
design, test and refine a model surface that reduces stormwater runoff and the pollution it carries, and evaluate it against criteria and constraints.
Instruction
A human impact we can see. In a spring thunderstorm, rain that falls on roofs, streets and parking lots cannot soak in, so it runs off, picking up oil, metals from brake pads, fertilizer, pet waste and litter. Where it goes depends on the pipes. The Metropolitan St. Louis Sewer District (MSD), which serves about 1.3 million people, runs about 3,000 miles of storm sewers that carry rainwater and street runoff, 4,700 miles of wastewater sewers, and 1,700 miles of older combined sewers that carry both in the same pipe. In moderate to heavy rain, combined sewers overflow, sending a mix of stormwater and wastewater into local streams. Under a consent decree with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency that took effect in 2012, MSD agreed to spend at least $4.7 billion over 23 years to reduce those overflows. In the Ozarks, runoff can also pour into sinkholes and losing streams and reach groundwater and springs with little filtering. Natural ground would have absorbed much of that water and filtered it.
Runoff coefficient. Engineers describe a surface by its runoff coefficient C: the fraction of rain that runs off. A roof or asphalt lot has C of about 0.9 (Boone County, Missouri’s drainage standards list 0.85 for asphalt streets and 0.87 for roofs in a 10-year storm); a flat lawn is about 0.17. The volume of runoff is V = C × area × rain depth.
Worked example. One centimeter of rain falls on a 1-hectare (10,000 m2) parking lot with C = 0.9: V = 0.9 × 10,000 × 0.01 = 90 m3, or 90,000 liters, in one modest storm. If the lot were rebuilt with permeable pavement and planted strips so that C fell to about 0.2 (an illustrative value), runoff would be 20 m3. The other 70 m3 would soak in, recharging groundwater (Unit 1) and leaving much of its pollution in the soil, where microbes can break some of it down.
Solutions to test. Engineers and cities use several green infrastructure designs:
- Permeable pavement: concrete, asphalt or pavers with gaps, over a bed of gravel that stores water while it soaks in.
- Rain gardens and bioswales: shallow planted basins that collect runoff from roofs and streets.
- Cisterns: tanks that capture roof water for later use in dry months.
The engineering design process. Engineering starts by defining the problem with criteria (what the solution must do: for example, cut runoff by at least half) and constraints (limits: cost, space, the need for cars to drive on it, maintenance). It breaks a big problem into smaller ones: how to let water through, how to store it, how to keep the surface strong. It then builds, tests, measures and refines. A first design rarely meets every criterion; the data show which part to change.
Evaluating fairly. A fair test keeps rain amount, rain rate, tray slope and tray size the same for every surface. You will also check the quality of the runoff: a spoonful of soil and a drop of food coloring on each surface stand for the pollutants of a city street. A design that lets water soak in but leaves the color in the gravel is doing both jobs.
Limits of a tray. Real permeable pavements can clog with fine sediment and need vacuum sweeping, and they suit parking lots and quiet streets better than highways. Include these real constraints when you judge your design.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Lab: Build and Test a Permeable Pavement
Question. Which surface design sheds the least runoff and pollution in a model rainstorm, and how can the best design be improved?
Materials
- Three identical shallow foil baking pans or cut-open milk cartons, each with a small hole cut at one low corner to drain runoff into a cup
- Plastic wrap and tape (impermeable ‘asphalt’)
- Aquarium gravel, sand and potting soil (or garden soil), plus a handful of shredded leaves or mulch
- A watering can or a plastic cup with holes punched in the bottom (the ‘rain’), and a kitchen measuring cup marked in mL
- Food coloring and a spoonful of soil per trial (the ‘pollutants’)
- Books or blocks to raise each tray by 3 cm, collection cups, and a phone stopwatch
- A 500 g weight, such as an unopened 500 g bag of rice or pasta
- Wear safety glasses: muddy water can splash when poured. Tell a parent or guardian before you start.
- Work outdoors or over a bathtub, wipe up spills so no one slips, and wash hands after handling soil. Food coloring stains: wear old clothes or an apron. Nothing in this lab is tasted.
Procedure
- Build three surfaces of the same size: A, plastic wrap stretched over sand (impermeable pavement); B, 2 cm of gravel over 2 cm of sand (permeable pavement); C, your own design (for example soil with a mulch strip or a small ‘rain garden’ dip). Write your criteria (for example, runoff under 50% of rain) and constraints (materials, the surface must support a 500 g weight without sinking more than 5 mm).
- Raise the upper end of each tray by 3 cm. Sprinkle a spoonful of soil and two drops of food coloring on the upper half of each surface.
- Pour 500 mL of ‘rain’ evenly over each tray in 30 seconds. Collect runoff from the drain hole for 3 minutes.
- Measure the runoff volume, compute the runoff coefficient (runoff / 500 mL), and rate the runoff’s color and cloudiness on a 0-3 scale.
- Refine design C using your data, test it again, and test each surface with the 500 g weight.
Data
| Surface | Rain (mL) | Runoff (mL) | Runoff coefficient | Color/cloudiness (0-3) | Sank under 500 g? (mm) | Meets criteria? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A Impermeable | 500 | |||||
| B Permeable | 500 | |||||
| C Your design | 500 | |||||
| C Refined | 500 |
Analysis
- Claim: which design best reduced runoff and pollution while meeting your constraints? Use runoff coefficients and pollution ratings as evidence.
- What did you change in your refined design, why, and did the data show an improvement? Explain the mechanism.
- Scale up: if your best coefficient applied to a 1-hectare store parking lot, how much runoff would 1 cm of rain produce, compared with 90 m³ for asphalt?
- Sources of error and limits: how might uneven pouring, water soaking into the tray edges, and the short test time affect your results? Name one real-world constraint the tray does not capture.
If you cannot do this lab in person: No pans or outdoor space? Use the recorded three-surface run in this lesson’s reading (rlp-esb-runoff-lab-record): compute each runoff coefficient from its volumes, judge it against the criteria, and propose your own refinement from the data.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
A 2,000 m² school roof (C = 0.9) receives 2 cm of rain. How much runoff does it produce?
In the oldest parts of the St. Louis area, rainwater from streets can flow into the same pipes as household wastewater, and heavy rain can send that mix into streams untreated.
In the lab, ‘the surface must hold a 500 g weight’ is a , while ‘runoff under 50% of the rain’ is a .
Break the problem ‘make a school parking lot shed less polluted runoff’ into three smaller problems (for example, letting water through, storing it, keeping the surface usable). For each, propose one solution and one test that would show whether it works.
How confident are you that you can design, test and refine a solution that reduces stormwater runoff and evaluate it against criteria and constraints?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Convert 25 kPa to atm.
Check your answer
Answer: 0.2467 atm - 1 cm of rain falls on a 1-hectare (10,000 m2) parking lot with C = 0.9. How much runoff is produced?
Check your answer
Answer: 90 m3 (90,000 L)V = C × area × depth. - In the lab, 500 mL of rain on the impermeable tray produced 430 mL of runoff. What is the runoff coefficient?
Check your answer
Answer: 0.86 - The permeable tray produced 120 mL of runoff from 500 mL. What is its runoff coefficient?
Check your answer
Answer: 0.24
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- A 2,000 m2 school parking lot (C = 0.9) is rebuilt as permeable pavement (C = 0.24, from the lab). How much runoff is avoided in a 2 cm storm?
Check your answer
Answer: 26.4 m3(0.9 − 0.24) × 2,000 × 0.02. - Name one criterion and two constraints for a permeable pavement at a school, and one maintenance issue.
Check your answer
Answer: Criterion: cut runoff by at least half. Constraints: must carry buses and cars; must fit the budget. Maintenance: fine sediment clogs pores, so it needs regular vacuum sweeping. - Your first design’s runoff was 260 mL of 500; after adding a mulch strip it was 150 mL. By what percentage did the refinement reduce runoff?
Check your answer
Answer: about 42%
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- A 200 m2 roof (C = 0.9) drains to a rain garden 0.15 m deep. How large must the garden be to hold the runoff from a 2.5 cm storm?
Check your answer
Answer: 4.5 m3 of runoff; about 30 m2 of gardenVolume ÷ depth.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Review (Unit 2): how much energy warms 1.0 kg of water by 10 °C?
Check your answer
Answer: 41,840 J
Runoff Coefficients, St. Louis Sewers and a Recorded Tray Run
Boone County, Missouri, Road Regulations Appendix F, Table C-2 (rational-method runoff coefficients); MSD Project Clear, About MSD and Consent Decree pages; SLS original illustrative tray-test data; retrieved November 6, 2026 · SLS original, citing Missouri county and public-agency records (brief quotations only)
Why this reading. The lab asks you to compare your trays with real design values and to scale your best coefficient up to a parking lot. This reading hosts a Missouri county’s published runoff-coefficient table, the St. Louis sewer facts the lesson uses, and a complete recorded run of the lesson’s own three-tray procedure, so you can finish every analysis question even without pans or outdoor space. Retrieved November 6, 2026.
1. Published runoff coefficients (Boone County, Missouri)
Boone County’s road regulations (Appendix F, Table C-2) give rational-method runoff coefficients, C, for use in Q = CiA. A coefficient rises with storm size because wet ground soaks up less. Selected rows:
| Surface | 2-year storm | 10-year storm | 100-year storm |
|---|---|---|---|
| Asphalt streets | 0.78 | 0.85 | 0.96 |
| Concrete streets, drives and walks | 0.82 | 0.90 | 0.99 |
| Roofs | 0.79 | 0.87 | 0.99 |
| Lawn, light (loam) soil, flat 0–2% | 0.15 | 0.17 | 0.21 |
| Lawn, heavy clay soil, steep 7%+ | 0.27 | 0.31 | 0.37 |
| Woodland or pasture, light soil, flat 0–2% | 0.23 | 0.27 | 0.33 |
| Woodland or pasture, heavy clay, steep 7%+ | 0.44 | 0.51 | 0.62 |
The table also warns that C is the variable in the rational method “least susceptible to precise determination,” which is why your own measurement is worth taking. The lesson’s 0.9 for asphalt sits between the 10-year and 100-year values. Permeable pavement is not in the table; the lesson’s 0.2 for it is illustrative, and real permeable pavement clogged with fine sediment performs much worse until it is vacuum-swept.
2. Where St. Louis runoff goes (MSD Project Clear)
| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| People and area served | About 1.3 million people over 520 square miles |
| Sewer types | About 4,700 miles of wastewater sewers and force mains; 3,000 miles of stormwater sewers and force mains; 1,700 miles of combined sewers, which carry both stormwater and wastewater |
| Age | About 524 miles more than 80 years old and 311 miles more than 120 years old; some of the earliest pipes date from the 1850s |
| Overflows | In moderate to heavy rain, combined sewers discharge a mix of stormwater and wastewater into local waterways; more than 350 overflow points were removed between 1992 and 2012 and fewer than 400 remain |
| Consent decree | Settlement with EPA and the Missouri Coalition for the Environment filed August 2011, effective April 27, 2012: at least $4.7 billion over 23 years, including “rainscaping” (green infrastructure) |
Every cubic meter of rain that soaks in on a lot or yard is a cubic meter that never enters those pipes.
3. A recorded run of the lesson’s procedure (illustrative SLS data)
Built to the lesson’s own procedure: 500 mL of “rain” over 30 seconds, trays raised 3 cm, runoff collected for 3 minutes. It is one plausible home run, not a measurement of any real pavement.
| Surface | Rain (mL) | Runoff (mL) | Runoff coefficient | Color/cloudiness (0–3) | Sank under 500 g (mm) | Meets “under 50%”? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. Impermeable (plastic over sand) | 500 | 430 | 0.86 | 3 | 0 | No |
| B. Permeable (gravel over sand) | 500 | 120 | 0.24 | 2 | 3 | Yes |
| C. First design (bare soil) | 500 | 260 | 0.52 | 2 | 7 | No |
| C. Refined (soil + mulch strip) | 500 | 150 | 0.30 | 1 | 6 | Yes |
The mulch strip cut runoff from 260 mL to 150 mL, a reduction of (260 − 150) ÷ 260 = 42%, and caught much of the color, because mulch slows water so more soaks in and traps soil particles. It still sank more than the 5 mm load criterion allows, a real trade-off between soaking in and carrying weight, the same trade-off that keeps permeable pavement in parking lots rather than on highways.
Scaling up. Design C-refined on a 1-hectare lot in a 1 cm rain: V = 0.30 × 10,000 × 0.01 = 30 m3, against 90 m3 for asphalt at C = 0.9 and 20 m3 for the lesson’s illustrative permeable pavement at C = 0.2.
Error sources to discuss. Uneven pouring, water soaking into the edges of the pan, water still draining after 3 minutes, and a single trial per surface.
Sources: Boone County, Missouri, Road Regulations, Appendix F (Stormwater design), Table C-2: Rational Method Runoff Coefficients (showmeboone.com); MSD Project Clear, About MSD (Metropolitan St. Louis Sewer District) (msdprojectclear.org); MSD Project Clear, Consent Decree (msdprojectclear.org)