
generate and narrow a research question, search authoritative print and digital sources effectively, evaluate their strengths and limits, and write an annotated bibliography in MLA format.
Instruction
The capstone is a sustained research project on a question you generate yourself. 11-12.W.1.A asks you to conduct research to answer a question, narrowing or broadening it as needed, and to synthesize multiple sources. 11-12.W.1.A.b asks you to gather information from authoritative sources using advanced searches, and to assess each source’s usefulness for your task, purpose and audience.
Step 1 — Generate a question. Start from something in the year’s reading that genuinely puzzles you. Good research questions ask how or why, and cannot be answered with a fact. Examples: How did reviewers in 1925 read Gatsby’s class, and what did they miss that later readers noticed? How did the Homestead Act and the Dawes Act divide the same prairie, and whose land does My Ántonia remember? How did Chinese Americans in San Francisco use the courts after Wong Kim Ark? Each connects to the year’s through-line: who belongs to the American promise, and on what terms.
Step 2 — Narrow or broaden. “The American Dream in literature” is too broad; you cannot answer it in 2,500 words. “The color of Daisy’s dock light” is too narrow. Adjust until your question can be answered with eight to twelve sources.
Step 3 — Search effectively. Use your school or public library’s databases before the open web; many public libraries offer free access to academic databases with a library card. Use advanced search: exact phrases in quotation marks, AND/OR/NOT, limits by date and source type. For primary documents, search the Library of Congress (including its Chronicling America newspaper archive), the National Archives and HathiTrust, which hold digitized public-domain books, newspapers and letters. Keep a search log of what you searched and what you found.
Step 4 — Evaluate each source. For every source ask: Who wrote it, and what is their expertise? Who published it, and was it reviewed? When, and does the date matter for your question? What is its purpose? What evidence does it use? A 1925 newspaper review is a poor source for facts about Fitzgerald’s life, and an excellent primary source for how readers responded in 1925. Usefulness depends on your question.
Step 5 — Annotate. An annotated bibliography gives each source’s MLA citation followed by a paragraph of 100-150 words that (1) summarizes the source’s argument or content, (2) assesses its authority and limits, and (3) states how you will use it. The third part is the most important and the most often skipped. “I will use Author X’s reading of the ending as my main counterclaim” is an annotation that shows thinking.
Avoiding plagiarism and over-reliance. Integrate information selectively, cite everything you did not know before, and never let one source structure your whole argument. If a single article gives you your claim, your evidence and your counterclaim, you are summarizing it, not researching.
Drawing evidence from texts (11-12.RL.1.A / 11-12.RI.1.A). Your literary and historical texts are evidence too; quote them from the editions you used in class and cite them precisely.
Using technology (11-12.W.3.A.e). Build your bibliography in a shared document so a partner and other readers can comment. Respond to each comment before the draft. A free citation manager such as Zotero can store sources; check every generated citation against MLA rules, because generators make errors.
📖 Before this lesson, read: The Great Gatsby, Chapters 1-7
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reading: The Research Workshop: a question ladder, a worked source evaluation and a model annotated bibliography
Calvin Coolidge, First State of the Union Address (message to Congress, delivered 6 December 1923), Wikisource, https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Calvin_Coolidge%27s_First_State_of_the_Union_Address, retrieved 26 September 2026; a work of the U.S. federal government; Immigration Act of 1924, 43 Stat. 153 (chapter 190, Public No. 139, approved 26 May 1924), a work of the U.S. federal government; text of the Statutes at Large, volume 43, at https://archive.org/download/sim_united-states-united-states-statutes-at-large_december-1923-march-1925_43/sim_united-states-united-states-statutes-at-large_december-1923-march-1925_43_djvu.txt, checked against the official page images at govinfo.gov (package STATUTE-43, file STATUTE-43-Pg153-2.pdf), retrieved 26 September 2026; Anzia Yezierska, “America and I,” in Children of Loneliness (1923), text of Project Gutenberg eBook #71361 (released 7 August 2023, scanned from a HathiTrust copy), https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/71361, retrieved 26 September 2026 · SLS original; quoted passage is a work of the U.S. federal government (Calvin Coolidge, 1923)
The one blockquote is exact. The question ladder, the worked answers, the model proposal, the model annotations and the scoring list are SLS original; the bibliographic citations refer to the public-domain sources named in the source line.
How to use this workshop. The three sources below are real, they are in the public domain, and you can retrieve every one of them yourself. They are the practice sources for the skills in this lesson: narrowing a question, judging a source, and annotating it. Your own eight or more sources come from your own search.
Part 1. The question ladder (SLS original)
| Question | Verdict |
|---|---|
| How did America treat immigrants in the 1920s? | Too broad. No set of eight to twelve sources can answer it in 2,500 words. |
| How did American law limit immigration in 1924? | Still broad, and it can be answered with facts. It asks what, not how or why. |
| How did the Immigration Act of 1924 define who could become an American, and how does Yezierska’s 1923 account of arrival answer that definition? | Workable. It is open, it needs a legal text, a literary text and at least three secondary sources, and it connects to the year’s through-line: who belongs to the American promise, and on what terms. |
| Does Section 11(a) of the 1924 Act mention the year 1890? | Too narrow. It is answered by reading one sentence. |
Part 2. Judging a primary source: a worked example
This paragraph is from the annual message to Congress delivered by President Calvin Coolidge on 6 December 1923.
Passage: Coolidge, 6 December 1923
American institutions rest solely on good citizenship. They were created by people who had a background of self-government. New arrivals should be limited to our capacity to absorb them into the ranks of good citizenship. America must be kept American.
Now apply the five questions from the lesson (SLS original worked answers).
- Who wrote it, and with what expertise? The President, in an official message to Congress. He has authority to recommend laws but the paragraph is not itself a law.
- Who published it, and was it reviewed? It is an official government address, so it was not peer reviewed; it was written to persuade and to set an agenda.
- When, and does the date matter? December 1923, about six months before the Immigration Act of 1924 was approved. The date is the reason to use it: it shows the argument being made before the law.
- What was its purpose? To urge Congress to limit arrivals. It cites no numbers in this paragraph; it argues from a principle about citizenship.
- What evidence does it use? Assertion and appeal to a national tradition, and no data. That limits it as evidence about immigrants, and makes it strong evidence about how supporters of restriction reasoned.
Usefulness depends on the question. For “how many people came in 1923?” this source is nearly useless. For “how did supporters of the 1924 Act frame the case for it?” it is exactly the kind of primary source you need.
Part 3. A model proposal (SLS original)
Question: How did the Immigration Act of 1924 define who could become an American, and how does Yezierska’s 1923 account of arrival answer that definition? Why it matters: the Act and the story were written within a year of each other and disagree about whether belonging is inherited or built. Through-line: who belongs to the American promise, and on what terms. Tentative claim: the Act treats belonging as a fact about a person’s origins, and Yezierska treats it as something a newcomer helps make, and the tension between them is what makes The Great Gatsby’s story of self-invention urgent. (A tentative claim is expected to change as you research.)
Part 4. Model annotated bibliography (SLS original annotations)
The citations follow MLA 9 and were built from the sources’ own records. Each annotation has the three parts the lesson names: summary, assessment, use.
Coolidge, Calvin. “First State of the Union Address.” 6 Dec. 1923. Wikisource, en.wikisource.org/wiki/Calvin_Coolidge%27s_First_State_of_the_Union_Address. Accessed 26 Sept. 2026.
This is the President’s first annual message to Congress. Its immigration paragraph argues that American institutions depend on good citizenship and that arrivals should be limited to the country’s capacity to absorb them. The source is authoritative for what the President recommended, but it is an advocate’s document: it offers no figures and does not represent immigrants’ views. Wikisource is a transcription, so quotations should be checked against the official record before they are printed in a final essay. I will use it as the restrictionist counterclaim in my second section, and to date the argument for restriction to before the 1924 law was passed.
United States, Congress. Immigration Act of 1924. 26 May 1924. United States Statutes at Large, vol. 43, p. 153. GovInfo, www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/STATUTE-43/pdf/STATUTE-43-Pg153-2.pdf. Accessed 26 Sept. 2026.
The statute sets annual quotas by nationality, first at 2 percent of each group’s foreign-born population in the 1890 census, then, from the fiscal year beginning in July 1927, by a formula based on national origin in 1920. It also bars aliens ineligible to citizenship, with listed exceptions. As the enacted text it is the highest authority for what the law required, but it says nothing about how officials applied it or how people experienced it. I will use it as my central primary source on the law’s definition of belonging, and pair it with narrative sources for its effects.
Yezierska, Anzia. “America and I.” Children of Loneliness, 1923. Project Gutenberg, 7 Aug. 2023, www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/71361. Accessed 26 Sept. 2026.
Told in the first person, this account follows an immigrant woman from an unpaid domestic job through a sweatshop and a factory to a turning point at which she decides that America is “a world still in the making” and that she can help make it by writing. Yezierska wrote from immigrant experience, but the piece appears in a collection of stories and its narrator is a shaped voice, so it is strong evidence of how a newcomer’s case could be argued in 1923 and weaker as evidence of any one life. I will use it as my main literary counter to the Act’s definition, and compare its ending with Gatsby’s self-invention.
Part 5. Revising a weak annotation (SLS original)
Before: This source is about immigration laws in 1924. It is a good source because it is from the government. I will use it in my paper.
What is wrong: the summary is a topic, not an account of the content; “good because it is from the government” assesses nothing about limits; “use it in my paper” does not say where or for what.
After: This is the enacted text of the Immigration Act of 1924. It sets quotas by nationality and bars people ineligible to become citizens. As the law itself it is authoritative about what was required, but it cannot show how the rules were enforced. I will use Section 11(a) in my opening section as the law’s definition of who could belong, and set it against Yezierska.
Part 6. What your proposal and bibliography will be scored on (SLS original)
- The question is open, narrowed to fit eight to twelve sources, and tied to the year’s through-line.
- At least eight sources: two literary texts from the year, two primary historical documents, three or more authoritative secondary sources.
- Each entry has a correct MLA citation and an annotation of 100 to 150 words that summarizes, assesses authority and limits, and states how the source will be used.
- The search log records what you searched, where, and what you found. A sample row: Date; database or site; exact search string; number of results; what I kept and why.
- The bibliography is built in a shared document, comments answered before the draft, and every generated citation checked against MLA rules.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which is the best capstone research question?
A 1925 newspaper review is a weak source for every research question about Gatsby.
Which part of an annotation is most often skipped and most important?
Submit your proposal (research question, why it matters, how it connects to the year’s through-line, and a tentative claim) and your annotated bibliography of at least eight sources: two literary texts from the year, two primary historical documents and three or more authoritative secondary sources, each with an MLA citation and a 100-150 word annotation. Attach your search log.
How confident are you that you can generate a research question, find and evaluate authoritative sources, and annotate them?
The Great Gatsby, Chapters 1-7
The Great Gatsby, Chapters 1-7 so far Bridge summary — not the primary text
A recap of what you have already read, written for this course, so the reading check below does not require re-opening every earlier popover.
Nick Carraway rents a house in West Egg beside Gatsby’s mansion, dines with his cousin Daisy and her husband, Tom Buchanan, in East Egg, and sees Gatsby reaching toward a green light across the bay (Chapter 1). Tom takes Nick to meet his mistress, Myrtle Wilson, the wife of a garage owner in the valley of ashes, and breaks her nose at a drunken party (Chapter 2). Nick attends one of Gatsby’s parties, where guests trade rumors about their host (Chapter 3). Gatsby tells Nick an embellished life story, introduces the gambler Meyer Wolfshiem, and through Jordan Baker asks Nick to arrange a meeting with Daisy, whom Gatsby loved in Louisville in 1917 (Chapter 4); the reunion at Nick’s house begins awkwardly and ends with the two of them transformed (Chapter 5). Nick reveals that Gatsby was born James Gatz and remade himself with the help of the millionaire Dan Cody; Tom and Daisy attend a party that Daisy dislikes, and Gatsby insists that he can repeat the past (Chapter 6). On the hottest day of the summer, a confrontation at the Plaza Hotel exposes Gatsby’s bootlegging and Daisy’s divided feelings, and on the drive home Daisy, at the wheel of Gatsby’s car, strikes and kills Myrtle without stopping; Gatsby resolves to take the blame (Chapter 7).