
explain how a material’s particle-level structure produces the properties that make it suitable for a Missouri application, and recommend one material over an alternative using prioritized criteria and constraints.
Instruction
Your job. Engineers rarely ask “what is the best material?” They ask “what is the best material for this job, under these limits?” This task asks you to answer that question for a Missouri application using everything in Unit 2: bonding type, shape and polarity, intermolecular forces and the structure of metals, ceramics, network solids and polymers. You will pick one scenario from the source file in this lesson’s reading, compare at least two candidate materials, and defend one recommendation.
Step 1: define criteria and constraints. A criterion is something you want more or less of (strength, low cost, low mass). A constraint is a limit that cannot be broken (must not melt below a given temperature, must not shatter if struck). Constraints eliminate candidates; criteria rank the survivors. Write at least three criteria and rank them by priority, with a reason for the top one. State any constraint as a number or a yes/no test.
Step 2: explain each property from structure. For every property you claim, write the three-link chain from Lesson 2.4: structure (which particles and how arranged), force (what holds them and what happens under stress or heat) and function (what that lets the material do). “Aluminum is light and strong” is a claim; a chain names the metallic lattice and the 2.70 g/cm3 density from the reading. Back each chain with at least one number from the reading and cite the source.
Step 3: compute. Cost per metric ton alone can mislead, because a pipe or rail is bought by volume. The reading shows how to convert: cost per cubic meter = price per metric ton × density in metric tons per cubic meter, which equals the density in g/cm3. For aluminum at $3,968 per metric ton and 2.70 g/cm3 that is $10,714 per cubic meter, while copper at $10,803 per metric ton and 8.96 g/cm3 costs $96,792 per cubic meter: copper is about 9.0 times as costly per volume. These are raw-material prices, not finished parts, so say so in your brief.
Step 4: score and test the recommendation. A weighted decision matrix scores each candidate from 1 to 5 on each criterion, multiplies by the criterion’s weight (weights add to 100%) and adds the results. The reading works an example: with weights of 35% corrosion resistance, 30% cost, 25% strength and 10% low mass, aluminum scores 3.90 and steel 3.65, so aluminum wins. Move 10 points of weight from corrosion to cost and the totals become 3.70 and 3.95, and steel wins. That is a sensitivity test, and it is honest: it shows your recommendation depends on your priorities. Your brief must say which weight change would flip your choice.
Step 5: communicate and defend. Write the brief, draw one labeled structure diagram, then record a four-minute presentation that ends by answering one defense question. Be clear about what you know from sources, what you computed and what you are assuming.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Use the cost-per-volume table in this lesson’s reading. Which statement is supported by it?
In the reading’s decision matrix with weights of 35%, 30%, 25% and 10%, aluminum’s weighted total is and steel’s is .
If moving 10 points of weight from one criterion to another changes which material scores highest, your recommendation is wrong and should be discarded.
Draft your plan: name your scenario and your two candidate materials, write your structure-force-function chain for each in two sentences, and list three criteria in priority order with one reason for the top one and one constraint written as a number from the reading.
How confident are you that you can explain a material’s function from its structure and evaluate it against an alternative with prioritized criteria and a sensitivity test?
Unit 2 checkpoint
Do this before you start the task. It covers the whole unit and tells you what to review first.
Electronegativities: Li 0.98, F 3.98. The bond in LiF is
How many valence electrons are placed in the Lewis structure of NH3?
Water has four electron domains around oxygen, two of them lone pairs. Its shape is
CO2 is a nonpolar molecule even though each C=O bond is polar.
At 25 °C, water has a surface tension of 71.97 mN/m and methanol 22.15 mN/m. The best explanation is that
Ethanol and dimethyl ether both have a molar mass of g/mol, but their NIST boiling points differ by K.
Which of these molecules can form hydrogen bonds with other molecules of its own kind?
Heavier molecules always have higher boiling points than lighter ones.
A solid is very hard, melts above 2,500 °C, does not conduct as a solid, and shatters under a hammer. It is most likely
The molar mass of SiO2 is g/mol and it is % silicon by mass.
Metals bend instead of shattering because layers of positive ions can slide while the sea of mobile electrons keeps them bonded.
A weighted decision matrix uses weights of 35%, 30%, 25% and 10% and scores of 5, 3, 3 and 5 for a candidate. Its weighted total is
Submit: Materials-Selection Brief (900-1,200 words) + four-minute presentation
Task: Choose one of the two Missouri scenarios in the source file (a handrail for a wet cave-tour trail, or a lining for a wood-fired outdoor oven or hearth), or propose your own and justify it. Compare at least two candidate materials. Explain, using bonding, shape and polarity, and intermolecular forces where relevant, why each material has the properties you cite. Support the explanation with data from at least two cited sources (the lesson’s reading counts as one family of sources) and with your own results from Lesson 2.2, or the recorded runs if you used the data path. Include one labeled structure diagram, a prioritized criteria list with at least three criteria, a weighted decision matrix and a sensitivity test.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Plan. Name your scenario, two or more candidates, your criteria in priority order (with a reason for the top one), your constraints as numbers or yes/no tests, and a sketch of the structure diagram.
- Stage 2 — Checklist-reviewed draft. After a day’s break, check your draft against the checklist (or have a parent or guardian read it with the checklist in hand): every property claim names a particle and a force, each score has a reason and every number has a source. Submit the completed checklist and your revision plan.
- Stage 3 — Final brief. 900-1,200 words with the diagram, the weighted decision matrix, the sensitivity test and cited sources.
- Stage 4 — Presentation and defense. Record a four-minute presentation (video, or audio with slides). End by answering one of these defense questions: Which data point in the source file most strongly supports your structure-force-function chain, and how could it mislead you? Which criterion’s weight, if changed, would flip your recommendation, and by how much? What new measurement would most change your conclusion?
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Structure and function (9-12.PS1.A.4) | Explains each property from a correct particle-level model, naming the bonds or intermolecular forces and the shape or lattice involved. |
| Evidence from properties (9-12.PS1.A.3) | Uses data accurately, with units, to connect bulk properties such as melting point or conductivity to the forces between particles. |
| Evaluation and trade-offs (9-12.ETS1.B.1) | Ranks at least three criteria with reasons, states constraints, scores both materials in a weighted matrix and tests how a change in weights affects the recommendation. |
| Sources (RST.9-10.2, SEP.8) | Summarizes at least two sources accurately, cites them, and states what each number does and does not show (for example, raw-material price versus finished-part cost). |
| Communication (SEP.8) | Clear organization and diagram; the presentation answers a defense question with evidence. |
Materials Selection Source File: Two Missouri Scenarios, Candidate Data and a Worked Decision Matrix
USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 (Aluminum, Copper, Lead, Zinc, Iron and Steel Scrap, Cement, Stone (crushed), Lime); NIST Chemistry WebBook melting points; PubChem density and melting-point records; SLS design scenarios, calculations and illustrative matrix scores; retrieved Nov. 15, 2026 · Public domain (U.S. government and NIST data), with SLS original scenarios and illustrative scores
Why this reading. The performance task needs a source file: real, cited numbers for candidate materials and two design scenarios to choose from. This reading supplies USGS 2025 prices, PubChem and NIST properties, the worked calculations for cost per cubic meter and a worked weighted decision matrix, with every limitation stated so your brief can say what each number does and does not show.
Scenario A: a handrail and stair treads for a wet cave-tour trail
This is an SLS design scenario, not an agency specification. Missouri’s cave country is wet limestone karst. Constraints: the rail must not shatter if struck or bent, must keep its strength where it is wet most of the year, and a pair of people must be able to carry each section in by hand. Think about how a metallic lattice and an ionic ceramic respond to a blow, and what dissolved minerals and water do to a surface.
Scenario B: a lining for a wood-fired outdoor oven or hearth
This is an SLS design scenario. The constraint is that the lining must stay solid at the temperatures of a wood fire (treat 1,000 °C as the design maximum) and not crack when heated unevenly. Think about melting points of the metals and ionic and network solids in the table below, and about how bonding in each class responds to heat.
Candidate metals: properties, prices and cost per cubic meter
Melting points: NIST Chemistry WebBook for aluminum (933.45 K), copper (1357.95 K) and lead (600.64 K), converted by SLS; PubChem for zinc (419.5 °C) and iron (1,538 °C). Densities: PubChem at 25 °C. Prices: USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026, 2025 estimates; cents per pound converted at 2,204.62 lb per metric ton. Cost per cubic meter = price per ton × density (g/cm3 is the same number as metric tons per m3).
| Material | Class | Melting point (°C) | Density (g/cm3) | Price ($ per metric ton) | Cost per m3 ($) | Price basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aluminum | Metal | 660.3 | 2.70 | 3,968 | 10,714 | USGS 2025 ingot price, 180 cents per pound |
| Copper | Metal | 1,084.8 | 8.96 | 10,803 | 96,792 | USGS 2025 cathode price, 490 cents per pound |
| Lead | Metal | 327.5 | 11.34 | 2,337 | 26,500 | USGS 2025 price, 106 cents per pound |
| Zinc | Metal | 419.5 | 7.13 | 3,285 | 23,421 | USGS 2025 North American price, 149 cents per pound |
| Iron (steel feedstock) | Metal | 1,538.0 | 7.87 | 319 | 2,511 | USGS 2025 price of No. 1 heavy melting scrap, $319 per metric ton; scrap is a raw feedstock, not finished steel |
Limitations: these are prices for raw metal or scrap feedstock, not finished rails or sheets; alloys, fabrication, finishing and transport are not included. Steel is mostly iron with a little carbon, so the iron row is an indicator only.
Candidate ceramics and minerals
| Material | Class | Melting point (°C) | Price basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Calcium oxide (lime), CaO | Ionic ceramic | 2,613 | Lime is a leading Missouri product (USGS); no price used here |
| Magnesium oxide, MgO | Ionic ceramic | 2,825 | PubChem |
| Silicon dioxide (quartz sand), SiO2 | Network covalent | 1,710 | PubChem |
| Portland cement (as a binder) | Ceramic (calcium compounds) | not a single compound | USGS: average mill unit value $160 per metric ton in 2025; Missouri is second in U.S. production |
| Crushed stone (limestone aggregate) | Ionic ceramic mineral | decomposes (CaCO3) | USGS: average unit value $18.50 per metric ton, 2025 estimate; Missouri is fourth in production |
Polymers
The polymer-structure facts from Lesson 2.4 (repeating unit, chains held together by weak forces, softening when warm) are conceptual; this file contains no polymer property table. If you choose a polymer as a candidate, you must find and cite one published property (for example a softening temperature) yourself, and say where it came from.
Missouri context facts (USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026)
- Missouri is second in U.S. cement production and fourth in crushed stone; about 17% of U.S. crushed stone goes to cement and 6% to lime.
- Five lead mines in Missouri supplied U.S. domestic lead production in 2025; lead-acid batteries use about 67% of U.S. lead.
- An aluminum smelter in New Madrid, Missouri, has been temporarily shut down since 2024; U.S. primary aluminum production in 2025 was an estimated 660 thousand metric tons.
Worked example: weighted decision matrix (illustrative scores)
Scenario for the example only: the frame of a picnic-shelter roof near a Missouri river, aluminum versus steel. Scores are SLS illustrations (1 = poor, 5 = excellent). Weighted total = the sum of weight × score.
| Criterion | Weight (set 1) | Aluminum score | Steel score | Weight (set 2) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Corrosion resistance | 35% | 5 | 2 | 25% |
| Cost | 30% | 3 | 5 | 40% |
| Strength | 25% | 3 | 5 | 25% |
| Low mass | 10% | 5 | 2 | 10% |
Set 1: aluminum = 0.35(5) + 0.30(3) + 0.25(3) + 0.10(5) = 3.90; steel = 0.35(2) + 0.30(5) + 0.25(5) + 0.10(2) = 3.65. Aluminum wins. Set 2 (10 points moved from corrosion to cost): aluminum = 0.25(5) + 0.40(3) + 0.25(3) + 0.10(5) = 3.70; steel = 0.25(2) + 0.40(5) + 0.25(5) + 0.10(2) = 3.95. Steel wins. The recommendation depends on the weights.
Cost-per-volume examples
Aluminum: $3,968 per metric ton × 2.70 = $10,714 per m3. Copper: $10,803 × 8.96 = $96,792 per m3. The ratio of copper to aluminum is 9.0.
Sources: USGS, Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026: Aluminum (pubs.usgs.gov); USGS, Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026: Copper (pubs.usgs.gov); USGS, Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026: Lead (pubs.usgs.gov); USGS, Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026: Zinc (pubs.usgs.gov); USGS, Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026: Iron and Steel Scrap (pubs.usgs.gov); USGS, Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026: Cement (pubs.usgs.gov); USGS, Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026: Stone (crushed) (pubs.usgs.gov); NIST Chemistry WebBook: lead, aluminum and copper (phase change data) (webbook.nist.gov); PubChem (NLM): density and melting-point records (pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov)