
find and evaluate published criticism of Heart of Darkness, represent critics fairly, and integrate their arguments into my own without letting them replace it.
Instruction
A critical essay adds your voice to a published conversation. That requires finding the conversation, understanding it, and using it without being swallowed by it.
Where to look (11-12.W.1.A.b). Start with your school or public library’s databases; many public libraries give free database access with a library card. Search the title with a focusing term: “Heart of Darkness” AND frame, “Heart of Darkness” AND Achebe, “Heart of Darkness” AND Intended. Look for articles in peer-reviewed journals and chapters in books from university presses. Public-domain sources also help: Conrad’s own Author’s Note (1917) and letters, and contemporary accounts of the Congo such as Twain’s. Avoid study-guide sites: they summarize but do not argue, and they are not criticism.
Evaluate each source. Who wrote it, and what is their expertise? When — and has the argument been answered since? What evidence does it use: close reading, historical documents, biography? What is its limitation for your claim? A biographical article about Conrad’s 1890 journey may be excellent and still not help an argument about the frame.
Represent critics fairly. Summarize a critic’s argument as they would, before you use it. Use signal phrases that name the move: Achebe argues, concedes, insists, questions. Don’t make a critic say more or less than they said.
Three ways to use a critic. Agree and extend: take a critic’s point further or apply it to a passage they did not discuss. Disagree: answer a critic with textual evidence. Complicate: accept part of a critic’s argument and show where it needs qualifying. The best essays usually do some of each.
Keep your claim at the center. Each paragraph should begin with your claim and use the critic as a partner in it, not begin with the critic and trail your comment behind. Critics are evidence and interlocutors; the novella is still your main evidence.
Applying reading standards in writing (11-12.RL.1.A and 9.b). You are applying literary reading to the novella and informational reading to the criticism and to Twain and Plaatje. Delineate a critic’s reasoning as you delineated a Supreme Court opinion in English 12A.
Precise vocabulary (11-12.W.2.A). Criticism has terms — frame narrative, unreliable narrator, representation, irony, postcolonial. Use them accurately, define them once if your reader might not know them, and prefer a plain word when it does the same work.
Share and update (11-12.W.3.A.e). Keep your plan in a shared document with your peer reviewer, respond to each comment, and keep version history on.
Integrity. Paraphrase critics in your own words and structure, and cite every idea you took, not only every quotation.
📖 Before this lesson, read: Heart of Darkness, The whole novella (Parts 1-3)
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reading: A critic of the 1910s, sample annotated sources and a model plan for the Heart of Darkness essay
Hugh Walpole, Joseph Conrad (New York: Henry Holt and Company, c. 1916; the text discusses Conrad’s books up to 1915), Project Gutenberg 49436 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/49436), retrieved 2026-09-26, italics markers removed; Joseph Conrad, Heart of Darkness (serialized 1899; book 1902), Project Gutenberg 219 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/219), retrieved 2026-09-26, cited by part. Chinua Achebe, ‘An Image of Africa’, The Massachusetts Review (1977), is in copyright and is summarized, not reproduced. · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (Hugh Walpole, c. 1916; Joseph Conrad, Heart of Darkness, 1902)
Study the mentor paragraphs, compare your annotated sources and passage map with the models, and check your plan against the criteria.
Criticism of Heart of Darkness did not begin with Achebe. This page gives you two paragraphs of criticism from the mid-1910s, quoted exactly, to study how one critic makes and qualifies claims about the novella; sample annotated-source entries for two real sources, one of them summarized because it is in copyright; a model Stage 1 plan; a before-and-after showing how to represent a critic fairly; and the criteria for Stage 1. Everything except the quotations is SLS original. Your own third source has to come from a library database, and you should read it in full.
Part 1. A mentor: two paragraphs of criticism from about 1916
Hugh Walpole, a novelist, wrote Joseph Conrad in the mid-1910s (it discusses Conrad’s books up to 1915), when Conrad was alive and the novella was about sixteen years old. He praises the three tales, and he also finds fault. He says nothing in these paragraphs about the novella’s Africans or its politics, which is itself a fact you can use: it shows what a reader of that time chose to notice.
Walpole on what the tale achieves
These three tales, Typhoon, Youth and Heart of Darkness, stand by themselves as the final expression of Conrad’s lyrical gift. We may remember such characters as McWhirr, Kurtz, Marlowe, but they are figures as the old seneschal in The Eve of St Agnes or the Ancient Mariner himself are figures. They are as surely complete poems, wrought and finished in the true spirit of poetry, as Whitman’s When Lilac first on the Door-yard bloomed or Keats’ Nightingale. Their author was never again to succeed so completely in combining the free spirit of his enthusiasm with the disciplined restraint of the true artist.
Walpole on what it costs
prose piled high with sonorous and slow-moving adjectives, three adjectives to a noun, prose that sounds like an Eastern invocation to a deity in whom, nevertheless, the suppliant does not believe. At its worst, the strain that its sonority places upon movements and objects of no importance is disastrous.
Moves to notice. The first paragraph makes a claim about a group of works and gives an image for it, complete poems. The second paragraph limits the first: the same style that Walpole admires is, at its worst, disastrous. A critic who only praises is easy to write and easy to ignore. Notice too that Walpole places Conrad among other writers, Whitman and Keats, to say what kind of writing it is.
Part 2. Sample annotated-source entries (SLS original)
Each entry has a summary, an evaluation and a plan for using the source. The third is a blank for you.
Source 1. Hugh Walpole, Joseph Conrad (Henry Holt, c. 1916). Summary. Walpole treats Heart of Darkness, Youth and Typhoon as the high point of Conrad’s lyrical gift, and he also says that the sonorous adjectives of the early style, at its worst, put too much weight on things of no importance. Evaluation. A working novelist writing a short book for general readers, in the mid-1910s. He argues from close reading of style, not from history or biography. In the passages above he does not discuss the frame or the novella’s treatment of Africans, so he cannot help a claim about either. Use. Complicate. I can use his complaint about adjectives to introduce the later argument, made in the 1940s, that Conrad’s insistence on mystery avoids saying what is happening, and then ask whether the passages Walpole praises are where that avoidance is most visible.
Source 2. Chinua Achebe, “An Image of Africa,” The Massachusetts Review, 1977 (from a 1975 lecture). Summary. Achebe argues that the novella sets Africa up as the opposite of Europe, a place where a European’s civilization is broken, and that its Africans are given no full humanity: they are bodies, faces and noises. He says that the frame and Marlow’s irony do not remove Conrad’s responsibility, because the book offers no other point of view. Evaluation. Written by a novelist from Nigeria who had read the book closely, for a university audience, and answered by many critics since, some in partial agreement. The argument uses close reading and knowledge of how Africa was written about in English. Its limit for a claim about the frame is that Achebe treats the frame as insufficient, so I would need to say what I think it does. Use. Disagree in part, and complicate: I accept that the book gives its Africans little speech, and I will argue that the frame still shows the Company’s words condemning themselves.
Source 3. [A peer-reviewed article or book chapter found through a library database. Give: author, title, journal or book, year, and the database. Then write your summary (two sentences, as the author would put it), your evaluation (who, when, what evidence, what limit for your claim), and the way you will use it: agree and extend, disagree, or complicate.]
Part 3. A model Stage 1 plan (SLS original)
Claim. The novella’s double frame lets Conrad show the Company’s language exposing itself, but it never gives the people who suffer a frame of their own, so its critique of empire is real and Achebe is right that it stops short.
Passage map: five passages across the novella, including the outer frame.
- Part I, the opening (outer frame). The narrator on the Nellie, before Marlow speaks. What is left unsaid: who the narrator is, and who “we” are.
- Part I, the chain gang. Marlow reports the men called criminals, and adds that they could by no stretch of imagination be called enemies. The Company’s word is shown to be false, and the men do not speak.
- Part I, the grove of death. They were not enemies, they were not criminals, the tale says of the dying, and it does so in Marlow’s voice.
- Part II, the river and the shore. The passage Achebe’s readers most often quote: a black and incomprehensible frenzy. Here the narration limits itself to what Marlow can see, and marks its own limit: We could not understand.
- Part III, the closing frame. the heart of an immense darkness. The narrator’s last word, and the one place where the book’s darkness is said to lie beyond Africa.
Using the critics. Achebe’s argument comes into paragraph 3, after my own claim, to test whether the passage supports him: it does, in part, and I add what it also does. Walpole comes into the introduction to show that the early readers found the book’s style more noticeable than its politics. My third source, a peer-reviewed article on narrative structure, comes into paragraph 2 to explain what the frame does.
Part 4. Representing a critic fairly (SLS original)
| Draft sentence | Problem | Revision |
|---|---|---|
| Walpole says Conrad’s prose is disastrous. | Takes one word out of a qualified sentence and reverses his verdict. He says the strain is disastrous only at its worst, and in the next paragraph he praises the same style. | Walpole calls the three tales the final expression of Conrad’s lyrical gift, though he admits that the sonorous style, at its worst, puts a strain on objects of no importance. |
| Walpole thinks Conrad is a great poet. | Makes the critic say more than he said. He says the tales are like poems; he does not call Conrad a poet. | Walpole compares Kurtz and Marlow to figures in poems, and says the tales are as surely complete poems as Keats’s or Whitman’s. |
Signal phrases that name the move. Achebe argues, insists, concedes, questions, denies. Walpole praises, qualifies, compares, admits. Avoid “says” when the critic is doing something more specific, and avoid “proves” for anything a critic argues.
Part 5. Criteria for Stage 1 (four levels)
| Criterion | Beginning | Developing | Proficient | Exemplary |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claim | Topic or summary. | A claim without a reason. | A clear, disputable claim. | Also says what the frame does, and what the critics do not answer. |
| Sources (11-12.W.1.A.b) | Study guides or unnamed websites. | Sources named, one not scholarly. | Three sources, one peer-reviewed, each summarized as its author would. | Each source is also evaluated for its limit and given a use. |
| Passage map | Fewer than five, or all from one part. | Five, but none from the frame. | Five across the novella, including the outer frame. | Each passage annotated for voice and what is left unsaid. |
| Representation of critics | Quotes out of context. | Fair but thin. | Each critic represented as they would recognize. | Also uses each critic to agree, disagree or complicate. |
Integrity. Paraphrase critics in your own words, cite every idea you took as well as every quotation, and read every source you list.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which is the best source for a critical essay on the novella’s frame?
It is acceptable to quote a critic’s single sentence out of context if it seems to support your claim.
Submit Stage 1 in a shared document: your claim; three annotated sources (at least one peer-reviewed critical source) with summary, evaluation and how you will use each (agree and extend, disagree, or complicate); and a passage map of five passages from across the novella, including one from the outer frame.
How confident are you that you can find, evaluate and fairly use published criticism in my own argument?
Heart of Darkness, The whole novella (Parts 1-3)
Heart of Darkness, The whole novella (Parts 1-3) so far Bridge summary — not the primary text
A recap of what you have already read, written for this course, so the reading check below does not require re-opening every earlier popover.
The novella is told in two frames: an unnamed narrator on a yacht in the Thames reports the tale Marlow tells his friends one evening. Part 1 follows Marlow from Europe to the Company’s stations, where he sees chained and dying laborers and hears of Kurtz as a remarkable agent. Part 2 carries him upriver through fog and an attack in which his helmsman dies, and shows Kurtz first as a voice and as the author of a report that ends “Exterminate all the brutes!” Part 3 brings Kurtz on stage at last: the heads on the stakes, the night in the forest, the cry of “The horror!” and his death, and then Marlow’s lie to the Intended in Europe and the narrator’s last look at the Thames. These are the passages your sources will argue about, and the ones your own essay must analyze.