
write a precise, disputable comparative claim about the two plays, develop a counterclaim with textual evidence, and link the argument’s sections with varied syntax.
Instruction
An argument about literature is still an argument. It needs a claim a thoughtful reader could reject, reasons, evidence and a fair hearing for the other side. The difference is that the evidence is the text, and the other side is usually another reading of it.
Step 1 — A disputable claim (11-12.W.2.A). “Both plays are about women in bad marriages” is true and undisputed. “Nora is braver than Annie” is disputable but shallow: it judges characters rather than plays. A strong comparative claim argues what the difference between the plays reveals: O’Neill rewrites Ibsen’s ending as a trap without a door: where Ibsen treats leaving as a choice that reason can make, Ile shows a world in which the choice depends on circumstances the wife does not control.
Step 2 — Establish significance and distinguish alternatives. Say why your claim matters — what it shows about each play, or about how drama changed between 1879 and 1917. Then name an alternative reading and distinguish yours from it: Some readers see Ile as a simple tragedy of obsession, with Annie as its incidental victim; my reading places her at its center.
Step 3 — The counterclaim with textual evidence (11-12.W.2.A). The strongest counterclaims in literary argument come from the text. If you argue that Nora’s leaving is liberation, the counterclaim is the evidence that the play leaves her future uncertain: she has no money, no training, and she says herself she must educate herself first. Develop the counterclaim with its quotations, acknowledge its strength, and answer it.
Step 4 — Comparative structure. Two common structures. Block: all of Ibsen, then all of O’Neill. Easy to write, hard to make comparative. Point-by-point: each section compares both plays on one point (the husband’s pride; the setting as trap; the ending). Harder, but it keeps the comparison alive. Use point-by-point for this essay.
Step 5 — Link the sections (11-12.W.3.A.d). Varied syntax clarifies relationships between claims, reasons and evidence. Use subordinate clauses to hold both plays in one sentence: Whereas Torvald’s pride is social, Keeney’s is professional; both, however, turn a wife into a measure of the husband’s standing. Use short sentences for turns in the argument. Avoid starting every paragraph with “In A Doll’s House …”.
Applying reading standards (11-12.RL.1.A). Your analysis should show how O’Neill draws on and transforms Ibsen’s material — a named standard move at grades 11-12. You do not need evidence that O’Neill had Ibsen in mind (though Ibsen’s plays were being staged in America in these years); you need to show what the comparison reveals.
Staging and translation. Plan one staging choice from each play (the letter box, the tarantella, the slammed door; the organ, the ice, the ship’s cabin) and one translator’s word choice from Lesson 2.2.
Revision. Stage 2 readers will first ask: could a thoughtful reader disagree with your claim? If not, sharpen it.
📖 Before this lesson, read: A Doll’s House, The whole play (Acts I-III)
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Reading: A mentor paragraph, a model plan and criteria for the comparative claim
James Huneker, Iconoclasts: A Book of Dramatists (New York: Scribner, 1905), chapter VII, ‘A Doll’s House’, Project Gutenberg 47546 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/47546), retrieved 2026-09-26. Henrik Ibsen, A Doll’s House (1879), translated by R. Farquharson Sharp (1910), Project Gutenberg 2542 (https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/2542), retrieved 2026-09-26, cited by act. Eugene O’Neill, Ile, in The Moon of the Caribbees and Six Other Plays of the Sea (Boni and Liveright, 1919), pp. 117-143; OCR text at https://archive.org/download/moonofthecaribbe00oneirich/moonofthecaribbe00oneirich_djvu.txt (Internet Archive, retrieved 2026-09-26), running heads removed, OCR errors repaired. · SLS original; quoted passages are public domain (James Huneker, 1905; Henrik Ibsen, tr. R. Farquharson Sharp, 1910; Eugene O’Neill, Ile, 1919)
Study the moves in the mentor paragraph, compare your plan with the model, then check your plan against the criteria before you submit Stage 1.
This page has four things: a mentor paragraph by a critic of 1905, a Stage 1 plan for the comparative essay written as a model (SLS original), a before-and-after revision of a claim, and the criteria your Stage 1 will be scored against. The quotations from the plays are from Sharp’s 1910 translation of Ibsen and O’Neill’s Ile (1919 printing), and I have checked each against the text. Use the model as a guide to the moves, not as a place to borrow claims. Your own claim has to come from your own reading.
Part 1. A mentor paragraph
James Huneker wrote about Ibsen for American readers in Iconoclasts (1905). This paragraph makes a disputable claim about the play, meets the objection to it, and ends by placing the play in a public controversy. Its wording of Nora is of its time, and you should not copy it. The moves are what to study.
It is Nora as an individual cheated of her true rights that the dramatist depicts, for her marriage, as she discovers in the crisis, has been merely material and not that spiritual tie Ibsen insists upon as the only happy one in this relation. So she goes away to find herself, and her going was the signal for almost a social war in Europe. His critics forgot that Ibsen was a skilled deviser of theatric effects, and such an unconventional exit was not without its artistic values. This does not mean that he was insincere–Nora’s departure is a logical necessity. Without it the play would be sheer sentimental, and therefore banal, nonsense. Nevertheless, that slammed door reverberated across the roof of the world, and not over the knocking at the gate in Macbeth was there such critical controversy.
Moves to notice. The claim is stated flatly: Nora’s departure is a logical necessity. The paragraph gives the reason: Without it the play would be sheer sentimental, and therefore banal, nonsense. It answers the objection ahead of time: This does not mean that he was insincere. And the last sentence says why the claim matters, by placing it inside the argument over the door. What it lacks is any quotation from the play itself, and that is what your paragraphs need to add.
Part 2. A model Stage 1 plan (SLS original)
Claim. Ibsen treats a wife’s leaving as a decision that reason can reach and words can win; O’Neill asks the same question in a place where words cannot win, and shows that the freedom to leave depends on circumstances a wife does not control.
Significance. The claim shows how drama moved between 1879 and 1917 from a theater of argument to a theater of circumstance, and it lets us see what is at stake in Nora’s door: it is a choice only because the house has one.
An alternative reading. Some readers see Ile as a tragedy of one man’s obsession, in which Annie is an incidental victim. My reading puts her at the center, because it is Annie who states the claim in plain terms and Annie who is answered by the ice and not by argument.
The strongest counterclaim, with two quotations. Nora’s leaving is not a picture of free choice either: she has no money and no plan, and she admits it, How can I tell? I have no idea what is going to become of me. And in Ile the ice does not decide. Keeney has agreed to turn back, and it is he who reverses himself when the Mate reports open water to the north and he orders, Then get her ready and we’ll drive her through. On that reading the obstacle is Keeney’s pride and not the setting.
Response. Nora’s uncertainty is a cost she chooses to pay; she can pay it because the door is hers to shut. Annie’s plea, Take me home, David, if you love me as you say. is a request, and the answer is Keeney’s alone. The counterclaim describes what makes Keeney choose. My claim describes what makes Annie unable to.
Outline (point by point).
- The husband’s pride. Torvald defines his wife by a role: Before all else, you are a wife and a mother. Keeney defines himself by a record: I ain’t never come back home in all my days without a full ship. Compare how each treats his wife’s argument.
- The setting as a trap. The Helmers’ home is a playroom, and it has a door. Annie calls the cabin a prison cell of a room, with the ice all around. Compare what each setting allows.
- The ending. Nora goes; the play closes on The sound of a door shutting is heard from below. Annie stays, and the stage direction has her commences softly to play the organ again. Compare what each ending proves.
One staging choice from each play. Ibsen: the door heard from below, which ends the play with a sound and not an image. O’Neill: the organ, which Keeney bought for Annie and which she says she hates; in the ending it becomes the one thing she can do. One translation choice. doll-wife: Sharp’s hyphenated compound makes one idea out of two words. A version with a different compound would change how much the word sounds like a joke and how much like an accusation (see Lesson 2.2).
Part 3. Before and after: a claim revised
| Draft | Problem | Revision |
|---|---|---|
| Both plays are about women trapped in marriages. | True and undisputed; no one could disagree, and it does not say what the comparison shows. | Both plays begin with a wife shut into a house her husband has made; they differ in what they take the wife’s escape to depend on. |
| Nora is braver than Annie. | Disputable but shallow: it judges characters, and the plays never invite that comparison. | Ibsen makes leaving a choice, and O’Neill makes it a circumstance; the plays differ in what freedom requires. |
| Ibsen is better than O’Neill because Nora leaves. | Ranks the authors, and Annie’s ending is a different kind of ending, not a worse one. | O’Neill turns Ibsen’s door into ice: the same question, asked where reason cannot open the way. |
Linking sentence to imitate (SLS original). Whereas Torvald’s pride is social, Keeney’s is professional; both, however, turn a wife into a measure of the husband’s standing.
Part 4. Criteria for Stage 1 (four levels)
| Criterion | Beginning | Developing | Proficient | Exemplary |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claim (11-12.W.2.A) | Summary or a topic. | A claim that is true but undisputed. | Precise, disputable, and comparative. | Also states what the difference between the plays reveals and why it matters. |
| Alternative and counterclaim (11-12.W.2.A) | None. | Named but not developed. | Developed with one quotation and answered. | The strongest counterclaim, from the text, with two quotations, answered fairly. |
| Evidence from both plays | One play only. | Both, but in separate blocks. | Both, quoted in every section of the outline. | Also one staging choice from each play and one translation choice, analyzed. |
| Structure and linking (11-12.W.3.A.d) | Block structure or a list. | Point by point, sections not linked. | Point by point, sections linked with varied syntax. | Also the order of sections builds toward the claim. |
Part 5. Stage 2 questions to ask a partner (SLS original)
Could a thoughtful reader reject this claim? Does every section put both plays in the same paragraph? Is the counterclaim from the text or made up? Did I quote what I said I quoted, and does the quotation prove what I say it proves? A partner who cannot find a place to disagree has found a problem with the claim.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Which is the strongest comparative claim?
A block structure — all of one play, then all of the other — is the best way to keep a comparison alive in every paragraph.
Submit Stage 1: your comparative claim and its significance; one alternative reading you reject; the strongest counterclaim with two quotations; a point-by-point outline of three sections, each with quotations from both plays; one staging choice from each play and one translation choice.
How confident are you that you can write a disputable comparative claim and develop a textual counterclaim?
A Doll’s House, The whole play (Acts I-III)
A Doll’s House, The whole play (Acts I-III) so far Bridge summary — not the primary text
A recap of what you have already read, written for this course, so the reading check below does not require re-opening every earlier popover.
In Act I, on Christmas Eve, Nora Helmer confides to her old friend Christine Linde that she secretly borrowed money to save her husband Torvald’s life, and the lender, Krogstad, threatens to expose the signature she forged unless she saves his job at the Bank Torvald now manages. In Act II, Torvald dismisses Krogstad anyway, Krogstad drops a letter revealing everything into the locked letter box, and Nora holds off its discovery by dancing the tarantella while she counts the hours she believes she has left. In Act III, Christine and Krogstad reunite and let the letter stand; Torvald reads it and turns on Nora, then forgives her the moment a second letter returns the bond. Nora sits him down for the first serious conversation of their marriage, tells him she has been a doll-wife, and leaves, and the play ends with the sound of the door shutting behind her.