
construct and defend a written argument, with a rebuttal, that hydrogen bonding rather than molar mass explains why ethanol boils far above dimethyl ether, using NIST boiling-point and vapor-pressure data.
Instruction
A Missouri puzzle. Missouri’s ethanol plants can produce 287 million gallons of ethanol a year, according to the Missouri Department of Natural Resources, which ranks the state 13th in the nation; about 1,086 million liters. Ethanol is made by fermenting sugars from plant material, and the fermented mixture is mostly water, so plants separate the ethanol by heating it: ethanol boils near 78.4 °C and water at 100.0 °C, a gap of 21.7 K. Now compare ethanol, C2H6O, with its isomer dimethyl ether, also C2H6O. Both molecules have the same atoms and the same molar mass, 46.069 g/mol. Yet NIST lists the normal boiling point of ethanol as 351.5 K and of dimethyl ether as 248.2 K, a difference of 103.3 K. Dimethyl ether is a gas at room temperature; ethanol is a liquid. Mass cannot explain that. What can?
Boiling is separating molecules. The normal boiling point is the temperature at which a liquid’s vapor pressure equals 1 atmosphere (101.325 kPa). To boil, molecules need enough energy to overcome the attractions to their neighbors. The stronger the intermolecular forces, the higher the temperature. The covalent bonds inside each molecule are not broken. For ethanol, NIST reports an average enthalpy of vaporization of 42.3 kJ/mol, so converting 1.00 kg of ethanol (21.71 mol) from liquid to vapor takes about 21.71 × 42.3 = 918 kJ.
The London-force baseline. For nonpolar alkanes, only London dispersion forces act, and they grow with molar mass. Using NIST boiling points, butane (58.124 g/mol) boils at 273 K and hexane (86.178 g/mol) at 341.9 K, a slope of (341.9 − 273) ÷ (86.178 − 58.124) = 2.46 K per g/mol. Extending that line to heptane (100.205 g/mol) predicts 376.3 K; NIST lists 371.5 K, so the line overshoots by 4.8 K (1.3%). It is a good model but not perfect: the trend flattens as molecules get larger. The same idea gives a London-only baseline for a molecule of mass 46.069: between propane (231.1 K) and butane (273 K) the baseline is about 237 K.
Reading the gap. Dimethyl ether boils at 248.2 K, only 11 K above the 237 K baseline. That small excess is what a modest dipole (1.302 D) adds. Ethanol boils 115 K above the baseline, ten times more, because its O–H group forms hydrogen bonds: the hydrogen on one molecule is attracted to a lone pair on the oxygen of the next. Dimethyl ether has oxygen but no O–H, so its molecules can accept hydrogen bonds but cannot donate them to each other. The same signature appears across families. In the hydrides, methane is lighter and boils lower than silane (CH4 minus SiH4 = -51 K, the normal trend), but NH3, H2O and HF boil far above their heavier neighbors PH3, H2S and HCl by 54, 160.3 and 104.7 K.
Building the argument. A scientific argument has a claim (a statement you could be wrong about), evidence (specific data), reasoning (the particle-level principle linking them), and a rebuttal (why the best counter-claim fails). Your claim: ethanol’s boiling point is 103.3 K above dimethyl ether’s because ethanol molecules form hydrogen bonds. A counter-claim: “heavier molecules boil higher.” Rebuttal: the masses are equal, and ethanol (46.069 g/mol) boils 9.6 K above hexane (86.178 g/mol), which is almost twice as heavy.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Ethanol and dimethyl ether both have the formula C2H6O. Before you open the data, which do you predict boils at the higher temperature?
Use the same-mass family table in this lesson’s reading (butane, acetone, 1-propanol, acetic acid). Which statement about those four molecules, each close to 58 to 60 g/mol, does the data support?
Because ethanol (46.069 g/mol) boils at a higher temperature than hexane (86.178 g/mol), molar mass alone cannot predict boiling point.
Ethanol and dimethyl ether both have a molar mass of g/mol, but their NIST boiling points differ by K.
Write a four-part argument (claim, evidence, reasoning, rebuttal) that hydrogen bonding explains why ethanol boils above dimethyl ether. Use at least three numbers from this lesson’s reading, name the counter-claim “heavier molecules always boil higher,” and rebut it with one pair of substances from the data.
How confident are you that you can build an evidence-based argument about boiling point from the types of intermolecular forces, and rebut a counter-claim with data?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- The NIST boiling points are 351.5 K for ethanol and 248.2 K for dimethyl ether. Find the difference in kelvins.
Check your answer
Answer: 103.3 K351.5 − 248.2 = 103.3 K. A difference in kelvins equals the same difference in °C. - Calculate the molar mass of ethanol, C2H6O, and of dimethyl ether, CH3OCH3.
Check your answer
Answer: Both 46.069 g/mol (about 46.07)2(12.011) + 6(1.008) + 15.999 = 46.069. They are isomers, so the formula and molar mass are the same. - Convert the boiling points of ethanol (351.5 K) and water (373.17 K) to °C and find the gap.
Check your answer
Answer: 78.35 °C and 100.02 °C; gap 21.67 K351.5 − 273.15 = 78.35; 373.17 − 273.15 = 100.02; 373.17 − 351.5 = 21.67. - Find the slope of boiling point against molar mass between propane (44.097 g/mol, 231.1 K) and butane (58.124 g/mol, 273 K).
Check your answer
Answer: 2.99 K per g/mol(273 − 231.1) ÷ (58.124 − 44.097) = 41.9 ÷ 14.027 = 2.99. - Which of these can form hydrogen bonds with molecules of its own kind: CH3CH2OH, CH3OCH3, CH3COCH3, CH3COOH?
Check your answer
Answer: CH3CH2OH and CH3COOHEach needs an O–H group to donate a hydrogen; the ether and the ketone have O but no O–H. - NIST gives an average enthalpy of vaporization of 42.3 kJ/mol for ethanol. How much energy does it take to vaporize 1.00 kg?
Check your answer
Answer: About 918 kJ1,000 g ÷ 46.069 g/mol = 21.71 mol; 21.71 × 42.3 = 918 kJ. - Missouri’s ethanol plants can produce 287 million gallons a year (Missouri DNR). Convert to millions of liters (1 gal = 3.785 L).
Check your answer
Answer: About 1,086 million liters287 × 3.7854 = 1,086 million L.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Using the line through butane and hexane (slope 2.46 K per g/mol), predict the boiling point of heptane (100.205 g/mol) and compare it with NIST’s 371.5 K.
Check your answer
Answer: Predicted 376.3 K; the line overshoots by 4.8 K (1.3%).341.9 + 2.46 × (100.205 − 86.178) = 376.3 K. Error = 376.3 − 371.5 = 4.8 K, or 1.3%. - Interpolating between propane and butane gives a London-only baseline of about 237 K for a molecule of mass 46.069 g/mol. By how many kelvins do ethanol (351.5 K) and dimethyl ether (248.2 K) exceed the baseline? What does each excess say about its forces?
Check your answer
Answer: Ethanol 115 K above; dimethyl ether 11 K above. Ethanol’s large excess reflects hydrogen bonding; the ether’s small excess reflects a modest dipole.351.5 − 237.0 = 115; 248.2 − 237.0 = 11. - Boiling points (K): H2O 373.17, H2S 212.87; HF 292.7, HCl 188; NH3 240, PH3 186. Compute how far above its heavier neighbor each period-2 hydride boils and rank the three.
Check your answer
Answer: H2O 160.3 K > HF 104.7 K > NH3 54 K373.17 − 212.87 = 160.30; 292.7 − 188 = 104.7; 240 − 186 = 54. Water can form up to two hydrogen bonds per molecule as donor and two as acceptor, so its network is the strongest. - A plant heats a fermented mixture. Using NIST boiling points of ethanol (351.5 K) and water (373.17 K), explain why ethanol-rich vapor leaves first and give the temperature gap. (Ignore the fact that the two form a mixture that cannot be fully separated by one distillation.)
Check your answer
Answer: Ethanol’s weaker forces (fewer hydrogen bonds per molecule than water) mean it reaches 1 atm vapor pressure at a lower temperature, by 21.7 K.373.17 − 351.5 = 21.67 K. The more volatile component is enriched in the vapor.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- A student claims, “Ethanol boils higher than hexane because ethanol has a greater molar mass.” Use NIST data (ethanol 46.069 g/mol, 351.5 K; hexane 86.178 g/mol, 341.9 K) to rebut the claim and state the correct reasoning.
Check your answer
Answer: The claim is false: hexane is nearly twice as heavy yet boils 9.6 K lower. Ethanol’s hydrogen bonds outweigh hexane’s larger London forces.351.5 − 341.9 = 9.6 K. Ethanol is the lighter molecule, so mass cannot be the cause. - Acetic acid (60.052 g/mol, 391.2 K) boils 20.9 K above 1-propanol (60.096 g/mol, 370.3 K), though both hydrogen-bond and have almost the same mass. Propose a particle-level explanation and one way to test it.
Check your answer
Answer: Acetic acid molecules can pair into dimers joined by two hydrogen bonds, giving stronger overall attraction. Test: compare vapor-pressure or enthalpy-of-vaporization data for the two liquids.391.2 − 370.3 = 20.9 K. The carboxylic acid group has both a hydrogen-bond donor (O–H) and a good acceptor (C=O) in one group.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Count the valence electrons in ethanol, C2H6O, and describe the shape around its oxygen atom.
Check your answer
Answer: 20 valence electrons; bent around oxygen (two bonds and two lone pairs, four electron domains)2(4) + 6(1) + 6 = 20. Oxygen is bonded to one C and one H and has two lone pairs, so VSEPR predicts a bent arrangement like water. - Methanol’s NIST dipole moment is 1.672 D and methane’s is 0 D, and their molar masses are 32.042 and 16.043 g/mol. Name the strongest intermolecular force in each and say which should have the higher boiling point.
Check your answer
Answer: Methanol: hydrogen bonding; methane: London dispersion only. Methanol should boil higher (NIST: 337.8 K versus 111 K).Methanol has an O–H group and is polar; methane is a symmetric, nonpolar molecule with fewer electrons.
Boiling Points, Hydrogen Bonding and Missouri Ethanol: NIST Data Set
NIST Chemistry WebBook phase-change data and Antoine parameters; NIST CCCBDB dipole moments; Missouri DNR, Biofuels (citing Renewable Fuels Association, 2021 Ethanol Industry Outlook); SLS calculations; retrieved Nov. 15, 2026 · Public domain (NIST data and Missouri government works), with SLS calculations
Why this reading. The lesson asks you to argue from NIST boiling-point and vapor-pressure data. This reading collects that data in one place: the alkane series, a same-mass family that isolates the effect of force type, the hydrides of groups 14 to 17, and the ethanol and dimethyl ether pair, plus the Missouri ethanol facts and every difference computed so you can check your own arithmetic.
Alkanes: London forces and molar mass
Normal boiling points from the NIST Chemistry WebBook (phase change data, the NIST average value). Molar masses are SLS calculations from NIST conventional atomic weights (H 1.008, C 12.011).
| Alkane | Molar mass (g/mol) | Boiling point (K) | Boiling point (°C) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Methane, CH4 | 16.043 | 111.0 | -162.1 |
| Ethane, C2H6 | 30.070 | 184.6 | -88.5 |
| Propane, C3H8 | 44.097 | 231.1 | -42.0 |
| Butane, C4H10 | 58.124 | 273.0 | -0.1 |
| Pentane, C5H12 | 72.151 | 309.2 | 36.1 |
| Hexane, C6H14 | 86.178 | 341.9 | 68.8 |
| Heptane, C7H16 | 100.205 | 371.5 | 98.4 |
| Octane, C8H18 | 114.232 | 398.7 | 125.6 |
SLS calculations: slope between butane and hexane = 2.456 K per g/mol; predicted heptane 376.3 K versus 371.5 K (error 4.8 K); predicted octane 410.8 K versus 398.7 K, so the line overshoots more as molecules grow. Propane to butane slope = 2.987 K per g/mol; London-only baseline for a 46.069 g/mol molecule = 237.0 K.
Same mass, different forces
Four liquids with molar masses between 58 and 61 g/mol. Acetone’s dipole moment, 2.880 D, is the experimental value from NIST CCCBDB.
| Substance | Strongest force | Molar mass (g/mol) | Boiling point (K) | Boiling point (°C) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Butane, C4H10 | London dispersion only | 58.124 | 273.0 | -0.1 |
| Acetone, C3H6O | Dipole-dipole (2.880 D) | 58.080 | 329.3 | 56.2 |
| 1-Propanol, C3H8O | Hydrogen bonding | 60.096 | 370.3 | 97.2 |
| Acetic acid, C2H4O2 | Hydrogen bonding (strong dimers) | 60.052 | 391.2 | 118.1 |
Range across the family: 391.2 − 273 = 118.2 K at nearly constant mass.
Ethanol, its twin, and water
| Substance | Formula | Molar mass (g/mol) | Dipole (D) | Boiling point (K) | Boiling point (°C) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ethanol | CH3CH2OH | 46.069 | 1.679 | 351.5 | 78.35 |
| Dimethyl ether | CH3OCH3 | 46.069 | 1.302 | 248.2 | -24.95 |
| Methanol | CH3OH | 32.042 | 1.672 | 337.8 | 64.65 |
| 1-Propanol | C3H7OH | 60.096 | 1.550 (trans) | 370.3 | 97.15 |
| 1-Butanol | C4H9OH | 74.123 | not used | 390.6 | 117.45 |
| Water | H2O | 18.015 | 1.857 | 373.17 | 100.02 |
Differences: ethanol minus dimethyl ether = 103.3 K; water minus ethanol = 21.67 K; ethanol minus hexane = 9.6 K. NIST lists an average enthalpy of vaporization for ethanol of 42.3 kJ/mol, so 1.00 kg (21.71 mol) takes about 918 kJ. Ethanol’s vapor pressure computed from NIST Antoine parameters is 7.87 kPa at 25 °C and 46.9 kPa at 60 °C, a factor of 6.0.
Hydrides of groups 14 to 17
Methane, hydrogen sulfide, water and hydrogen fluoride boiling points are NIST WebBook values. The others are computed by SLS from NIST Antoine-equation parameters at 1.01325 bar (a few fall a fraction of a kelvin outside the range the equation was fitted to, so treat them as good to about a kelvin).
| Group | Period-2 hydride | Boiling point (K) | Heavier hydrides | Boiling point (K) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 14 | CH4 | 111 | SiH4 | 162 |
| 15 | NH3 | 240 | PH3 / AsH3 | 186 / 211 |
| 16 | H2O | 373.2 | H2S / H2Se / H2Te | 212.9 / 232 / 271 |
| 17 | HF | 292.7 | HCl / HBr | 188 / 207 |
Period-2 minus period-3 boiling point: CH4 − SiH4 = -51 K; NH3 − PH3 = 54 K; H2O − H2S = 160.3 K; HF − HCl = 104.7 K.
Missouri ethanol
The Missouri Department of Natural Resources reports that ethanol is produced by fermenting sugars from plant materials such as corn, and that one common blend is E10, 10% ethanol with 90% gasoline. Citing the Renewable Fuels Association’s 2021 Ethanol Industry Outlook, it states that Missouri ranks 13th in ethanol production, that Missouri’s ethanol plants can produce 287 million gallons each year, and that this is roughly 1.6% of the 17.4 billion gallons produced annually in the United States. In liters: 287 × 3.7854 = 1,086 million L (SLS conversion).
Sources: NIST Chemistry WebBook: ethanol (phase change data, enthalpy of vaporization, Antoine parameters) (webbook.nist.gov); NIST Chemistry WebBook: dimethyl ether (webbook.nist.gov); NIST Chemistry WebBook: water (webbook.nist.gov); NIST Chemistry WebBook: methane through octane, methanol, 1-propanol, 1-butanol, acetone, acetic acid, hydrogen sulfide, hydrogen fluoride and the other hydrides (phase change data and Antoine parameters) (webbook.nist.gov); NIST CCCBDB, experimental dipole moments (cccbdb.nist.gov); Missouri Department of Natural Resources, Biofuels (dnr.mo.gov); NIST, Atomic Weights and Isotopic Compositions (physics.nist.gov)