
construct and critique an argument that the universe began in a hot, dense state about 13.8 billion years ago, using redshift data, the cosmic microwave background and the composition of matter.
Instruction
The claim. The Big Bang theory says the universe was once extremely hot and dense and has been expanding and cooling for about 13.8 billion years. It is not an explosion at a point in space; space itself stretches everywhere. A scientific theory is accepted because several independent lines of evidence point the same way. Here are the three main ones.
Evidence 1: redshift and Hubble’s law. Every element absorbs and emits light at fixed wavelengths. Hydrogen’s red line is at 656.3 nm in the lab. In the light of distant galaxies the same pattern of lines appears, but shifted to longer wavelengths: a redshift. The fractional shift is z = Δλ/λ, and for nearby galaxies the recession speed is v ≈ zc.
Worked example. A galaxy’s hydrogen line is observed at 671.0 nm. z = (671.0 − 656.3)/656.3 ≈ 0.0224, so v ≈ 0.0224 × 299,792 km/s ≈ 6,700 km/s. In 1929 Edwin Hubble showed that more distant galaxies recede faster: v = H0d. With H0 ≈ 70 km/s per megaparsec, this galaxy is about 6,700/70 ≈ 96 Mpc away (about 310 million light-years). If everything is moving apart, then running time backward brings everything together. The time since then is roughly 1/H0, which works out to about 14 billion years. (Current measurements of H0 range from about 67 to 73; the disagreement is an active research question, but every value gives an age of 13-15 billion years.)
Evidence 2: the cosmic microwave background (CMB). A hot, dense early universe would have glowed. As space expanded, that glow would be stretched into microwaves. In 1965 Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson found a faint microwave signal coming equally from every direction. Satellites (COBE, WMAP, Planck) have measured it as a nearly perfect thermal spectrum at 2.725 K, the same in every direction to about 1 part in 100,000. Nothing in a universe that has always looked as it does today produces that signal.
Evidence 3: the composition of matter. Big Bang models predict that the first few minutes produced mostly hydrogen and about 25% helium by mass, with a trace of lithium, before the universe cooled too much for fusion. The oldest stars and gas clouds show almost exactly this mix. Stars since then have not had time to make that much helium.
Building a strong argument. A claim-evidence-reasoning (CER) argument states the claim, gives specific data (with numbers and sources), and explains why the data support the claim. A strong argument also answers a counter-claim. For example, “Maybe galaxies are just flying away from us because we are at the center” fails, because observers in any galaxy would see the same pattern: in a uniformly stretching space, every point sees the others receding. Critique any argument, including the sample argument in this lesson, by asking: Is the evidence specific? Does the reasoning connect it to the claim? Is an alternative explanation ruled out?
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Galaxy A is 50 Mpc away and galaxy B is 200 Mpc away. If Hubble’s law holds, how does B’s recession speed compare with A’s?
Which observation would be hardest to explain WITHOUT a hot, dense early universe?
Because nearly every galaxy is redshifted, the Milky Way must be at the center of the universe.
Write a CER argument (claim, at least two pieces of specific evidence with numbers, and reasoning) that the universe began in a hot, dense state. Then critique this sample argument: “The universe started with the Big Bang because almost every galaxy is redshifted. Hubble measured that galaxies move away at 500 km/s for every megaparsec of distance, so the universe is about 2 billion years old. Also, the sky is dark at night.” In two sentences, name the strongest piece of evidence it uses and one place where its numbers or reasoning need correcting (compare Hubble’s 1929 slope with the modern values in this lesson’s reading, and ask what the dark sky actually proves). Finish with a short rebuttal, recorded (about one minute) or written.
How confident are you that you can argue for the Big Bang from redshift, the cosmic microwave background and the composition of matter?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- A galaxy’s hydrogen line (656.3 nm in the lab) is observed at 662.9 nm. Find z and the recession speed.
Check your answer
Answer: z ≈ 0.0101; v ≈ 3,015 km/sz = Δλ/λ; v = zc with c = 299,792 km/s. - Using H0 = 70 km/s/Mpc, how fast does a galaxy 150 Mpc away recede?
Check your answer
Answer: 10,500 km/sv = H0d. - A galaxy recedes at 3,500 km/s. With H0 = 70 km/s/Mpc, how far away is it?
Check your answer
Answer: 50 Mpcd = v / H0.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- A galaxy’s hydrogen line appears at 690.0 nm. Find its speed and distance (H0 = 70 km/s/Mpc).
Check your answer
Answer: z ≈ 0.0513; v ≈ 15,394 km/s; d ≈ 220 Mpcz = (690.0 − 656.3)/656.3. - Estimate the age of the universe as 1/H0 for H0 = 70 km/s/Mpc (1 Mpc = 3.086 × 1019 km; 1 yr = 3.156 × 107 s).
Check your answer
Answer: about 14.0 billion years1/H0 = 3.086 × 1019 / 70 seconds; divide by seconds per year. - Repeat the 1/H0 estimate for H0 = 67 and 73 km/s/Mpc. Does the disagreement change the conclusion that the universe had a beginning?
Check your answer
Answer: about 14.6 and 13.4 billion years; no, both give a finite age of roughly 13-15 billion yearsSame method with each H0.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- The cosmic microwave background has a temperature of 2.725 K. Use Wien’s law (λ = 2.898 × 10−3 m·K / T) to find its peak wavelength, and explain why it is called a microwave background.
Check your answer
Answer: about 1.06 mm, in the microwave bandλ = 2.898 × 10−3 / 2.725 m; millimeter wavelengths are microwaves.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Find the slope of the line through (−6, −9) and (−3, −9).
Check your answer
Answer: m = 0m = (−9 − (−9)) ÷ (−3 − (−6)) = 0 - Convert 60 mL to L.
Check your answer
Answer: 0.0600 L
Hubble’s 1929 Table, the Microwave Background, and Two Values of H0
E. Hubble, ‘A relation between distance and radial velocity among extra-galactic nebulae’, PNAS 15:168-173 (March 15, 1929), Table 1 and the two solutions, as reproduced on NASA’s APOD site; Planck 2018 results VI (arXiv:1807.06209, abstract); Riess et al. 2022 (arXiv:2112.04510, abstract); Fixsen 2009 (arXiv:0911.1955, abstract); Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Origin of the Light Elements; all retrieved November 6, 2026 · Public domain (Hubble 1929 is a 1929 U.S. publication whose data are facts; hosted by NASA), with SLS original worked computations
Why this reading. The argumentation lab asks for a CER argument with “at least two pieces of specific evidence with numbers” and a written critique of the sample argument printed in the lesson. The lesson names the evidence but gives you only its own worked example. Below is the actual 1929 table that started it, the measured temperature of the microwave background, and the two modern measurements of the Hubble constant that disagree. Argue from these.
Table 1. Hubble’s 24 nebulae, 1929
Reproduced from Table 1 of Hubble’s paper. r is his estimated distance in millions of parsecs (Mpc); v is the measured radial velocity in km/s, positive for receding. “S. Mag.” and “L. Mag.” are the Small and Large Magellanic Clouds; the rest are NGC catalog numbers (NGC 224 is the Andromeda galaxy, M31).
| Object | r (Mpc) | v (km/s) | Object | r (Mpc) | v (km/s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S. Mag. | 0.032 | +170 | NGC 3627 | 0.9 | +650 |
| L. Mag. | 0.034 | +290 | NGC 4826 | 0.9 | +150 |
| NGC 6822 | 0.214 | −130 | NGC 5236 | 0.9 | +500 |
| NGC 598 | 0.263 | −70 | NGC 1068 | 1.0 | +920 |
| NGC 221 | 0.275 | −185 | NGC 5055 | 1.1 | +450 |
| NGC 224 | 0.275 | −220 | NGC 7331 | 1.1 | +500 |
| NGC 5457 | 0.45 | +200 | NGC 4258 | 1.4 | +500 |
| NGC 4736 | 0.5 | +290 | NGC 4151 | 1.7 | +960 |
| NGC 5194 | 0.5 | +270 | NGC 4382 | 2.0 | +500 |
| NGC 4449 | 0.63 | +200 | NGC 4472 | 2.0 | +850 |
| NGC 4214 | 0.8 | +300 | NGC 4486 | 2.0 | +800 |
| NGC 3031 | 0.9 | −30 | NGC 4649 | 2.0 | +1,090 |
Hubble fitted a line through these points, after correcting for the Sun’s own motion, and reported K = +465 ± 50 km/s per Mpc from the 24 objects taken singly and +513 ± 60 from nine groups, settling on a round 500 km/s per Mpc. A plain least-squares line through the 24 raw points in the table (no solar-motion correction) gives v = −41 + 454 r, slope 454 km/s per Mpc; a line forced through the origin gives 424. Plot the table and draw your own; the scatter is real and the trend is unmistakable.
What was right and what was wrong
The trend, velocity proportional to distance, has held up for a century. The slope has not: modern values are about seven times smaller. Hubble’s distances were far too short, because the stars he used as distance markers were misidentified and the distance scale of the day was miscalibrated. The lesson’s own worked example uses H0 ≈ 70 km/s per Mpc: a galaxy receding at 6,700 km/s is about 96 Mpc away, not the 13 Mpc Hubble’s constant would give. Two studies of the same relation, one giving 500 and one giving 70, is exactly the situation the CER critique is for. The claim survived; the number was corrected by better distances.
Table 2. Two modern measurements of H0
| Team and method | H0 (km/s per Mpc) | 1/H0 in years |
|---|---|---|
| Planck Collaboration 2018, from the microwave background (A&A 641, A6, 2020) | 67.4 ± 0.5 | 14.5 billion |
| Riess and others (SH0ES) 2022, from Cepheid stars and supernovae | 73.04 ± 1.04 | 13.4 billion |
| Hubble 1929, for comparison | about 500 | 2.0 billion |
Turning H0 into a time. One megaparsec is 3.086 × 1019 km. So 1/H0 for 70 km/s per Mpc is 3.086 × 1019 / 70 = 4.41 × 1017 s, and dividing by 3.156 × 107 s per year gives 13.97 billion years, the lesson’s “about 14 billion”. For 67.4 it is 14.5 billion; for 73.04 it is 13.4 billion. This simple estimate assumes the expansion rate never changed; a full model that includes matter and dark energy gives about 13.8 billion years for either value of H0. Riess and others describe the gap between 67.4 and 73.04 as a five-sigma disagreement whose cause is unknown. Both numbers still put the beginning 13 to 15 billion years ago, which is why the true/false item in the lesson says the disagreement does not touch the conclusion.
The redshift example, checked
A hydrogen line observed at 671.0 nm against 656.3 nm in the laboratory: z = (671.0 − 656.3)/656.3 = 14.7/656.3 = 0.02240. Speed: 0.02240 × 299,792 km/s = 6,715 km/s. Distance at 70 km/s per Mpc: 6,715/70 = 95.9 Mpc. At 67.4 it is 99.6 Mpc, at 73.04 it is 91.9 Mpc. The uncertainty in H0 becomes an 8% uncertainty in every distance found this way.
Table 3. The microwave background
| Measurement | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Temperature of the cosmic microwave background | 2.72548 ± 0.00057 K | Fixsen 2009, combining COBE FIRAS with other measurements |
| FIRAS recalibrated against WMAP | 2.7260 ± 0.0013 K | Fixsen 2009 |
| Helium made in the first minutes | about 25% of ordinary matter by mass (the Sun’s is about 30%, because stars have since turned some hydrogen into helium) | Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Origin of the Light Elements |
A hot, dense early universe predicts a glow that has been stretched by expansion into microwaves with a thermal (blackbody) spectrum, the same in every direction. The measured spectrum is thermal to high precision at 2.725 K. Nothing in the present-day sky, no star or galaxy or dust cloud, makes a uniform 2.7 K glow. The lesson’s 2.725 K is this number rounded. The same early hot phase predicts that about a quarter of ordinary matter by mass emerged as helium, before any star existed; Berkeley Lab’s summary calls a helium abundance of about 25% by mass a robust prediction that depends only on the early universe having passed through a hot, dense phase, and it is what is observed in material believed to be primordial. That is the lesson’s 25%.
Building the argument
A strong claim-evidence-reasoning paragraph names a number, names where it came from, and says why it matters. “Hubble’s 1929 table shows the four most distant nebulae, at about 2 Mpc, receding at 500 to 1,090 km/s, while the nearest recede at under 300 km/s or approach; velocity grows with distance” is evidence. “The microwave background is 2.72548 K in every direction (Fixsen 2009)” is evidence. “Everything is redshifted” is not, until you say by how much and how it was measured. For your critique, look for an argument that cites Hubble’s slope of 500 as if it were still accepted, or that treats the 67.4 versus 73.04 disagreement as doubt about expansion rather than about its exact rate.
Checking the lesson’s sample argument
The sample argument says galaxies recede at 500 km/s per megaparsec, so the universe is about 2 billion years old. Its arithmetic is right for that slope: 3.086 × 1019 ÷ 500 = 6.17 × 1016 s, and dividing by 3.156 × 107 s per year gives 1.96 billion years (Table 2). The number is the problem: Hubble’s 1929 slope was about seven times too large, and an age of 2 billion years is less than half the age of Earth itself (about 4.54 billion years, from meteorites and lead isotopes; USGS), which is one of the reasons astronomers knew the distance scale had to be fixed. Its strongest evidence is the redshift pattern, but it never says that redshift grows with distance, which is the part that implies expansion. And “the sky is dark at night” is not evidence a reader can check from this unit’s data: it names no measurement and gives no reasoning. A strong rebuttal replaces it with the 2.72548 K microwave background (Table 3) or the 25% helium abundance.
Sources: Hubble 1929, PNAS 15:168, as reproduced by NASA (APOD) (apod.nasa.gov); Planck Collaboration, Planck 2018 results VI: Cosmological parameters (arXiv:1807.06209) (arxiv.org); Riess et al. 2022, local value of the Hubble constant (arXiv:2112.04510) (arxiv.org); Fixsen 2009, The Temperature of the Cosmic Microwave Background (arXiv:0911.1955) (arxiv.org); Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, Origin of the Light Elements (aether.lbl.gov)