
measure the mass of a reacting system in an open cup and in a sealed bag, predict the mass of gas released from moles and molar mass, and use the results to support the claim that mass is conserved.
Instruction
Where does the mass go? Chemists in the 1700s, led by Antoine Lavoisier, found that when a reaction was carried out in a sealed vessel the total mass did not change. Mass seems to disappear when a gas escapes (an open cup of vinegar and baking soda gets lighter) or to appear when a gas joins a solid (iron gains mass as it rusts). The model that explains both: atoms are rearranged in a reaction, never created or destroyed, so the mass of everything in a closed system stays constant. An open system lets matter in or out. Today’s lab tests that idea with NaHCO3 + CH3COOH → CH3COONa + H2O + CO2.
Counting atoms by weighing: the mole. You cannot count atoms one by one, but you can weigh them. A mole is a fixed number of particles, exactly 6.02214076 × 1023 (the Avogadro constant, as defined by NIST). The molar mass of a substance is the mass of one mole in grams, and it is found by adding standard atomic weights (NIST: H 1.008, C 12.011, O 15.999, Na 22.990). Sodium hydrogen carbonate (baking soda), NaHCO3: 22.990 + 1.008 + 12.011 + 3(15.999) = 84.006 g/mol. Carbon dioxide, CO2: 12.011 + 2(15.999) = 44.009 g/mol. Acetic acid, CH3COOH: 60.052 g/mol. Moles = grams ÷ molar mass.
A prediction before the experiment. The coefficients of a balanced equation are particle ratios, which means they are also mole ratios: 1 NaHCO3 : 1 CH3COOH : 1 CO2. Start with 2.0 g of baking soda: 2.0 g ÷ 84.006 g/mol = 0.02381 mol. The ratio to CO2 is 1 : 1, so 0.02381 mol of CO2 forms, which weighs 0.02381 mol × 44.009 g/mol = 1.048 g. That is a prediction you can test: in an open cup the scale should read about 1.05 g less when the fizzing stops, and in a sealed bag it should read the same.
Is the vinegar enough? The vinegar matters too. White vinegar is labeled 5% acidity, which this lesson treats as about 5.0 g of acetic acid per 100 mL, so 30 mL holds about 1.5 g, or 1.5 ÷ 60.052 = 0.02498 mol. That is slightly more than the 0.02381 mol of baking soda, so baking soda runs out first and about 4.7% of the acid is left over. The reactant that runs out first is called the limiting reagent, the idea of the next lesson.
The full mass account. Account for every gram. Reactants: 2.0 g NaHCO3 + 1.5 g acetic acid = 3.500 g. Products: CO2 1.048 g; H2O 0.429 g (from 0.02381 mol × 18.015); sodium acetate 1.953 g (82.034 g/mol); leftover acetic acid 0.070 g. Total 3.500 g. The books balance exactly because the atoms did not go anywhere; only the CO2 can leave an open cup.
Reading measurements honestly. A kitchen scale reads to 0.1 g, so a change of 0.1 g is within its uncertainty. A sealed bag that inflates is pushed up slightly by the air around it (buoyancy), so the scale can read a little low even though no matter left. A leaking seal does lose real mass. Averaging several trials, and combining them with the recorded data in this lesson’s reading, reduces the effect of random error.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Lab: Conservation of Mass in Open and Closed Systems
Question. Does the total mass of a baking-soda and vinegar reaction change in an open cup and in a sealed bag, and does the mass of gas released match the mole-based prediction?
Materials
- Baking soda (sodium hydrogen carbonate), 2.0 g per trial, weighed on a folded paper square or coffee filter
- White vinegar (5% acidity), 30 mL (2 tablespoons) per trial, in a small plastic cup that fits inside a quart bag
- Quart-size zip-top freezer bags and one drinking cup for the open trial
- Digital kitchen or pocket scale that reads to 0.1 g; measuring spoons; a spoon
- Safety glasses or goggles and paper towels
- Do this lab with a parent or guardian nearby, and wear safety glasses or goggles throughout; vinegar stings if it splashes in the eyes.
- Use only baking soda and white vinegar. Never mix them with bleach, ammonia or any other cleaner, and taste nothing.
- Point the sealed bag away from faces while it inflates, and open it slowly at the end.
- Wipe up spills at once. The leftover liquid is dilute sodium acetate solution and may go down the sink with running water.
Procedure
- Predict first: with the formula-mass method from the mini-lecture, write the mass of CO2 you expect from 2.0 g of baking soda, then write what you expect each scale to read afterward.
- Open trial: place the cup with 30 mL of vinegar and the paper with 2.0 g of baking soda on the scale together and record the starting mass.
- Tip the baking soda into the vinegar and leave the paper on the scale. When the fizzing stops (about 2 minutes), record the final mass.
- Closed trial: put 2.0 g of baking soda in a corner of a bag, stand the small cup with 30 mL of vinegar upright inside, press out extra air and seal. Check the seal by pressing gently, and record the mass of the whole sealed bag.
- Without opening the bag, tip the cup so the liquid meets the baking soda. When the fizzing stops, record the final mass and note how full the bag is.
- Calculate final minus initial for each trial. Repeat both once more if you have materials, then add your trials to the six recorded trials in this lesson’s reading and find the average change for open trials and for closed trials.
- Optional Part B (open cup): repeat the open trial with 1.0 g and then 4.0 g of baking soda, keeping 30 mL of vinegar, and record the mass lost each time. You will use these in Lesson 3.3.
Data
| Trial | Initial mass (g) | Final mass (g) | Change (g) | Observations (fizzing, bag fullness, leaks) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Open cup | ||||
| Sealed bag | ||||
| Average, open (your trials + recorded set) | n = ___ | |||
| Average, closed (your trials + recorded set) | n = ___ | |||
| Part B: 1.0 g baking soda, open | ||||
| Part B: 4.0 g baking soda, open | ||||
Analysis
- Claim, evidence, reasoning: is mass conserved in this reaction? Use the average change for open and for closed trials (your trials plus the recorded set), the atom count in the balanced equation, and where the CO2 went.
- Your mole-based prediction for 2.0 g of baking soda is 1.048 g of CO2. Compare your open-cup loss and the recorded open-trial average of 0.97 g with it, calculate each as a percent of the prediction, and suggest why the measured loss is smaller (for example, some CO2 stays dissolved).
- Name two sources of error in the closed trial (leaks, buoyancy of an inflated bag, scale uncertainty) and say in which direction each would push the reading.
- Using the mass account in the mini-lecture, show that the products plus the leftover acetic acid add up to the 3.5 g of reactants, and explain which one product would leave an open cup.
If you cannot do this lab in person: No scale that reads to 0.1 g, or no materials? Use the six recorded open and sealed trials, the Part B series and the mass-accounting table in this lesson’s reading as your data, and complete the same analysis. You can also model the atom count with the PhET Reactants, Products and Leftovers simulation.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
What will the scale reading of the sealed bag do during the reaction?
What is the molar mass of NaHCO3 (Na 22.990, H 1.008, C 12.011, O 15.999)?
The number of moles in 2.0 g of NaHCO3 is mol (to 3 significant figures).
A sealed bag that reads 0.1 g lighter after the reaction proves that 0.1 g of matter was destroyed.
Write your claim-evidence-reasoning paragraph on conservation of mass. Use the open and sealed averages (your trials plus the recorded trials in this lesson’s reading), your mole-based prediction of 1.05 g of CO2, and one source of error with its direction.
How confident are you that you can convert between grams and moles with molar mass, and use a closed-system measurement to support conservation of mass?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Find the molar mass of NaHCO3.
Check your answer
Answer: 84.006 g/mol22.990 + 1.008 + 12.011 + 3(15.999). - Find the molar mass of CO2.
Check your answer
Answer: 44.009 g/mol12.011 + 2(15.999). - Find the molar mass of H2O.
Check your answer
Answer: 18.015 g/mol2(1.008) + 15.999. - How many moles are in 25.0 g of water?
Check your answer
Answer: 1.39 mol25.0 ÷ 18.015. - What is the mass of 0.500 mol of CO2?
Check your answer
Answer: 22.0 g0.500 × 44.009. - How many molecules are in 0.500 mol of CO2?
Check your answer
Answer: 3.01 × 1023 molecules0.500 × 6.02214076 × 1023.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- In the lab, 2.0 g of baking soda reacts completely with vinegar (NaHCO3 + CH3COOH → CH3COONa + H2O + CO2). Predict the mass of CO2 released.
Check your answer
Answer: 1.05 g2.0 ÷ 84.006 = 0.02381 mol; 1 : 1 ratio; × 44.009 g/mol. - A student reacts 3.0 g of baking soda with plenty of vinegar. Predict the mass of CO2 and say what the scale does for an open cup and a sealed bag.
Check your answer
Answer: 1.57 g of CO2; the open cup reads about 1.6 g lighter and the sealed bag about the same3.0 ÷ 84.006 = 0.03571 mol; × 44.009 = 1.572 g. A sealed bag keeps the gas. - An open-cup trial of the 2.0 g reaction lost 0.9 g. What percent of the predicted CO2 mass was lost?
Check your answer
Answer: 85.9%0.9 ÷ 1.048 × 100. - A sealed bag started at 139.0 g with 2.0 g of baking soda and 30 mL of vinegar inside. What mass should the scale read when the fizzing stops, and what mass of CO2 is inside?
Check your answer
Answer: 139.0 g; about 1.05 g of CO2 is inside the bagNo matter left the closed system, so the total mass is unchanged.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- A student uses only 1.0 g of baking soda with 30 mL of vinegar (assume 1.5 g of acetic acid, 60.052 g/mol). Which reactant limits the reaction, and what mass of CO2 forms?
Check your answer
Answer: baking soda limits (0.01190 mol vs 0.02498 mol of acid); 0.524 g of CO21.0 ÷ 84.006 = 0.01190 mol of baking soda, less than 0.02498 mol of acid; CO2 = 0.01190 × 44.009. - Account for every gram when 4.0 g of baking soda reacts with 1.5 g of acetic acid (acid is limiting). Give the mass of CO2, H2O and CH3COONa formed, the mass of baking soda left over, and show the total equals the reactants.
Check your answer
Answer: CO2 1.099 g; H2O 0.450 g; CH3COONa 2.049 g; NaHCO3 left 1.902 g; total 5.500 g = 4.0 + 1.5 = 5.5 gMoles of acid 0.02498 set the amounts; leftover NaHCO3 = (0.04762 − 0.02498) × 84.006. The sum is 5.500 g.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Balance and classify: NaHCO3 + CH3COOH → CH3COONa + H2O + CO2. Count the atoms of each element on each side.
Check your answer
Answer: already balanced with all coefficients 1; Na 1, C 3, H 5, O 5 on each side; the net change is a double replacement followed by decomposition of carbonic acidC: 1 + 2 = 3 and 2 + 1 = 3. H: 1 + 4 = 5 and 3 + 2 = 5. O: 3 + 2 = 5 and 2 + 1 + 2 = 5. - Predict the products of Mg + 2HCl and write the balanced equation (a single replacement; magnesium is more reactive than hydrogen).
Check your answer
Answer: Mg + 2HCl → MgCl2 + H2Mg loses two electrons (Mg2+) and pairs with two Cl−; the hydrogen is released as H2.
Open Cup, Sealed Bag and the Mole: Recorded Trials and a Full Mass Account
SLS original constructed teaching data for the Lesson 3.2 procedure (illustrative; six trials on a scale reading to 0.1 g); molar masses from NIST standard atomic weights and the NIST Avogadro constant, retrieved 2026-11-15 · SLS original (constructed teaching data, labeled illustrative), with NIST reference values (public domain)
Why this reading. The lab asks you to average several trials, to test a mole-based prediction, and gives a route for students without a scale. This is the data for all three: six recorded open-cup and sealed-bag trials, a limiting-reagent series for the optional Part B, and a gram-by-gram mass account. The trial data are SLS original and illustrative, built to match the theoretical prediction; they are not measurements by any agency.
Six recorded trials
Each trial used 2.0 g of baking soda and 30 mL of white vinegar, and the scale read to 0.1 g.
| Trial | Open: initial (g) | Open: final (g) | Open: change (g) | Sealed: initial (g) | Sealed: final (g) | Sealed: change (g) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 141.8 | 140.9 | −0.9 | 139.2 | 139.1 | −0.1 | bag moderately inflated |
| 2 | 143.2 | 142.2 | −1.0 | 138.4 | 138.4 | 0.0 | bag loosely full, little buoyancy |
| 3 | 140.6 | 139.6 | −1.0 | 139.9 | 139.8 | −0.1 | bag very full; likely buoyancy effect |
| 4 | 142.4 | 141.5 | −0.9 | 137.6 | 137.4 | −0.2 | small leak suspected at seal corner |
| 5 | 141.0 | 139.9 | −1.1 | 138.8 | 138.8 | 0.0 | no leak, bag loosely full |
| 6 | 143.9 | 143.0 | −0.9 | 139.3 | 139.2 | −0.1 | bag moderately inflated |
| Average | −0.97 | −0.08 |
Every open trial lost about a gram (average 0.97 g lost); every sealed trial changed by 0.2 g or less (average 0.08 g). The fullest bag (trial 3) and the suspected leak (trial 4) show the largest sealed changes, the two error sources named in the mini-lecture. The scale’s uncertainty is about ±0.1 g.
The prediction these data test
Molar masses (NIST atomic weights): NaHCO3 84.006 g/mol, CO2 44.009 g/mol, CH3COOH 60.052 g/mol. 2.0 g ÷ 84.006 = 0.02381 mol of baking soda, which is 1.43 × 1022 formula units (using 6.02214076 × 1023 per mole, the NIST value). One CO2 forms per NaHCO3: 0.02381 mol × 44.009 = 1.048 g. The recorded open-trial average of 0.97 g is 92.3% of that prediction, which is plausible because some CO2 stays dissolved in the liquid.
Part B: how much baking soda? (open cup, 30 mL vinegar)
The 30 mL of vinegar is assumed to hold about 1.5 g of acetic acid, which is 0.0250 mol (treating 5% acidity as 5.0 g per 100 mL). The measured losses are SLS illustrative values.
| Baking soda (g) | Baking soda (mol) | Acetic acid (mol) | Limiting reagent | Predicted CO2 (g) | Illustrative measured loss (g) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1.0 | 0.0119 | 0.0250 | baking soda | 0.524 | 0.5 |
| 2.0 | 0.0238 | 0.0250 | baking soda | 1.048 | 1.0 |
| 4.0 | 0.0476 | 0.0250 | acetic acid | 1.099 | 1.1 |
| 8.0 | 0.0952 | 0.0250 | acetic acid | 1.099 | 1.1 |
Once the baking soda exceeds the acid, extra baking soda cannot make more CO2: the predicted loss levels off near 1.10 g. This is the idea of Lesson 3.3.
The full mass account for 2.0 g of baking soda and 1.5 g of acetic acid
| Substance | Molar mass (g/mol) | Moles | Mass (g) | Role |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NaHCO3 (reactant) | 84.006 | 0.02381 | 2.000 | reactant |
| CH3COOH consumed | 60.052 | 0.02381 | 1.430 | reactant |
| CH3COOH left over | 60.052 | 0.00117 | 0.070 | unreacted |
| CO2 | 44.009 | 0.02381 | 1.048 | product (the only one that can leave an open cup) |
| H2O | 18.015 | 0.02381 | 0.429 | product |
| CH3COONa | 82.034 | 0.02381 | 1.953 | product |
Reactants: 2.000 + 1.500 = 3.500 g. Products plus leftover acid: 1.048 + 0.429 + 1.953 + 0.070 = 3.500 g. Mass in equals mass out.
Using this record
Write your claim-evidence-reasoning paragraph with the averages (yours plus these, or these alone: −0.97 g open, −0.08 g sealed), the atom count from the balanced equation, and at least one named source of error with its direction: an inflated bag pushes the sealed reading slightly negative, and a leaking seal makes it more negative because mass really left.
Sources: NIST Physical Measurement Laboratory, Atomic Weights and Isotopic Compositions (standard atomic weights; conventional values used where NIST gives an interval) (retrieved 2026-11-15) (physics.nist.gov); NIST, CODATA 2022 value of the Avogadro constant (retrieved 2026-11-15) (physics.nist.gov)