
complete a quantitative brief that uses concentration calculations or bond-energy and fuel-energy calculations to evaluate a real water-quality or fuel decision against stated criteria and constraints.
Instruction
The context. Two decisions in Missouri depend on the arithmetic you have just learned. A water utility must decide whether its tap samples call for action on lead. A fuel buyer or a plant manager must decide how much energy a gallon of ethanol really delivers compared with gasoline. In both cases a number is only useful when you know its unit, its source, its uncertainty and the line it is compared with. Your brief does that work for one of the two decisions, as a technical adviser would.
Choose one strand. Strand A: Lead in drinking water. Use the 20 illustrative first-draw samples and the dilution report in this lesson’s reading. Calculate the percent of samples above 15 µg/L and above 10 µg/L, convert the action levels to mol/L, correct the diluted laboratory reading, and judge what the system must do under each level. Strand B: Ethanol and gasoline energy. Use the bond-energy table and the NIST data in the reading. Calculate ΔH for ethanol and octane by the bond-energy model, check them against NIST, convert to kJ per gram, and compare with the per-gallon energy content from the U.S. Department of Energy.
What every brief contains. (1) A question and decision stated in one sentence. (2) A calculation table with each number, its unit, its formula and its source; every calculation can be reproduced from the table, ideally with a short Python or spreadsheet check. (3) A graph or energy diagram: Strand A, a bar graph of the 20 samples with both action-level lines; Strand B, energy diagrams for both fuels with break and form sums. (4) A criteria table: three or more prioritized criteria (for example protection of health, accuracy of the calculation, cost, ease of carrying out) and at least one constraint, with each option scored. (5) A recommendation that names the trade-off and the limits of the data: the 20 samples and the dilution report are illustrative, the bond energies are averages, and the per-gallon figures are U.S. Department of Energy values.
Quality bar. Every claim has a number. Every number has a unit and a source or an “illustrative” label. For Strand A you must say that EPA’s health goal for lead is zero and that an action level is a trigger for steps, not a statement that the water is safe. For Strand B you must say how close the bond-energy model came to the NIST value, and that equal carbon dioxide per megajoule at the tailpipe does not settle the question of life-cycle emissions.
Stages. Plan, draft, review with the rubric (a parent, guardian or other adult reader, or you after a day away), revise, and defend in four minutes, recorded, answering one question about your recommendation.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Use the dilution report in this lesson’s reading. A sample diluted from 5.00 mL to 50.0 mL reads 1.30 µg/L. What do you report for the original sample, and does it exceed 10 µg/L?
Ethanol releases less energy per gram than octane because its molecule already contains oxygen bonds, so less new bond energy is gained when it burns.
Draft your plan from this lesson’s reading: state your strand and decision in one sentence, list the three numbers you will calculate first with their units, and rank your three criteria with one sentence explaining why the top one comes first.
How confident are you that you can use concentration or bond-energy calculations to make a quantitative recommendation with stated trade-offs?
Unit 4 checkpoint
Do this before you start the task. It covers the whole unit and tells you what to review first.
A sealed rigid tank of gas is warmed. The pressure rises because
A gas at 2.00 atm and 4.00 L is compressed to 1.00 L at constant temperature. The new pressure is
Gas-law calculations must use temperature in and absolute pressure.
A 600 mL balloon at 300 K is cooled to 250 K at constant pressure. Its new volume is mL.
A trend line through gas-volume data extended to zero volume gives an estimate of absolute zero, about −273 °C.
How many grams of NaCl (58.44 g/mol) make 250 mL of 0.200 M solution?
Lead at 15 µg/L is 15 parts per .
A result below an action level shows that tap water contains no lead.
A reaction has bonds broken totaling 679.5 kJ and bonds formed totaling 934 kJ. ΔH is
Splitting water into hydrogen and oxygen is endothermic because the bonds broken are stronger in total than the bonds formed.
Ethanol releases 1,367.6 kJ/mol at 46.069 g/mol, which is kJ/g (one decimal place).
Per gram, burning octane releases more energy than ethanol mainly because
Submit: quantitative brief (800-1,100 words) + four-minute defense
Task: Choose Strand A (lead in water) or Strand B (ethanol and gasoline energy). Write a brief with a decision statement, a calculation table that shows every number with unit and source, a graph or energy diagram, a criteria table with at least three prioritized criteria and one constraint, and a recommendation that names its trade-offs and the limits of the data. Use this lesson’s reading for your data and cite at least three sources.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Plan. State your decision, list the numbers you must calculate, and rank your criteria and constraint.
- Stage 2 — Reviewed draft. A reviewer (a parent, guardian or other adult reader, or you yourself after at least a day away) checks that every number has a unit and a source or an ‘illustrative’ label and that every calculation can be reproduced; submit the review notes and your revision plan.
- Stage 3 — Final brief. 800-1,100 words with the calculation table, graph or diagram, criteria table and cited sources.
- Stage 4 — Presentation and defense. Four minutes, recorded, then answer one question about your recommendation: a question from your listener, or, if you record alone, ‘What would change your recommendation, and which number would you need to see?’
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Calculations (9-12.PS1.B.3 / 9-12.PS1.A.5) | All calculations are correct, with units, a method that can be reproduced, and a comparison with a reference value or action level. |
| Energy or concentration model (9-12.PS1.A.5) | Strand B explains energy released from bonds broken and formed and checks it against NIST; Strand A explains concentration and dilution with the moles of solute. |
| Criteria and trade-offs (9-12.ETS1.B.1) | Ranks at least three criteria with reasons, applies a constraint and makes a recommendation that states its trade-offs. |
| Sources and limits (RST.9-10.9) | Cites at least three sources, labels illustrative data and states the limits of the data and the model. |
| Communication (SEP.5) | Clear writing, an accurate graph or diagram and a defense that answers a question with evidence. |
Source File for the Quantitative Brief: Lead in Water or Ethanol Fuel Energy
EPA, Basic Information about Lead in Drinking Water and Lead and Copper Rule Improvements fact sheet; NIST Chemistry WebBook; Chemistry LibreTexts Bond Energies table (cited by link); U.S. DOE Alternative Fuels Data Center; U.S. EIA ethanol plant capacity; NIST atomic weights; all retrieved 2026-11-15. The tap samples, dilution report and criteria scores are SLS illustrative data · SLS original (prose, calculations and constructed illustrative data); EPA, NIST, DOE and EIA content is U.S. government information in the public domain
Why this reading. This is the one file you need for the performance task. It collects, in one place, the sourced numbers and the labeled illustrative data for both strands, the order of the calculations you must show, and a worked example of a criteria table so you can see how options are scored.
Strand A: Lead in drinking water
Sourced facts (EPA). The health goal for lead is zero. The treatment technique requires action if more than 10 percent of tap samples exceed the action level, which has been 15 parts per billion; the 2024 Lead and Copper Rule Improvements lower the action level to 10 µg/L. Lead usually enters tap water from lead service lines, faucets and solder through corrosion.
Illustrative data (SLS). Twenty first-draw samples, µg/L of lead, sorted: 0.5, 0.8, 0.9, 1.2, 1.4, 1.9, 2.2, 2.5, 2.9, 3.1, 3.6, 4.8, 5.1, 6.2, 7.4, 8.7, 10.8, 12.4, 16.3, 18.9. Count above 15: 2 (10 percent). Count above 10: 4 (20 percent). Laboratory report: 5.00 mL diluted to 50.0 mL reads 1.30 µg/L, so the original is 13.0 µg/L.
Conversions (NIST: Pb = 207.2 g/mol; NA = 6.02214076 × 1023/mol). 15 µg/L = 7.24 × 10−8 mol/L; 10 µg/L = 4.83 × 10−8 mol/L. A 250 mL glass at 15 µg/L holds 3.75 µg, or 1.09 × 1016 atoms.
Calculations to show: percent of samples above each level; the corrected value of the dilution report; the concentration of each action level in mol/L; a statement about what the action level does and does not mean.
Strand B: Ethanol and gasoline energy
Sourced data. Average bond energies (kJ/mol): H–H 432, O=O 495, O–H 467, C–H 413, C–C 347, C–O 358, C=O in CO2 799. NIST enthalpies of formation (kJ/mol): CO2(g) −393.51, H2O(g) −241.826, H2O(l) −285.830, ethanol(g) −234, octane(g) −208.4, octane(l) −250.0; ethanol(l) combustion −1,367.6. DOE energy content: ethanol 76,330 Btu/gal; gasoline 112,114–116,090 Btu/gal (lower heating value). EIA: Missouri has 6 fuel ethanol plants with 338 million gallons per year of capacity.
Results you should reproduce. Ethanol (gas) by bond energies: −1,276 kJ/mol, against −1,278.5 from NIST (0.2 percent). Octane (gas): −5,139.5 against −5,116.1 (0.5 percent). Liquid ethanol: 29.7 kJ/g; liquid octane: 47.9 kJ/g; ratio 0.62. DOE per-gallon ratio: 0.658 to 0.681. Tailpipe CO2: 64.4 g/MJ for both.
Calculations to show: the break and form sums for ethanol and octane; the percent difference from NIST; energy per gram for both; the per-gallon ratio; a clear statement that bond energies are averages.
A worked criteria table (illustrative, for a different decision)
A household must choose a way to check its tap water: send a sample to a certified laboratory, use a home test kit, or ask the water system for its sampling results. Scores run from 1 (poor) to 3 (best); the weights are the household’s priorities. The weighted total is the sum of weight × score.
| Criterion (weight) | Certified lab | Ask the utility | Home kit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Protects health (weight 3) | 3 | 2 | 1 |
| Accuracy of the calculation (weight 2) | 3 | 3 | 2 |
| Ease of carrying out (weight 1) | 1 | 2 | 3 |
Weighted totals: certified lab 16, ask the utility 14, home kit 10. The constraint, a laboratory fee the household may not be able to pay, can change the recommendation, and the brief should say so. Use your own criteria and scores for your decision and explain each score.
Checklist for the calculation table
- Every number has a unit and a source or the word “illustrative”.
- Every calculation shows the formula, the substitution and the result.
- Every comparison names the reference value (the action level, the NIST value, the DOE figure).
Sources: EPA: Basic Information about Lead in Drinking Water (epa.gov); EPA: Final Lead and Copper Rule Improvements fact sheet (epa.gov); NIST Chemistry WebBook: ethanol (webbook.nist.gov); Chemistry LibreTexts: Bond Energies (chem.libretexts.org); U.S. DOE Alternative Fuels Data Center: Fuel Properties Comparison (afdc.energy.gov); U.S. EIA: U.S. Fuel Ethanol Plant Production Capacity (eia.gov); NIST atomic weights and isotopic compositions (physics.nist.gov)