43, file STATUTE-43-Pg153-2.pdf), retrieved 26 September 2026 · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Fitzgerald, 1925; Yezierska, 1923) or works of the U.S. government (Coolidge, 1923; Immigration Act of 1924)
Blockquoted passages are exact, in the spelling and punctuation of their sources. The brief, rubric, model claim, outline, model paragraph and presentation plan are SLS original.
How to use this text. Your capstone question is your own, and your sources include texts from the whole year. This reading gives you the shared core: the exact wording of key passages from the novel and from three primary documents, located by chapter or section, plus the rubric and a model. Quote from these when your argument needs them; use the full works for everything else.
Part 1. The prompt in brief (SLS original)
Write a researched argument of 1,800 to 2,500 words that answers your own question about the year’s reading, centered on The Great Gatsby or another full-length work from English 11 and tied to the through-line: who belongs to the American promise, and on what terms. Use at least eight sources: two literary texts from the year, two primary historical documents and three or more authoritative secondary sources, each annotated in your bibliography. Present a precise claim, develop counterclaims with evidence, integrate sources smoothly, and cite in MLA format. Then give a six-to-eight minute presentation with digital media.
Part 2. Key passages
The Great Gatsby, Chapter VI: how Gatsby invents himself
So he invented just the sort of Jay Gatsby that a seventeen-year-old boy would be likely to invent, and to this conception he was faithful to the end.
The Great Gatsby, Chapter VII: how Tom names an outsider
“Self-control!” repeated Tom incredulously. “I suppose the latest thing is to sit back and let Mr. Nobody from Nowhere make love to your wife.
The Great Gatsby, Chapter IX: Nick’s verdict on the Buchanans
It was all very careless and confused. They were careless people, Tom and Daisy—they smashed up things and creatures and then retreated back into their money or their vast carelessness, or whatever it was that kept them together, and let other people clean up the mess they had made
Anzia Yezierska, “America and I” (1923): the turn
Then came a light–a great revelation! I saw America–a big idea–a deathless hope–a world still in the making. I saw that it was the glory of America that it was not yet finished. And I, the last comer, had her share to give, small or great, to the making of America, like those Pilgrims who came in the _Mayflower_.
Fired up by this revealing light, I began to build a bridge of understanding between the American-born and myself. Since their life was shut out from such as me, I began to open up my life and the lives of my people to them. And life draws life. In only writing about the Ghetto I found America.
Calvin Coolidge, message to Congress, 6 December 1923
American institutions rest solely on good citizenship. They were created by people who had a background of self-government. New arrivals should be limited to our capacity to absorb them into the ranks of good citizenship. America must be kept American.
Immigration Act of 1924, Section 11(a) (43 Stat. 153)
The annual quota of any nationality shall be 2 per centum of the number of foreign-born individuals of such nationality resident in continental United States as determined by the United States census of 1890, but the minimum quota of any nationality shall be 100.
Part 3. Rubric (SLS original)
| Criterion | 4 Exemplary | 3 Proficient | 2 Developing | 1 Beginning |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Question and claim | Self-generated question, well narrowed; a precise, significant, qualified claim that others could dispute. | Clear question and precise claim; scope mostly right. | Question too broad or too narrow, or claim general. | No answerable question, or claim only restates the topic. |
| Research and synthesis | Eight or more authoritative sources of every required type; paragraphs show where sources agree, differ and what the essay adds. | Eight sources of the required types; mostly synthesized. | Fewer than eight, or a type missing; sources are stacked one after another. | Few sources, weak authority, or one source carries the argument. |
| Literary evidence | Close reading of the year’s texts carries the argument; quotations precise and interpreted. | Quotations are accurate and mostly interpreted. | Quotations are dropped in or summarized; secondary sources replace reading. | Little or no textual evidence. |
| Counterclaim | Strongest counterclaim is developed with sources and answered fairly, placed where it arises. | A real counterclaim is stated and answered. | Counterclaim is weak or answered by dismissal. | No counterclaim. |
| Annotated bibliography | Each entry has correct MLA and 100 to 150 words that summarize, assess and state the use. | Correct MLA; annotations complete but uneven. | Errors in MLA, or annotations only summarize. | Missing entries or no annotations. |
| Conventions and process | Controlled grammar across a long text; complete record of proposal, drafts and revision notes. | Few errors; process record present. | Errors accumulate; record incomplete. | Frequent errors; no process record. |
| Presentation | Clear line of reasoning in six to eight minutes; media used strategically and credited; questions answered well. | Clear; media mostly relevant and credited. | Reads the essay aloud, or media decorates. | Unclear, off time, or uncredited images. |
Part 4. A model claim, outline and paragraph (SLS original)
Question. How did the Immigration Act of 1924 and The Great Gatsby each answer who could belong from “nowhere,” and how does Yezierska’s 1923 account of arrival answer them both?
Claim. In 1923 to 1925, American law and American fiction asked the same question about newcomers: does belonging come from what a person is, or from what a person makes? Congress answered by origin, Yezierska by contribution, and Fitzgerald shows that Gatsby’s contribution is only as secure as the goodwill of those who hold the test.
Outline. (1) The law’s definition of belonging: Section 11(a) and the restrictionist argument. (2) Tom Buchanan’s version of the same test. (3) Yezierska’s counter-definition. (4) Gatsby’s self-invention read against both. (5) Counterclaim: Gatsby is destroyed by his own crimes and by Daisy, not by exclusion; answer: the novel makes his origins the ground on which Tom dismisses him. (6) What the comparison shows about the promise, and its limits.
Model body paragraph.
When Tom Buchanan calls Gatsby “Mr. Nobody from Nowhere,” he asks the question that Congress had already written into law: where does a person come from, and does that origin count? The Immigration Act of 1924 does not ask what an applicant can do. Its quota rule is arithmetic on origins: “The annual quota of any nationality shall be 2 per centum of the number of foreign-born individuals of such nationality resident in continental United States as determined by the United States census of 1890” (Sec. 11(a)). Six months earlier, President Coolidge had put the principle of restriction in one sentence: “America must be kept American” (“First State”). The statute and the sneer both treat belonging as fixed before a person arrives. Yezierska’s narrator refuses that premise from below, concluding that America is “a world still in the making” and that even “the last comer” has a share in making it. Fitzgerald complicates her answer. Gatsby has made himself as thoroughly as she has, and Tom needs only four words to undo the making. Self-invention, the novel suggests, works for exactly as long as those who own the test agree not to apply it.
What the model does. It states a claim in its first sentence and connects two very different sources through one shared idea (the test of origin); it quotes precisely and cites in MLA; it puts the essay’s own reading of the novel last, so the sources support the argument and do not replace it. Notice too what it does not do: it does not claim that Fitzgerald endorsed Tom’s view, only that the novel shows the view at work.
Part 5. Presentation plan and image credits (SLS original)
- Minute 1: your question and why it matters. Minutes 2 to 5: your claim and your two best pieces of evidence, each shown on screen while you analyze it. Minutes 5 to 7: the strongest counterclaim and your answer. Last minute: what the answer changes about how the year’s texts read.
- Show a passage, a primary document or an image you discuss, or a simple timeline. Do not show slides of your essay’s text.
- Credit format for every image: Title. Creator. Year. Source URL. License (public domain or the specific open license).
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
synthesis
Tap to revealCombining sources to show agreement, difference and what one’s own evidence adds.
annotated bibliography
Tap to revealSources with summary, evaluation and use.
qualified claim
Tap to revealA claim limited to what the evidence supports.
primary source
Tap to revealA document from the period studied.
symbol
Tap to revealAn object that gathers meaning through repetition.
A paragraph summarizes one critic, then another, with no connection. What is the best revision?
How confident are you that you can carry out a researched argument on my own question and present it with digital media?
Submit: Researched Argument (1,800-2,500 words) + annotated bibliography (8+ sources) + 6-8 minute presentation
Task: Answer your own research question about the year’s American literature, connected to the course through-line — who belongs to the American promise, and on what terms — in a researched argument supported by literary texts, primary documents and scholarship.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Proposal and annotated bibliography. Question, tentative claim, eight or more annotated sources and a search log (from Lesson 4.7).
- Stage 2 — Peer-reviewed draft. A partner checks synthesis (does each research paragraph combine sources?) and counterclaim; a second reader checks the integration of quotations; submit a revision note.
- Stage 3 — Final essay. 1,800-2,500 words, MLA, published to the class portfolio with the final annotated bibliography.
- Stage 4 — Presentation. Six to eight minutes with digital media and a question period, live or recorded with written answers.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Question and claim (11-12.W.1.A, 11-12.W.2.A) | Self-generated question appropriately narrowed; precise, significant claim. |
| Research and synthesis (11-12.W.1.A, 11-12.W.1.A.b) | Eight or more authoritative sources of the required types, synthesized rather than stacked. |
| Literary evidence (11-12.RL.1.A) | Close reading of the year’s texts carries the argument. |
| Counterclaim (11-12.W.2.A) | Strongest counterclaim developed with sources and answered. |
| Annotated bibliography (11-12.W.1.A.b) | Each entry summarizes, evaluates and states its use; MLA correct. |
| Conventions and process (11-12.W.3.A.c, 11-12.W.2.A) | Controlled grammar across a long text; complete process record. |
| Presentation (11-12.SL.2.A, 11-12.SL.2.B, 11-12.SL.2.C) | Clear line of reasoning; digital media used strategically and credited; questions answered. |
The Great Gatsby, The whole novel (Chapters 1-9)
The Great Gatsby, The whole novel (Chapters 1-9) so far Bridge summary — not the primary text
A recap of what you have already read, written for this course, so the reading check below does not require re-opening every earlier popover.
In the summer of 1922 Nick Carraway, newly arrived in West Egg, is drawn into the world of his neighbor Jay Gatsby, who throws enormous parties in the hope that Daisy Buchanan, the woman he loved in Louisville in 1917, will appear (Chapters 1-4). Nick arranges their reunion, and the affair resumes while Nick learns that Gatsby was born James Gatz, a poor farm boy who remade himself (Chapters 5-6). On the hottest day of the summer Tom Buchanan exposes Gatsby’s bootlegging at the Plaza Hotel, and Daisy, driving Gatsby’s car home, kills Tom’s mistress, Myrtle Wilson; Myrtle’s husband, George, learns from Tom whose car it was, and shoots Gatsby and then himself (Chapters 7-8). Almost no one comes to Gatsby’s funeral; Tom and Daisy leave without a word, Nick condemns them as careless people, and on his last night in the East he connects Gatsby’s green light to the dream that first drew people to the continent (Chapter 9).