
use the Stefan-Boltzmann law and an energy-balance model to calculate Earth’s temperature without greenhouse gases, and explain how greenhouse gases and albedo change the flow of energy and the climate.
Instruction
Balance. Over time, a planet must lose as much energy as it gains; otherwise it keeps warming or cooling until it does. That simple idea lets us calculate what Earth’s temperature should be.
Energy in. Sunlight arrives at 1,361 W per square meter facing the Sun. Earth intercepts it over a disc of area πR2 but spreads it over a sphere of area 4πR2, so the average per square meter of surface is 1,361 / 4 ≈ 340 W/m2. Earth reflects about 30% of it (its albedo is about 0.30), from clouds, ice and bright surfaces. Absorbed: 1,361 × (1 − 0.30) / 4 ≈ 238 W/m2.
Energy out. Every object emits infrared radiation according to its temperature. The Stefan-Boltzmann law gives the power per square meter: P = σT4, with σ = 5.67 × 10−8 W/(m2·K4) and T in kelvin.
Worked example: Earth without greenhouse gases. Set energy out equal to energy in: σT4 = 238. Then T4 = 238 / (5.67 × 10−8) ≈ 4.2 × 109, and T ≈ 255 K, or about −18 °C. But Earth’s actual average surface temperature is about 288 K (15 °C). The difference, about 33 °C, is the natural greenhouse effect. Without it, the oceans would freeze.
How the greenhouse effect works. Sunlight is mostly visible light, which passes through the air and warms the surface. The warm surface emits infrared radiation: at 288 K, σT4 ≈ 390 W/m2, far more than the 238 W/m2 that finally leaves the top of the atmosphere. The difference is caught on the way out. Molecules with three or more atoms, or two different atoms, such as water vapor (H2O), carbon dioxide (CO2) and methane (CH4), bend and stretch in ways that absorb infrared energy and then re-emit it in all directions, including back down. Nitrogen and oxygen, 99% of the air, do not. So the surface receives energy from both the Sun and the atmosphere, and it warms until the energy escaping to space again equals the energy absorbed. The name is misleading: a real greenhouse stays warm mainly by stopping warm air from rising away, not by absorbing infrared.
Changing the balance. Two kinds of change shift the balance, and the model shows the size of each.
- Albedo. If the albedo fell from 0.30 to 0.25 (less ice and snow), the no-greenhouse temperature would rise from 255 K to about 259 K; if it rose to 0.35 (more cloud or ice), it would fall to about 250 K.
- More greenhouse gases. Adding CO2 makes it harder for infrared to escape, so for a while less energy leaves than arrives. Satellites measure Earth now gaining roughly 1 W/m2 more than it loses, and most of that extra energy goes into the ocean.
Feedbacks. Warming increases evaporation, and more water vapor, itself a greenhouse gas, adds more warming: a reinforcing feedback. Melting snow and ice lowers albedo: another. Doubling CO2 alone (3.7 W/m2) would warm Earth by only about 1 °C; with feedbacks, the IPCC’s best estimate is about 3 °C, with a likely range of 2.5-4 °C.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Simulation & tools
Photons, greenhouse gases and surface temperature
Open the Photons screen. Start the Sun with the greenhouse gas concentration set to its lowest setting and turn on the thermometer. Wait until the surface temperature stops changing and record it. Then set the concentration to the highest setting (or step through the date presets from the ice age to today) and record the new steady temperature each time. Watch individual infrared photons: what happens when one meets a greenhouse gas molecule?
Then open the Layer Model screen, add one absorbing layer, and record the surface temperature. Change the surface albedo and record the effect. Explain in two sentences how each setting changes the flow of energy out of the system.
No sim? Use the energy-balance equation in the lesson: compute the temperature for albedos of 0.25, 0.30 and 0.35 and explain what adding greenhouse gases does to the 390 W/m2 leaving the surface.
Open in a new tab ↗ · PhET Interactive Simulations, University of Colorado Boulder · CC BY 4.0
A planet absorbs an average of 150 W/m². Using σT⁴ = 150 with σ = 5.67 × 10⁻⁸, about what is its no-greenhouse temperature?
Nitrogen and oxygen, which make up 99% of the atmosphere, are the main greenhouse gases.
Earth absorbs about W/m² on average; without greenhouse gases its temperature would be about K instead of the actual 288 K.
Draw a labeled energy-flow diagram of Earth with numbers: 340 W/m² arriving, about 102 W/m² reflected, 238 W/m² absorbed, 390 W/m² emitted by the surface, and 238 W/m² leaving to space. Show where greenhouse gases intercept and re-emit energy. Then explain in three sentences what happens to the flows, and then to temperature, when CO₂ increases.
How confident are you that you can calculate Earth’s energy balance and explain how greenhouse gases and albedo change climate?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- How much power per square meter does a surface at 288 K emit? (σ = 5.67 × 10−8)
Check your answer
Answer: about 390 W/m2σT4. - Find Earth’s absorbed sunlight per square meter: 1,361 W/m2, albedo 0.30.
Check your answer
Answer: about 238 W/m21,361 × 0.70 / 4. - Find Earth’s no-greenhouse temperature for albedo 0.30.
Check your answer
Answer: about 255 KT = (238 / σ)1/4.
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Find the no-greenhouse temperature if Earth’s albedo were 0.25 and if it were 0.35.
Check your answer
Answer: about 259 K and 250 K - Mars receives 586 W/m2 and has an albedo of about 0.25. Find its no-greenhouse temperature. (Its thin CO2 atmosphere adds only a few degrees.)
Check your answer
Answer: about 210 K - Venus receives about 2,601 W/m2 and reflects about 76% of it. Find its no-greenhouse temperature and compare with its measured surface temperature of about 737 K. What explains the difference?
Check your answer
Answer: about 229 K; the surface is about 508 K hotter because its very thick CO2 atmosphere produces an enormous greenhouse effect
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- Without feedbacks, a forcing ΔF changes the emitting temperature by about ΔF / (4σT3) at T = 255 K. Estimate the no-feedback warming for doubled CO2 (3.7 W/m2) and compare with the IPCC best estimate of about 3 °C.
Check your answer
Answer: about 1.0 K; feedbacks such as water vapor and melting ice roughly triple it
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- A sample starts with 100 g of an isotope whose half-life is 1600 years. How much remains after 4,800.0 years?
Check your answer
Answer: 12.50 g4,800.0 years is 3 half-lives; halve 3 times.
Two Hundred Fifty-Five Kelvin: The Energy Balance Worked for Five Albedos, One Layer and a Quiz Planet
SLS worked energy-balance calculations; NASA Earth Observatory, Climate and Earth’s Energy Budget; NASA/NOAA 2021 energy-imbalance study; IPCC AR6 WGI SPM statement A.4.4 (cited as findings) · SLS original, with public-domain NASA figures and IPCC findings cited as facts
Why this reading. This workshop is a calculation, and a calculation you can check is worth more than one you copy. Here is the energy-balance model worked for five albedos, the surface and one-layer cases, NASA’s measured budget to compare against, the quiz planet, and a route through the PhET simulation’s two screens for anyone who cannot open it. The IPCC and NASA figures are cited as findings; the arithmetic is SLS.
The two equations
Energy in, averaged over the whole surface: S(1 − a)/4, with S = 1,361 W/m2 the solar constant and a the albedo. The 4 is the ratio of a sphere’s area (4πR2) to the disc that intercepts sunlight (πR2). Energy out: σT4 per square meter, σ = 5.67 × 10−8 W/(m2·K4). Setting them equal and solving for T gives the temperature a planet with no greenhouse gases would settle at.
Table 1. The no-greenhouse temperature for five albedos
| Albedo | Reflected (W/m2) | Absorbed (W/m2) | T4 = absorbed / σ | T (K) | T (°C) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.20 | 68.0 | 272.2 | 4.801e+09 | 263.2 | -9.9 |
| 0.25 | 85.1 | 255.2 | 4.501e+09 | 259.0 | -14.1 |
| 0.30 | 102.1 | 238.2 | 4.201e+09 | 254.6 | -18.6 |
| 0.35 | 119.1 | 221.2 | 3.901e+09 | 249.9 | -23.2 |
| 0.40 | 136.1 | 204.2 | 3.601e+09 | 245.0 | -28.2 |
The lesson’s numbers are the middle row: 340.25 W/m2 arriving (1,361/4), about 102 reflected, 238 absorbed, T4 = 4.2 × 109 and T = 255 K (254.6 unrounded), or −18 °C. Albedo 0.25 gives 259 K and 0.35 gives 250 K, as the lesson says. Notice how gentle the fourth root is: 7% more absorbed energy (0.25 against 0.30) buys only 4.4 K. That gentleness is why the Stefan-Boltzmann law is such a strong thermostat, and why a 2 or 3 W/m2 forcing has to be amplified by feedbacks to matter.
The quiz planet, and the surface
A planet absorbing 150 W/m2: T4 = 150 / 5.67 × 10−8 = 2.65 × 109, T = 227 K. Earth’s actual surface at 288 K emits σ × 2884 = 390 W/m2, yet only about 238 leaves the top of the atmosphere. The 152 W/m2 difference is absorbed on the way out by water vapor, carbon dioxide, methane and clouds and partly re-emitted downward; that is the natural greenhouse effect, worth 288 − 255 = 33 °C.
One absorbing layer: the PhET Layer Model, on paper
The simulation’s Layer Model screen is this calculation. Put one layer above the surface that lets sunlight through and absorbs all infrared. In balance, the layer must emit to space what the planet absorbs, 238 W/m2, so the layer is at 255 K. But the layer emits equally up and down, so the surface receives 238 from the Sun plus 238 from the layer and must emit 476 W/m2: Ts4 = 2 × 2554, Ts = 255 × 21/4 = 303 K. One perfect layer overshoots the real 288 K because the real atmosphere is not a perfect absorber at every wavelength; the simulation’s temperature will land between 255 and 303 K depending on how absorbing you make the layer, and its albedo slider reproduces Table 1. If you cannot open the simulation, report Table 1’s three middle rows and the 303 K layer result as your “readings.”
What NASA measures
NASA’s Earth Observatory summarizes the satellite budget in the same units: the Sun delivers about 1,360 W/m2 at the top of the atmosphere facing the Sun, about 340 W/m2 averaged over the globe, and the Earth system absorbs about 240 W/m2 once reflection is removed. Those three numbers are the ones the lesson asks you to put on your diagram (340 in, about 102 reflected, 238 absorbed, 390 emitted by the surface, 238 to space). In 2021 a joint NASA–NOAA study, using the CERES satellite instruments and the Argo ocean floats independently, found that Earth’s energy imbalance, the excess of absorbed over emitted energy, approximately doubled between 2005 and 2019; the lesson’s “roughly 1 W/m2” is the rounded size of that imbalance in recent years, and about 90% of the excess goes into the ocean.
Sensitivity, from the IPCC
Doubling carbon dioxide adds 5.35 ln 2 = 3.7 W/m2. Working that through Table 1’s arithmetic with no feedbacks gives about 1 °C: raising the emission to space from 238 to 241.7 W/m2 requires T to rise by a factor of (241.7/238)1/4, about 0.4%, or 1.0 K at 255 K. The IPCC’s 2021 assessment (Working Group I, statement A.4.4) reports that with feedbacks the equilibrium climate sensitivity has a best estimate of 3 °C per doubling, a likely range of 2.5 to 4 °C and a very likely range of 2 to 5 °C. The gap between 1 and 3 is the water-vapor, ice-albedo and cloud feedbacks the lesson describes.
A check on your diagram
Every arrow must balance at every boundary. At the top of the atmosphere: 340 in = 102 reflected + 238 emitted. At the surface: 390 emitted must be matched by sunlight absorbed at the surface plus infrared coming back down from the atmosphere. If your arrows do not add up, the model is not in balance and the planet’s temperature would still be changing, which is exactly the state Earth is in when CO2 is rising.
Sources: NASA Earth Observatory, Climate and Earth’s Energy Budget (earthobservatory.nasa.gov); NASA, Joint NASA-NOAA study finds Earth’s energy imbalance has doubled (2021) (nasa.gov); IPCC AR6 Working Group I, Summary for Policymakers (ipcc.ch); PhET Greenhouse Effect simulation (phet.colorado.edu)