
analyze how the older Jim’s narration in Book I, Chapters 7-13 undercuts the younger Jim’s view of himself and his neighbors, and explain how debt, hunger and pride shape the immigrant families’ first winter.
Instruction
Book I, Chapter 7 is the most famous adventure in the novel, and Cather builds it so that we enjoy it twice: once as the boy experienced it, and once as the man explains it. Jim and Ántonia are digging into a prairie-dog hole when Ántonia screams in Bohemian. Jim turns and finds “the biggest snake I had ever seen,” kills it with a borrowed spade, and drags it home in triumph. Ántonia tells the story “with a great deal of colour,” and from that day she “never took a supercilious air with me again. I had killed a big snake—I was now a big fellow.”
Two Jims (11-12.RL.2.B / 11-12.RL.3.C). 11-12.RL.2.B / 11-12.RL.3.C asks you to tell what a text states directly from what it really means, including irony. Notice what the older narrator adds. “Subsequent experiences with rattlesnakes taught me that my first encounter was fortunate in circumstance.” The snake was old and lazy, and “he had forgot that the world doesn’t owe rattlers a living.” Then the verdict: “So in reality it was a mock adventure; the game was fixed for me by chance, as it probably was for many a dragon-slayer.” The man does not cancel the boy’s pride; he places it. This double vision is Cather’s method throughout Book I, and you should watch for every place where the older Jim corrects, softens or questions the younger one.
Who was here first? Look closely at how the boy imagines the snake’s age: “he must have been there when white men first came, left on from buffalo and Indian times.” In Chapter 9 the first snow reveals “a great circle where the Indians used to ride,” and the hired men are sure it was a place of torture, while the grandfather thinks it was used for races or for training horses. These are the only traces in Book I of the Native nations who lived and hunted on this land before the survey and the homestead claims. The novel records them as marks in the grass, interpreted by settlers who disagree about what they mean. Keep these passages; you will need them in the seminar.
Debt as a predator. Chapter 8 tells a second story of wolves. Pavel, dying, confesses that years ago in Russia he threw a bride and groom from a sledge to the pursuing wolves to save himself and Peter, and the story has followed them ever since. But the chapter opens with a different kind of hunter. Peter cannot meet a note: “His creditor was Wick Cutter, the merciless Black Hawk money-lender.” Each renewal adds a bonus to the principal, “and the debt grew faster than any crop he planted. Now everything was plastered with mortgages.” After Pavel dies, Cutter buys up the sale notes “at about fifty cents on the dollar,” and Peter eats all his winter melons on the floor of his empty house. The rattlesnake that lives off the prairie dogs, the wolves that chase the sledges and the lender who lives off the settlers are versions of one idea.
Pride and need. In Chapter 10 the Burdens bring food to the Shimerdas’ cave and find frozen potatoes and almost no flour. Mr. Shimerda insists, through Ántonia, “that they were not beggars in the old country.” In Chapter 13, after Mrs. Shimerda carries off the Burdens’ iron pot, Jim snaps, “People who don’t like this country ought to stay at home,” and Ántonia retorts, “Your grandfather is rich,” and then, “Why he not help my papa?” The grandmother’s reply is the wisest line in these chapters: “a body never knows what traits poverty might bring out in ’em.” As you read, ask whose judgment the novel trusts, the boy’s, the grandmother’s, or neither.
Your chart. Make two columns. On the left, copy what the young Jim believes at the time; on the right, what the older narrator admits, adds or implies. Aim for at least five pairs across Chapters 7-13.
📖 Before this lesson, read: My Ántonia, Book I, Chapters 7-13
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Jim kills a huge rattlesnake and becomes a hero to Ántonia. Before you read the end of Chapter 7, what do you predict the older Jim will say about it?
Why does Russian Peter lose his cow, his horses and his house in Chapter 8?
In Chapter 9 the characters agree that the great circle in the grass was where Native riders tortured prisoners.
Complete your two-voice chart for Chapters 7-13 with at least five pairs. Then, in six to eight sentences, analyze one place where the older narrator’s comment changes the meaning of the younger Jim’s experience. Quote both voices, and explain what Cather gains by letting the reader see both at once.
How confident are you that you can tell what young Jim believes from what the novel shows, and explain how debt and pride shape the first winter?
My Ántonia, Book I, Chapters 7-13
My Ántonia, Book 1 (The Shimerdas), Chapter 7
Source: Willa Cather, My Ántonia (Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1918), Project Gutenberg eBook #242 (gutenberg.org) · Public domain
Much as I liked Ántonia, I hated a superior tone that she sometimes took with me. She was four years older than I, to be sure, and had seen more of the world; but I was a boy and she was a girl, and I resented her protecting manner. Before the autumn was over, she began to treat me more like an equal and to defer to me in other things than reading lessons. This change came about from an adventure we had together.
One day when I rode over to the Shimerdas’ I found Ántonia starting off on foot for Russian Peter’s house, to borrow a spade Ambrosch needed. I offered to take her on the pony, and she got up behind me. There had been another black frost the night before, and the air was clear and heady as wine. Within a week all the blooming roads had been despoiled, hundreds of miles of yellow sunflowers had been transformed into brown, rattling, burry stalks.
We found Russian Peter digging his potatoes. We were glad to go in and get warm by his kitchen stove and to see his squashes and Christmas melons, heaped in the storeroom for winter. As we rode away with the spade, Ántonia suggested that we stop at the prairie-dog-town and dig into one of the holes. We could find out whether they ran straight down, or were horizontal, like mole-holes; whether they had underground connections; whether the owls had nests down there, lined with feathers. We might get some puppies, or owl eggs, or snakeskins.
The dog-town was spread out over perhaps ten acres. The grass had been nibbled short and even, so this stretch was not shaggy and red like the surrounding country, but grey and velvety. The holes were several yards apart, and were disposed with a good deal of regularity, almost as if the town had been laid out in streets and avenues. One always felt that an orderly and very sociable kind of life was going on there. I picketed Dude down in a draw, and we went wandering about, looking for a hole that would be easy to dig. The dogs were out, as usual, dozens of them, sitting up on their hind legs over the doors of their houses. As we approached, they barked, shook their tails at us, and scurried underground. Before the mouths of the holes were little patches of sand and gravel, scratched up, we supposed, from a long way below the surface. Here and there, in the town, we came on larger gravel patches, several yards away from any hole. If the dogs had scratched the sand up in excavating, how had they carried it so far? It was on one of these gravel beds that I met my adventure.
We were examining a big hole with two entrances. The burrow sloped into the ground at a gentle angle, so that we could see where the two corridors united, and the floor was dusty from use, like a little highway over which much travel went. I was walking backward, in a crouching position, when I heard Ántonia scream. She was standing opposite me, pointing behind me and shouting something in Bohemian. I whirled round, and there, on one of those dry gravel beds, was the biggest snake I had ever seen. He was sunning himself, after the cold night, and he must have been asleep when Ántonia screamed. When I turned, he was lying in long loose waves, like a letter ‘W.’ He twitched and began to coil slowly. He was not merely a big snake, I thought—he was a circus monstrosity. His abominable muscularity, his loathsome, fluid motion, somehow made me sick. He was as thick as my leg, and looked as if millstones couldn’t crush the disgusting vitality out of him. He lifted his hideous little head, and rattled. I didn’t run because I didn’t think of it—if my back had been against a stone wall I couldn’t have felt more cornered. I saw his coils tighten—now he would spring, spring his length, I remembered. I ran up and drove at his head with my spade, struck him fairly across the neck, and in a minute he was all about my feet in wavy loops. I struck now from hate. Ántonia, barefooted as she was, ran up behind me. Even after I had pounded his ugly head flat, his body kept on coiling and winding, doubling and falling back on itself. I walked away and turned my back. I felt seasick.
Ántonia came after me, crying, ‘O Jimmy, he not bite you? You sure? Why you not run when I say?’
‘What did you jabber Bohunk for? You might have told me there was a snake behind me!’ I said petulantly.
‘I know I am just awful, Jim, I was so scared.’ She took my handkerchief from my pocket and tried to wipe my face with it, but I snatched it away from her. I suppose I looked as sick as I felt.
‘I never know you was so brave, Jim,’ she went on comfortingly. ‘You is just like big mans; you wait for him lift his head and then you go for him. Ain’t you feel scared a bit? Now we take that snake home and show everybody. Nobody ain’t seen in this kawntree so big snake like you kill.’
She went on in this strain until I began to think that I had longed for this opportunity, and had hailed it with joy. Cautiously we went back to the snake; he was still groping with his tail, turning up his ugly belly in the light. A faint, fetid smell came from him, and a thread of green liquid oozed from his crushed head.
‘Look, Tony, that’s his poison,’ I said.
I took a long piece of string from my pocket, and she lifted his head with the spade while I tied a noose around it. We pulled him out straight and measured him by my riding-quirt; he was about five and a half feet long. He had twelve rattles, but they were broken off before they began to taper, so I insisted that he must once have had twenty-four. I explained to Ántonia how this meant that he was twenty-four years old, that he must have been there when white men first came, left on from buffalo and Indian times. As I turned him over, I began to feel proud of him, to have a kind of respect for his age and size. He seemed like the ancient, eldest Evil. Certainly his kind have left horrible unconscious memories in all warm-blooded life. When we dragged him down into the draw, Dude sprang off to the end of his tether and shivered all over—wouldn’t let us come near him.
We decided that Ántonia should ride Dude home, and I would walk. As she rode along slowly, her bare legs swinging against the pony’s sides, she kept shouting back to me about how astonished everybody would be. I followed with the spade over my shoulder, dragging my snake. Her exultation was contagious. The great land had never looked to me so big and free. If the red grass were full of rattlers, I was equal to them all. Nevertheless, I stole furtive glances behind me now and then to see that no avenging mate, older and bigger than my quarry, was racing up from the rear.
The sun had set when we reached our garden and went down the draw toward the house. Otto Fuchs was the first one we met. He was sitting on the edge of the cattle-pond, having a quiet pipe before supper. Ántonia called him to come quick and look. He did not say anything for a minute, but scratched his head and turned the snake over with his boot.
‘Where did you run onto that beauty, Jim?’
‘Up at the dog-town,’ I answered laconically.
‘Kill him yourself? How come you to have a weepon?’
‘We’d been up to Russian Peter’s, to borrow a spade for Ambrosch.’
Otto shook the ashes out of his pipe and squatted down to count the rattles. ‘It was just luck you had a tool,’ he said cautiously. ‘Gosh! I wouldn’t want to do any business with that fellow myself, unless I had a fence-post along. Your grandmother’s snake-cane wouldn’t more than tickle him. He could stand right up and talk to you, he could. Did he fight hard?’
Ántonia broke in: ‘He fight something awful! He is all over Jimmy’s boots. I scream for him to run, but he just hit and hit that snake like he was crazy.’
Otto winked at me. After Ántonia rode on he said: ‘Got him in the head first crack, didn’t you? That was just as well.’
We hung him up to the windmill, and when I went down to the kitchen, I found Ántonia standing in the middle of the floor, telling the story with a great deal of colour.
Subsequent experiences with rattlesnakes taught me that my first encounter was fortunate in circumstance. My big rattler was old, and had led too easy a life; there was not much fight in him. He had probably lived there for years, with a fat prairie-dog for breakfast whenever he felt like it, a sheltered home, even an owl-feather bed, perhaps, and he had forgot that the world doesn’t owe rattlers a living. A snake of his size, in fighting trim, would be more than any boy could handle. So in reality it was a mock adventure; the game was fixed for me by chance, as it probably was for many a dragon-slayer. I had been adequately armed by Russian Peter; the snake was old and lazy; and I had Ántonia beside me, to appreciate and admire.
That snake hung on our corral fence for several days; some of the neighbours came to see it and agreed that it was the biggest rattler ever killed in those parts. This was enough for Ántonia. She liked me better from that time on, and she never took a supercilious air with me again. I had killed a big snake—I was now a big fellow.
My Ántonia, Book 1 (The Shimerdas), Chapter 8 Bridge summary — not the primary text
This is a short recap written for this course, not Willa Cather’s own words, so you can follow the story between close-reading lessons.
{summary}My Ántonia, Book 1 (The Shimerdas), Chapter 9 Bridge summary — not the primary text
This is a short recap written for this course, not Willa Cather’s own words, so you can follow the story between close-reading lessons.
{summary}My Ántonia, Book 1 (The Shimerdas), Chapter 10 Bridge summary — not the primary text
This is a short recap written for this course, not Willa Cather’s own words, so you can follow the story between close-reading lessons.
{summary}My Ántonia, Book 1 (The Shimerdas), Chapter 11 Bridge summary — not the primary text
This is a short recap written for this course, not Willa Cather’s own words, so you can follow the story between close-reading lessons.
{summary}My Ántonia, Book 1 (The Shimerdas), Chapter 12 Bridge summary — not the primary text
This is a short recap written for this course, not Willa Cather’s own words, so you can follow the story between close-reading lessons.
{summary}My Ántonia, Book 1 (The Shimerdas), Chapter 13 Bridge summary — not the primary text
This is a short recap written for this course, not Willa Cather’s own words, so you can follow the story between close-reading lessons.
{summary}