
use the periodic table and electron configurations to explain lead’s properties, support the claims with sourced data, and state criteria and constraints for a Missouri lead-safety problem.
Instruction
The task. You have spent four lessons building the tools: atoms and isotopes (1.1), patterns tested in the lab (1.2), arguments from NIST data (1.3) and electron configurations (1.4). Now you use them together in an element brief on lead, a short, sourced explanation that starts at lead’s place in the periodic table and ends at a real Missouri question: why is this element both useful and hazardous?
Structure of a strong brief. Move in the same order as the periodic-table model. First, identity: atomic number 82, Group 14, period 6, the isotopes and the average atomic mass you compute (about 207.2 u). Second, electrons: four valence electrons, with the configuration from Lesson 1.4. Third, properties from position: lead is a metal, so it is dense, malleable and tends to lose electrons; the NIST energies show that losing two costs 22.4 eV while losing four costs 96.7 eV, so Pb2+ is the ion you expect in galena. Fourth, use: why batteries, why recycling. Fifth, hazard: the documented Missouri record. Last, an engineering step with criteria and constraints.
Worked example: formula checks from charges. In galena, Pb2+ pairs with S2−: the charges cancel one to one, so the formula is PbS. Pb4+ with oxide would need two O2− to cancel +4, so the formula is PbO2: +4 + 2 × (−2) = 0. Checking charges is a way to test your own claims.
Use evidence honestly. Put the source after every number from an agency. Use only documented facts for Missouri: EPA’s counts for 2009 and 2010 are records of those dates, and your brief should say so. Do not claim anything about conditions today unless you cite a current source. If your data contradict the simple trend, as lead’s ionization energy (7.417 eV) does against tin’s (7.344 eV), say so and explain what you can and cannot conclude.
Criteria and constraints. Engineers begin a design problem by stating what a solution must do (criteria) and what limits it must work within (constraints), each measurable. Example: a criterion is that a soil check reports mg/kg so it can be compared with 400 mg/kg; a constraint is that sampling must not carry lead dust into a home. Write at least two of each for your own problem, with how each would be measured. The source file in this lesson’s reading has a worked example and a checklist. Plan first, check your draft against the criteria list on your own or with a parent or guardian, revise, then record your presentation and answer the defense question with evidence.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Lead can form Pb4+. Using charges, what is the formula of the compound of Pb4+ and oxide, O2−?
Use the isotope table in this lesson’s reading. Lead’s average atomic mass, rounded to one decimal place, is u.
‘The soil check must not carry lead dust into the home’ is an example of a constraint.
Draft your plan using this lesson’s reading: list three claims about lead, the evidence and source for each, and one criterion and one constraint for a Missouri lead-safety problem. Mark any claim that the documented facts cannot support.
How confident are you that you can use the periodic table to explain an element’s properties and frame an engineering problem with measurable criteria and constraints?
Unit 1 checkpoint
Do this before you start the task. It covers the whole unit and tells you what to review first.
A neutral atom has 82 protons and 126 neutrons. What is its mass number?
Which pair are isotopes?
Using the NIST values in Lesson 1.3’s reading, which of lithium, sodium, potassium or magnesium has the lowest first ionization energy?
Magnesium bubbled vigorously in vinegar and copper did not. The best explanation is that
An element’s successive ionization energies are 5.99, 18.83, 28.45 and 119.99 eV. How many valence electrons does it have?
Which hydrogen photon carries more energy, the 410.1734 nm violet line or the 656.279 nm red line, and why?
Which statement is a criterion, not a constraint, for a yard-soil lead check?
The sum of lead’s first two ionization energies is eV (one decimal place, using the NIST values in Lesson 1.3’s reading).
Iron’s neutral-atom configuration is [Ar] 3d 4s.
400 ppm of lead in soil means 400 mg of lead per kilogram of soil.
Isotopes of an element differ in their number of protons.
Copper’s ground configuration is [Ar] 3d9 4s2.
Because aluminum’s ionization energy is lower than magnesium’s, aluminum must bubble faster in vinegar than magnesium.
Submit: Element Brief on Lead (800-1,100 words) + four-minute presentation
Task: Write an element brief on lead. Explain its position in the periodic table, its isotopes and the average atomic mass you compute from NIST data, its electron configuration and valence electrons, and why Pb2+ is the ion in galena (use NIST ionization energies). Compare it with tin or another Group 14 element and acknowledge the exception in the data. Explain why lead is useful (batteries, recycling) and why it is hazardous, using only documented Missouri facts from this lesson’s reading. Finish with at least two criteria and two constraints, each with a way to measure it, for a Missouri lead-safety problem of your choice (for example, checking yard soil against EPA’s 400 ppm level). Include one data table and at least three cited sources from the reading (NIST, USGS, EPA, ATSDR or Missouri DNR).
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 – Plan. Outline with your claims, the evidence for each (NIST values, Missouri facts and your lab or reading data) and a list of sources.
- Stage 2 – Reviewed draft. Check each property claim for electron-based reasoning and each number against its source using the checklist in the reading, or ask a parent, guardian or other reader to check it with you; keep the marked-up checklist and your revision plan.
- Stage 3 – Final brief. 800-1,100 words with a data table, the average-atomic-mass calculation, the PbS and PbO2 charge checks, and your criteria and constraints.
- Stage 4 – Presentation and defense. Four minutes, recorded, ending with your answer to this defense question: which single piece of evidence in your brief is strongest, and what would change your conclusion?
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Periodic table as a model (9-12.PS1.A.1) | Predicts lead’s ions, formulas and properties from its position, valence electrons and ionization-energy data, with correct reasoning. |
| Use of data (SEP.8, RST.9-10.1) | Cites NIST values and Missouri facts accurately with the source named, and acknowledges the Group 14 exception. |
| Calculation (CCC.3) | Average atomic mass computed correctly with the method shown; charge checks for PbS and PbO2 correct. |
| Criteria and constraints (9-12.ETS1.A.1) | At least two criteria and two constraints, each measurable, including a health or safety constraint, tied to a Missouri lead problem. |
| Communication (SEP.8, RST.9-10.9) | Clear structure with claims separated from documented facts; the recorded presentation answers the defense question with evidence. |
Source File for the Lead Element Brief
EPA news releases (Oct. 26, 2009; Oct. 8, 2010); Missouri DNR PUB0659; USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2024; ATSDR ToxFAQs; NIST isotope and ionization-energy data; SLS calculations; retrieved 2026-11-15 · Public domain (U.S. government and Missouri state agency facts, NIST data), with SLS commentary and worked examples
Why this reading. This is the source file for the Lesson 1.5 element brief on lead. Every number and claim you may cite is here with its source, so you can spend your time on explaining instead of searching. Cite the source named beside each fact, not this reading. Anything you add from elsewhere needs its own source and a check against these values.
Element card: lead
| Item | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Atomic number, symbol | 82, Pb (from Latin plumbum) | Missouri DNR PUB0659 |
| Position | Group 14, period 6 | Periodic table |
| Ground configuration | [Xe] 4f14 5d10 6s2 6p2; four valence electrons | NIST Atomic Spectra Database (written there as [Hg] 6p2) |
| Natural isotopes | Pb-204 (1.4%), Pb-206 (24.1%), Pb-207 (22.1%), Pb-208 (52.4%) | NIST isotopic compositions |
| Average atomic mass (computed) | 207.217 u, published as 207.2 | SLS calculation from NIST values |
| First four ionization energies (eV) | 7.417, 15.032, 31.937, 42.333 | NIST Ionization Energies Form |
| Energy to remove two / four electrons | 22.449 eV / 96.719 eV (4.31 times as much) | SLS sum of NIST values |
| Group 14 comparison: first ionization energy (eV) | C 11.260; Si 8.152; Ge 7.899; Sn 7.344; Pb 7.417 | NIST Ionization Energies Form |
| Physical properties | Soft, very dense, ductile, malleable and corrosion-resistant metal | Missouri DNR PUB0659 |
| Main ore | Galena, PbS (Missouri’s state mineral); 86.60% lead by mass using Pb 207.2 and S 32.06 | Missouri DNR PUB0659; SLS calculation |
Uses and Missouri mining
| Fact | Source |
|---|---|
| Lead-acid batteries account for about 85% of U.S. lead consumption. | MDNR PUB0659; USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2024 |
| In 2023 lead was produced in the United States by five lead mines in Missouri plus byproduct production in Alaska and Idaho. | USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2024 |
| In 2023 an estimated 1,000,000 tons of secondary (recycled) lead was produced, equivalent to 62% of apparent domestic consumption. Nearly all secondary lead came from old scrap, mostly lead-acid batteries. | USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2024 |
| The Viburnum Trend (1955 to present) is in Crawford, Dent, Iron, Reynolds, Shannon and Washington counties and produces lead with zinc, copper and silver. Missouri has mined lead for more than 300 years. | MDNR PUB0659 |
| Lead is used in batteries, ammunition and metal products such as solder and pipes. Use as an additive in automobile gasoline was banned in the United States in 1996. | ATSDR ToxFAQs for Lead |
Hazard and the Missouri record
| Fact | Source |
|---|---|
| Lead is an element, so it does not break down. In soil, lead can stick to soil particles; when released into the air it may be carried long distances before it lands. | ATSDR ToxFAQs for Lead |
| EPA described lead as one of the most dangerous neurotoxins in the environment and said that infants and young children are at greatest risk from lead exposure, which even at low levels can cause behavioral problems, learning deficits and lowered IQ (statement by an EPA assistant administrator, 2010). | EPA news release, Oct. 8, 2010 |
| 2009 sampling near the Herculaneum smelter: 372 properties sampled, 129 (34.7%) with at least one area above the 400 ppm action level, 104 of those already cleaned up within nine years. EPA called this recontamination. | EPA Region 7 news release, Oct. 26, 2009 |
| 2010 settlement: the smelter’s owner agreed to shut the Herculaneum smelter by Dec. 31, 2013; EPA issued an order to sample residential properties within 1.5 miles and clean up those at 400 ppm or higher; the settlement also covered cleanup and permit work at mining and milling facilities in southeast Missouri. | EPA news release, Oct. 8, 2010 |
These are what the agencies reported on those dates. They are not claims about conditions today, and the brief must not make any.
Criteria and constraints: a worked example
Problem: a Missouri family wants a method to check whether yard soil is above EPA’s 400 ppm level. A criterion is something the solution must achieve: for example, “reports lead concentration in mg/kg so it can be compared with 400 mg/kg.” A constraint is a limit it must stay within: for example, “uses a sampling step that does not put lead dust on the family’s hands or into the house.” Each should be measurable: 400 ppm is 400 mg of lead per kilogram of soil, so a 250 g sample at the action level holds 100 mg of lead.
Checklist for the brief
- Position, configuration and valence electrons stated and tied to at least one property.
- Average atomic mass computed with the calculation shown.
- At least one NIST ionization-energy comparison, with the Group 14 exception acknowledged.
- Every Missouri or agency fact followed by its source.
- Formula checks from charges: PbS (Pb2+ and S2−) and PbO2 (Pb4+ and two O2−).
- At least two criteria and two constraints, each with a way to measure it.
Sources
All items retrieved 2026-11-15. NIST values are public-domain data; EPA, ATSDR, USGS and Missouri DNR statements are government works, paraphrased here with the source named in each row.
Sources: Missouri Department of Natural Resources, Missouri Geological Survey, “Lead,” PUB0659 (Oct. 8, 2020) (dnr.mo.gov); U.S. Geological Survey, Mineral Commodity Summaries 2024: Lead (pubs.usgs.gov); U.S. EPA Region 7 news release, “Tests Show Recontamination of Soils in Herculaneum, Mo., from Doe Run Resources Corporation Lead Smelting Operation,” Oct. 26, 2009 (epa.gov); U.S. EPA, Justice Department and Missouri DNR news release, “North America’s Largest Lead Producer to Spend $65 Million for Environmental Violations at Missouri Facilities,” Oct. 8, 2010 (epa.gov); ATSDR (CDC), ToxFAQs for Lead (atsdr.cdc.gov); NIST, Atomic Weights and Isotopic Compositions with Relative Atomic Masses (Physical Measurement Laboratory) (physics.nist.gov); NIST Atomic Spectra Database, Ionization Energies Form (physics.nist.gov)