
specify criteria and constraints for a real Missouri hazard or impact, break it into smaller problems, and evaluate competing solutions with a cost-benefit ratio and trade-offs, defending my proposal before an audience.
Instruction
The challenge. Choose a Missouri community and one hazard or human impact it faces, and propose an engineering solution that makes the community more resilient. Hazards could include tornadoes, river flooding, New Madrid earthquake shaking, drought and extreme heat, polluted runoff or lead left in soil by old mines. You work on your own; a family member can read your draft or play a council member at the end.
The engineering process you will follow.
- Define the problem (9-12.ETS1.A.1). Explain the Earth-science causes of the hazard with evidence from this course. Then specify criteria (measurable goals, such as “reduce expected annual loss by half” or “keep runoff under 30% of rainfall”) and constraints (cost, space, law, time, fairness to every neighborhood). Rank them.
- Break it down (9-12.ETS1.A.2). Split the big problem into smaller ones that can each be solved. For tornadoes in a town like Joplin: warning everyone in time, giving every resident a strong place to shelter, and building homes whose roofs and walls stay attached are three different sub-problems.
- Evaluate solutions (9-12.ETS1.B.1). Compare at least two solutions in a trade-off matrix: list your criteria as rows with weights, score each solution, and total the weighted scores. Add a benefit-cost ratio for each solution.
- Test or simulate. Use evidence from one of this unit’s labs (runoff trays, shake table) or simulations (NetLogo, a spreadsheet model), and say what that evidence can and cannot show.
A worked trade-off matrix (illustrative). A Missouri River town compares two flood solutions. Criteria and weights: lives protected (weight 5), cost (3), ecological harm (2), time to finish (2). Solution 1, raising the levee, scores 4, 3, 2, 4; solution 2, a voluntary buyout that moves homes off the floodplain and reconnects it to the river (like the Big Muddy refuge or the L-536 levee setback), scores 4, 2, 5, 2. Weighted totals: solution 1 = 5×4 + 3×3 + 2×2 + 2×4 = 20 + 9 + 4 + 8 = 41; solution 2 = 5×4 + 3×2 + 2×5 + 2×2 = 20 + 6 + 10 + 4 = 40. The totals are almost equal, which tells you something important: the choice depends on the weights, and on whether the two can be combined. State that honestly.
Equity and people. Hazards fall hardest on people with the fewest resources to prepare or recover. A strong proposal says who benefits, who pays, and how it will reach renters, people in mobile homes, older residents and people who do not speak English. Remember the human impact of the disasters you cite, and describe it accurately and with respect.
The defense. You will record a four-minute presentation to a mock city council, then answer in writing at least two questions about cost, fairness and evidence, chosen from the question bank in this lesson’s reading or asked by a family member playing a council member. Prepare by anticipating the three hardest questions.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Weights: safety 5, cost 3, time 2. A solution scores safety 3, cost 4, time 5. What is its weighted total?
‘The solution must be affordable for renters as well as homeowners’ is a constraint that accounts for societal needs.
Draft your trade-off matrix: at least four weighted criteria and two solutions, with scores and totals. Then write three sentences explaining how your recommendation would change if the heaviest-weighted criterion were given half its weight.
How confident are you that you can specify criteria and constraints, break down a hazard problem and evaluate solutions with trade-offs?
Unit 4 checkpoint
Do this before you start the task. It covers the whole unit and tells you what to review first.
A 5% annual chance of a $10 million loss gives what expected annual loss?
Risk depends on exposure and vulnerability as well as on the hazard.
After the Great Flood of 1993, what did the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service create on flood-damaged Missouri River land bought from willing sellers?
500 mL of rain producing 200 mL of runoff gives a runoff coefficient of .
In a combined sewer, rainwater from streets and household wastewater flow in the same pipe.
Which is a constraint rather than a criterion for a permeable pavement?
A project costs $2 million and yields $9 million in benefits. What is its benefit-cost ratio?
Wind turbines in Missouri produce electricity at their full rated power all year.
In the NetLogo Fire model, what happens near 59% tree density?
Weights 5, 3 and 2 with scores 2, 4 and 5 give a weighted total of .
Submit: Engineering Resilience proposal (1,200-1,500 words) + recorded four-minute defense to a mock city council
Task: Write an engineering proposal for one Missouri community and one hazard or human impact. Include (1) the Earth-science causes of the hazard, with evidence; (2) prioritized criteria and constraints, including societal needs and equity; (3) the problem broken into at least three smaller problems; (4) at least two solutions compared in a weighted trade-off matrix and with benefit-cost ratios; (5) evidence from a lab test or a simulation, with its limits; (6) a recommendation with its trade-offs. Cite Earle’s Physical Geology, USGS, NOAA and the National Weather Service, FEMA, the Missouri State Emergency Management Agency, the Missouri Department of Natural Resources (Missouri Geological Survey) or local agency sources. Label illustrative numbers.
Submission workflow
- Stage 1 — Plan. Your community, hazard, ranked criteria and constraints, sub-problems, and the two solutions you will compare, with the test or simulation you will use.
- Stage 2 — Self-reviewed draft. Recheck your trade-off matrix and benefit-cost arithmetic against the formulas in this lesson’s reading, test whether each criterion is measurable, and mark any claim about causes that has no evidence; a parent or guardian may also read it. Submit your completed checklist and your revision plan.
- Stage 3 — Final proposal. 1,200-1,500 words with the matrix, calculations, evidence, sources and recommendation.
- Stage 4 — Defense. Four minutes to a mock city council, recorded (family members may act as the council), followed by written answers to at least two questions about cost, fairness or evidence.
How it is scored
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Criteria and constraints (9-12.ETS1.A.1) | Measurable, prioritized criteria and realistic constraints that account for societal needs, safety, cost and equity. |
| Problem decomposition (9-12.ETS1.A.2) | The problem is broken into at least three solvable sub-problems, each linked to part of the solution. |
| Evaluation of solutions (9-12.ETS1.B.1) | Weighted trade-off matrix and benefit-cost ratios are correct, and the recommendation follows from them with trade-offs stated. |
| Hazard science (9-12.ESS3.A.1, 9-12.ESS3.C.2) | Explains the Earth-science causes of the hazard or impact with evidence, and how the solution reduces risk or human impact. |
| Evidence from testing (SEP.6, CCC.2) | Uses lab or simulation evidence appropriately and states its limits. |
| Communication (WHST.9-10.1, RST.9-10.1) | Clear, well-sourced proposal; defense answers questions with evidence. |
An Engineering Resilience Dossier for Missouri: Hosted Figures by Hazard, Formulas and Checklists
Compiled from rlp-esb-missouri-hazards-record, rlp-esb-runoff-lab-record, rlp-esb-missouri-resource-weighing, rlp-esb-fire-shake-simulation-runs, rlp-biob-supp-missouri-resources-hazards, rlp-psb-new-madrid-usgs-sources, rlp-psb-new-madrid-warning-times and rlp-psa-battery-metals-source-file (NWS, FEMA, USGS, NOAA, EPA, MDC, MSD and Missouri statute sources); safe-room worked example illustrative; retrieved November 6, 2026 · SLS original compilation and arithmetic, citing public-domain U.S. government works and Missouri public records
Why this reading. The rubric asks you to explain the Earth-science causes of your hazard with evidence and to cite agencies accurately, whichever hazard you choose. This dossier sorts, by hazard, the hosted figures a Missouri proposal is likely to need and names the reading each came from, restates the formulas, works a second example, and gives the self-review checklist and council question bank for Stages 2 and 4. Retrieved November 6, 2026.
Part 1. Choose your hazard: what this unit has hosted
| Hazard | Key figures available | Reading(s) |
|---|---|---|
| Tornado | Joplin 2011: EF-5, winds above 200 mph, path 22.1 miles long and up to 1 mile wide, 158 direct deaths, more than 1,000 injured; 14 Joplin school safe rooms rated for 250 mph, FEMA share 75%; NIST’s tornado-design and shelter recommendations; bracing geometry | rlp-esb-missouri-hazards-record; rlp-esb-fire-shake-simulation-runs |
| River flooding | 1993 St. Louis crest 49.58 ft; Big Muddy refuge; FEMA Missouri buyout study (cost $44.2 million, losses avoided $93.6 million, ratio 2.12); 2019 flood and the L-536 levee setback (1,040 acres reconnected, about $103.5 million) | rlp-esb-missouri-hazards-record; rlp-biob-supp-missouri-resources-hazards |
| Earthquake shaking | 1811–1812 New Madrid sequence; USGS 50-year odds (7–10% for an 1811–1812-size event, 25–40% for magnitude 6+); RSMo 319.200 (new construction only); warning times from New Madrid to Missouri cities | rlp-esb-missouri-hazards-record; rlp-psb-new-madrid-usgs-sources; rlp-psb-new-madrid-warning-times |
| Drought and heat | 2012: 5.8 in of rain May–July, all 114 counties disaster areas, hottest year 58.6 °F; 2022–2024: 102 straight weeks of drought; Missouri water sources from Unit 1 | rlp-esb-missouri-hazards-record; Unit 1 readings |
| Polluted runoff | Boone County runoff coefficients; MSD’s 1,700 miles of combined sewers and $4.7 billion consent decree; a recorded tray run with a refined design | rlp-esb-runoff-lab-record |
| Wildfire | 224 Missouri wildfires and more than 15,500 acres in one week of March 2025; percolation threshold 59.3%; reference density run | rlp-esb-fire-shake-simulation-runs |
| Mine legacy | EPA cleanup of soil at more than 1,900 Fredericktown-area homes; children with elevated blood lead in Madison County about 27% in 1996, under 2% in 2019 | rlp-psa-battery-metals-source-file |
Part 2. The arithmetic, restated for reuse
Expected annual loss = annual probability × loss if it happens. Benefit-cost ratio = (loss prevented over the project’s life) ÷ (project cost). Weighted trade-off total = Σ (criterion weight × the solution’s score on that criterion), computed once per solution. All three are worked with numbers in Lessons 4.1 and 4.5; reuse the method with your own community’s numbers, and label any number you estimate as illustrative.
Part 3. A second worked example (illustrative): a tornado safe room
Suppose a town of 4,000 has a 0.5% chance each year of a violent tornado that, without shelters, would cause an estimated $20 million in injuries and losses that a community safe room could prevent half of. Expected annual loss = 0.005 × $20,000,000 = $100,000. A safe room that prevents half of it saves $50,000 a year, or $1.5 million over 30 years. If it costs $2 million, the benefit-cost ratio is 1.5 ÷ 2 = 0.75, below 1. With FEMA paying 75% the town’s own share is $500,000, a local ratio of 1.5 ÷ 0.5 = 3; and if the room doubles as a school gym, as Joplin’s do, the gym’s value adds to the benefit. A proposal should show both ratios and say whose money each one counts. All numbers here are invented for teaching.
Part 4. Equity: name a mechanism
A strong equity argument is specific. A grant program that requires a 25% local or household cost-share may be out of reach for renters and low-income owners; residents of mobile homes have no safe place in their own homes during a tornado; people who rely on outdoor sirens alone may get one 3-minute burst and no follow-up (the Joplin assessment found most residents waited for further confirmation before sheltering). Name the group, the barrier and the change that removes it.
Part 5. Self-review checklist (Stage 2)
- Every dated event or statistic names its agency (NWS, USGS, NOAA, FEMA, SEMA, Missouri DNR, EPA) or is labeled as an illustrative number.
- Each criterion is measurable (a number, a unit and a target).
- The trade-off matrix totals and every benefit-cost ratio have been recomputed from scratch.
- Every cause of the hazard is backed by evidence, not just asserted.
- Each test or simulation used (trays, shake table, NetLogo) has one sentence on what it leaves out.
Part 6. Council question bank (Stage 4; answer at least two in writing)
- Who pays for this, and what happens if the federal share does not come through?
- Which neighborhood benefits last, and why?
- What is your evidence that the hazard will happen here, and how likely is it each year?
- If we halved your most heavily weighted criterion, would your recommendation change?
- What does your lab or simulation leave out, and how could that make your solution fail?
- What will this cost to maintain in 20 years?
Sources: NWS Central Region Service Assessment, Joplin, Missouri, Tornado, May 22, 2011 (July 2011) (weather.gov); FEMA news release, Missouri Schools Build Safe Rooms to Shelter from Tornadoes (Aug. 28, 2019) (fema.gov); FEMA, Loss Avoidance Study: Eastern Missouri Building Acquisition (case study, updated Feb. 11, 2021) (fema.gov); USGS Fact Sheet 2009-3071, Earthquake Hazard in the New Madrid Seismic Zone Remains a Concern (pubs.usgs.gov); Revised Statutes of Missouri, section 319.200 (seismic construction ordinances; L. 1990 S.B. 539, as amended) (revisor.mo.gov); NOAA NCEI / NCICS, State Climate Summaries: Missouri (data through 2024) (statesummaries.ncics.org); MSD Project Clear, Consent Decree (msdprojectclear.org); Missouri Department of Conservation, MDC staff fought more than 80 wildfires around Missouri last week (Mar. 19, 2025) (mdc.mo.gov)