
evaluate competing ways of developing and using energy and mineral resources by comparing their costs, benefits and trade-offs, and argue for a choice with evidence.
Instruction
Every resource has a cost. All energy and all materials come from Earth: fuels, metals, the steel in wind turbines, the cobalt in batteries, the limestone in concrete. No option is free of impacts. The science question is not “Is it good or bad?” but “What are its costs and benefits, and for whom?”
Energy resources in Missouri. In 2024, Missouri’s power plants generated about 66.9 million MWh of electricity. Coal supplied 58.1% of it, down from 81.3% in 2010; the Callaway nuclear plant supplied 15.7%; natural gas 13.6%; wind 10.2%; and utility-scale solar only 0.3% (U.S. Energy Information Administration). Coal and gas plants can run whenever needed, but burning them releases carbon dioxide: across the United States in 2023, coal plants emitted about 2.31 pounds of CO2 per kWh (about 1.05 metric tons per MWh) and natural gas plants about 0.96 pounds per kWh (about 0.44 t/MWh). Wind and sunlight emit no CO2 while generating, but they come and go. In 2024, Missouri’s wind turbines produced only 32.3% of what they would have at full power all year, and its solar panels 18.5%, so a reliable supply needs storage or backup.
Mineral resources in Missouri. Missouri has led the nation in lead production for more than a century, today from the Viburnum Trend mines. Old mine waste near Fredericktown also holds cobalt and nickel, metals used in battery electrodes, and a company has worked since 2019 to reprocess those tailings. The United States imported 79% of the cobalt it used in 2025, and Congo (Kinshasa) mined an estimated 73% of the world’s supply (U.S. Geological Survey). Supporters of reprocessing point to a domestic supply and local jobs. Concerns include the lead in the same tailings, a Superfund site where EPA has already cleaned soil at more than 1,900 homes; water and chemical use; and whether the plant pays when cobalt prices swing. Limestone is the quiet giant: the Missouri Geological Survey reports that it is mined in 92 of Missouri’s 114 counties and that Missouri ranks first in the nation in lime production, with quarry dust, noise and truck traffic as local costs.
A cost-benefit ratio. One way to compare options is to count every cost and every benefit in the same units, often dollars. Worked example (illustrative round numbers, not quotes from any project). A town needs 100,000 MWh of electricity a year. Suppose wind with battery storage costs $70 per MWh, a natural gas plant $60 per MWh, and a coal plant $50 per MWh. Gas emits roughly 0.4 metric tons of CO2 per MWh, or 40,000 tons a year; coal about 1.0 t per MWh (rounded from EIA’s 1.05), or 100,000 tons a year. If each ton of CO2 causes an estimated $100 of damage (an illustrative value; published estimates vary widely), gas carries a hidden $4,000,000 a year and coal $10,000,000. Totals: wind with storage $7.0 million, gas $6.0 million + $4.0 million = $10.0 million, coal $5.0 million + $10.0 million = $15.0 million. If the benefit (reliable power) is the same, the benefit-cost ratio is highest for the option with the lowest full cost.
What the numbers leave out. A good analysis also lists what is hard to price: land (100,000 MWh of wind at Missouri’s 32.3% capacity factor needs about 35 MW of turbines spread across many farms), birds and bats, water, local air quality, jobs at power plants and mines, and reliability during a heat wave or a winter cold snap. Different people weigh these differently, which is why resource decisions are argued in public. Your argument must show its numbers, state its assumptions and name who gains and who pays.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
A gas plant produces 100,000 MWh a year and emits 0.4 t of CO₂ per MWh. At an illustrative $100 per ton, what is the yearly external cost?
To produce 100,000 MWh a year at Missouri’s 2024 wind capacity factor of 32.3%, a wind farm needs about MW of turbines, because 100,000 / (8,760 × 0.323) ≈ .
A 100 MW wind farm in Missouri produces about 100 MW × 8,760 h = 876,000 MWh of electricity a year.
Build a cost-benefit table for three options for one decision: either supplying a town’s electricity (wind with storage, natural gas, coal) or supplying cobalt for batteries (reprocessing the Fredericktown tailings, importing mined cobalt, recycling used batteries). Include at least one priced cost and two unpriced costs or benefits for each. Then write a CER argument for one option, state your assumptions, name who gains and who pays, and answer the strongest objection you can find (from a source, or raised by a family member) in writing or on a recording.
How confident are you that you can evaluate energy and mineral options with cost-benefit ratios and argue for a choice?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- How many MW of solar panels at Missouri’s 2024 solar capacity factor (18.5%) produce 100,000 MWh per year? (8,760 hours per year)
Check your answer
Answer: about 62 MW100,000 ÷ (8,760 × 0.185) ≈ 61.7. - How many MW of coal-plant capacity at Missouri’s 2024 coal capacity factor (47.3%) produce the same 100,000 MWh?
Check your answer
Answer: about 24.1 MW - A gas plant emits 0.4 t CO2 per MWh. How much CO2 for 100,000 MWh?
Check your answer
Answer: 40,000 t
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- Using illustrative costs (wind with storage $70/MWh; gas $60/MWh plus $100 per ton of CO2 at 0.4 t/MWh; coal $50/MWh plus $100 per ton of CO2 at 1.0 t/MWh), find the full yearly cost of 100,000 MWh from each and rank them.
Check your answer
Answer: wind with storage $7.0 million; gas $6.0 + $4.0 = $10.0 million; coal $5.0 + $10.0 = $15.0 million; wind with storage ranks first on full cost, then gas, then coal - List two costs that the dollar comparison leaves out for each of: a Missouri wind farm, and reprocessing the Fredericktown mine tailings for cobalt.
Check your answer
Answer: Wind farm: bird and bat collisions, changed rural views, and output that varies with the wind so backup or storage is needed. Tailings: keeping lead dust out of air, soil and streams at a Superfund site, water and chemical use, and whether the plant pays when cobalt prices swing. - A mitigation project costing $4 million produces benefits of $10 million. Another costing $1 million produces $3 million. Which has the higher benefit-cost ratio, and which delivers more total benefit?
Check your answer
Answer: Ratios 2.5 and 3.0: the second has the higher ratio; the first delivers more total benefit ($10 million). Which is better depends on the budget and goals.
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- At what carbon price per ton would coal ($50/MWh, 1.0 t CO2/MWh) cost the same as wind with storage ($70/MWh)?
Check your answer
Answer: $20 per ton50 + 1.0p = 70.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Review (Unit 3): the atmosphere gains 2.58 ppm in a year. How many GtC is that?
Check your answer
Answer: about 5.5 GtC
Cobalt, Coal and Wind: The Missouri Numbers Behind the Argument
U.S. EIA, Missouri Electricity Profile 2024 and full data tables (Tables 1, 2A, 5, 15, 19); U.S. EIA FAQ on CO2 per kWh (2023 data); Missouri DNR Division of Geology and Land Survey, The Geologic Column of Missouri, Winter 2006; retrieved November 6, 2026 · Public domain (works of the U.S. government) and a Missouri state publication summarized, with SLS original arithmetic
Why this reading. The lesson’s cost-benefit worked example is illustrative by design, so the argument needs real figures to weigh beside it. This reading hosts Missouri’s 2024 electricity mix and capacity factors from the U.S. Energy Information Administration, EIA’s emission rates for coal and gas, and the Missouri Geological Survey’s limestone figures. Cobalt and the Fredericktown tailings are documented in the companion reading Battery Metals Source File (rlp-psa-battery-metals-source-file); lead in Missouri’s Resources and Hazards. Retrieved November 6, 2026.
1. Where Missouri’s electricity came from, 2024 (EIA Table 5)
| Source | Net generation (MWh) | Share | Share in 2010 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Coal | 38,831,623 | 58.1% | 81.3% |
| Nuclear (Callaway) | 10,525,784 | 15.7% | 9.7% |
| Natural gas | 9,099,566 | 13.6% | 5.1% |
| Wind | 6,789,964 | 10.2% | 1.0% |
| Hydroelectric | — | 1.5% | 1.7% |
| Utility-scale solar | 207,676 | 0.3% | — |
| All sources | 66,875,710 | 100% |
Rooftop and other small-scale solar produced another 742,146 MWh in 2024 (EIA Table 19), not counted in the total above; that is 742,146 ÷ 66,875,710 ≈ 1.1% as much again. Missouri’s largest plant is the Labadie coal plant, 2,372 MW; three of its four largest plants burn coal (EIA Table 2A). In 2024 Missouri’s power plants averaged 1,456 pounds of CO2 per MWh, fourth-highest among the states (EIA Table 1).
2. Capacity factors, Missouri 2024 (EIA Table 15)
| Technology | Capacity in the calculation (MW) | Capacity factor |
|---|---|---|
| Nuclear | 1,190 | 100.7%* |
| Coal | 9,421 | 47.3% |
| Natural gas, combined cycle | 1,889 | 38.8% |
| Wind (onshore) | 2,393 | 32.3% |
| Solar PV | 111 | 18.5% |
*A capacity factor slightly above 100% can occur because it is computed against the plant’s rated summer capacity, which a plant can exceed in cool weather. Sizing check used in the lesson: 100,000 MWh ÷ (8,760 h × 0.323) = 35.3 MW of wind; at solar’s 18.5% it would take 61.7 MW of panels, and at coal’s 47.3%, 24.1 MW. Coal’s low number is a choice, not a limit: Missouri’s coal plants ran well below full power in 2024 because cheaper wind and gas were often available.
3. CO2 per unit of electricity (EIA, U.S. utility-scale plants, 2023)
| Fuel | Generation (million kWh) | CO2 (million metric tons) | Pounds per kWh | Metric tons per MWh |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coal | 675,115 | 709 | 2.31 | 709 ÷ 675,115 × 1,000 = 1.05 |
| Natural gas | 1,806,063 | 790 | 0.96 | 790 ÷ 1,806,063 × 1,000 = 0.44 |
The lesson rounds these to 1.0 and 0.4 t/MWh to keep the arithmetic simple; with the unrounded values the illustrative external costs at $100 per ton become $10.5 million for coal and $4.4 million for gas for 100,000 MWh. The ranking does not change.
4. Limestone, Missouri’s quiet giant (Missouri Geological Survey, 2006)
- Missouri ranked first in the nation in lime production, fourth in crushed limestone and fifth in portland cement.
- Limestone was mined in 92 of Missouri’s 114 counties.
- In 2004 the limestone-based commodities were worth $994 million: cement $412 million (41.4%), crushed limestone $407 million (41.0%) and lime $175 million (17.6%).
Lime and limestone are also used in pollution control, including scrubbers that remove sulfur dioxide from coal-plant exhaust, so one Missouri resource reduces part of the harm of another. These rankings are from 2006; check a current USGS Minerals Yearbook before citing them as present-day.
5. Using these numbers honestly
None of the shares or capacity factors above are dollar costs, so they do not replace the lesson’s illustrative $/MWh table. They support the unpriced side of the ledger: how dependent Missouri still is on coal, how much backup variable sources need, and how large the state’s mineral industries are. Cite the source and the year for every figure you borrow.
Sources: U.S. EIA, Missouri Electricity Profile 2024 (eia.gov); U.S. EIA, Missouri Electricity Profile 2024, full data tables 1-19 (Tables 1, 2A, 5, 15, 19) (eia.gov); U.S. EIA FAQ, How much carbon dioxide is produced per kilowatthour of U.S. electricity generation? (eia.gov); Missouri Department of Natural Resources, Division of Geology and Land Survey, The Geologic Column of Missouri, Winter 2006 (Missouri limestone) (dnr.mo.gov)
Battery Metals Source File: Lithium, Missouri Cobalt and NIST Data
USGS Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026 (Lithium; Cobalt); USGS Mineral Industry Surveys, Cobalt in February 2022; Missouri Geological Survey, Cobalt fact sheet (PUB2893); EPA news release on the Madison County Mines Superfund Site (April 1, 2019); NIST atomic data; public domain U.S. government works and a Missouri state publication; all retrieved Nov. 5, 2026 · Public domain (U.S. government works) and a Missouri state publication summarized, with SLS commentary
Why this reading. The brief must cite at least three sources, compare two of them, and state no figure it cannot source. This file hosts the figures: the U.S. Geological Survey’s 2026 summaries for lithium and cobalt, the Missouri Geological Survey’s cobalt fact sheet, a USGS industry report on the Fredericktown tailings project, an EPA report on the lead cleanup there, and NIST’s atomic data. Every number below carries its source. The engineering section at the end lists what the sources say about constraints and what they do not.
Source 1: USGS, Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026, Lithium
Published February 2026. Quantities are metric tons of lithium content unless stated.
| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| U.S. commercial production, 2025 | One continental brine operation in Nevada; production withheld (company proprietary) |
| U.S. net import reliance, 2025 | More than 50% of apparent consumption |
| World production, 2024 → 2025 (excluding U.S.) | 222,000 t → about 290,000 t (+31%) |
| Global end uses | Batteries 88%; ceramics and glass 4%; lubricating greases 2%; air treatment 1%; casting mold flux 1%; medical 1%; other 3% |
| Battery-grade lithium carbonate price, annual average (dollars per metric ton) | 2021: 11,700; 2022: 63,700; 2023: 39,000; 2024: 11,800; 2025: 9,000 |
| U.S. import sources, 2021–24 | Chile 54%; Argentina 43%; other 3% |
| Reserves | World about 37 million t; United States 4.4 million t |
| Measured and indicated U.S. resources | 30 million t, “from continental brines, claystone, geothermal brines, hectorite, oilfield brines, and pegmatites” |
Missouri appears nowhere in the lithium summary: the state has no lithium production. Its battery-metal story is cobalt.
Source 2: USGS, Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026, Cobalt
Published February 2026. Metric tons of cobalt content; 2025 values are USGS estimates.
| Item | 2024 | 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| U.S. mine production | 200 t | 300 t |
| U.S. secondary (scrap) production | 2,050 t | 2,000 t |
| U.S. imports for consumption | 10,800 t | 14,000 t |
| U.S. apparent consumption | 7,960 t | 9,600 t |
| Net import reliance (% of apparent consumption) | 74% | 79% |
| U.S. spot price, cobalt cathode (dollars per pound) | 16.77 | 21 |
Other USGS statements in the same summary: the U.S. spot price averaged $30.78 per pound in 2022; lithium-ion batteries are “the leading global use for cobalt,” and their cobalt content was being decreased, with cobalt-free iron-phosphate cells holding significant market share in China; Congo (Kinshasa) supplied an estimated 73% of world mined cobalt in 2025; U.S. reserves are 70,000 t; and identified U.S. cobalt resources are about 1 million tons, mostly in Minnesota, with Missouri among the states that have other notable occurrences.
Read two rows together. U.S. mine production in 2025 (300 t) was 300 ÷ 9,600 = 3.1% of apparent consumption. And the price fell from $30.78 to $16.77 per pound between 2022 and 2024, a factor of 30.78 ÷ 16.77 = 1.84. A recovery process that pays at the first price may not pay at the second; cost is a constraint that moves.
Source 3: Missouri Geological Survey, Cobalt fact sheet
| Item | As the Survey states it |
|---|---|
| Missouri’s standing | One of only a few areas in the continental United States known to have produced cobalt and to contain potentially significant cobalt reserves |
| Where | Southeast Missouri Lead District: the Viburnum Trend (1955 to present) and Mine LaMotte-Fredericktown (1720–1961); Mine LaMotte-Fredericktown is the only district with known cobalt production, along with nickel |
| Grade | Cobalt and nickel amounts at Mine LaMotte-Fredericktown are generally 10 times higher than in the Viburnum Trend; ore lies about 250 to 400 feet below the surface |
| Minerals | Mainly siegenite (CoNi2S4), bravoite ((Fe,Ni,Co)S2) and millerite (NiS) at Fredericktown; also cobaltite (CoAsS) |
| Production history | Attempts in 1903–1910, 1917–1920 and 1944–1961 were generally not economic; 1,443 tons of cobalt were delivered under a federal contract from 1954 to 1961 |
| Uses named | Superalloys, magnets, corrosion-resistant alloys, high-speed steels, cemented carbides and battery electrodes |
Two checks. Siegenite, CoNi2S4, has a molar mass of 58.933 + 2(58.693) + 4(32.06) = 304.56 g/mol, of which cobalt is 58.933 ÷ 304.56 = 19.4%. Even a pure crystal of the main ore mineral is less than a fifth cobalt, and the ore is mostly other rock. And 1,443 tons over the eight years 1954–1961 averages about 180 tons a year. The fact sheet does not say which ton it uses, and USGS reports metric tons, so compare the two only roughly: Missouri’s 1950s output was of the same order as U.S. mine production in 2025.
Source 4: USGS, Mineral Industry Surveys, Cobalt in February 2022
USGS reported that since 2019 Missouri Cobalt, LLC had processed tailings left by earlier mining of lead and other metals at the Madison Mine near Fredericktown, producing a bulk concentrate containing cobalt, copper and nickel; that the company was building a hydrometallurgical plant to produce battery-grade cobalt and nickel; and that its parent company had been renamed United States Strategic Metals. The plant’s status after 2022 is not hosted here, so do not claim it is operating unless you have read a current source that says so.
Source 5: EPA, Madison County Mines Superfund Site (April 1, 2019)
| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| Residential cleanup in and around Fredericktown | Over 626,000 cubic yards of soil at more than 1,900 residential properties |
| Mine waste cleaned up | About 87 acres |
| Children tested in Madison County with elevated blood lead | About 27% in 1996; less than 2% in 2019 |
| Plan for the Anschutz Mine property | New owners intended to reopen a former cobalt mine after a property-wide cleanup of historical mine waste |
The lead in these tailings is the same chemistry you have been studying: lead from the ore ended up in the waste rock, and from there in yard soil. Any process that digs up and reprocesses the tailings has to keep that lead out of the air, the soil and the streams.
Source 6: NIST atomic data for lithium, its neighbors, and cobalt
| Quantity | Lithium | Sodium | Potassium | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Atomic number, shells | 3; 2, 1 | 11; 2, 8, 1 | 19; 2, 8, 8, 1 | shell model |
| First ionization energy | 5.39 eV | 5.14 eV | 4.34 eV | NIST Atomic Spectra Database |
| Standard atomic weight | [6.938, 6.997] | 22.98977 | 39.0983 | NIST Compositions |
| Isotopes (mass u, fraction) | Li-6: 6.01512, 0.0759; Li-7: 7.01600, 0.9241 | Na-23 only | K-39 0.9326; K-40 0.0001; K-41 0.0673 | NIST Compositions |
| Metal | First ionization energy (NIST) | How it is found in nature |
|---|---|---|
| Iron | 7.90 eV | combined, as oxides (hematite, magnetite) |
| Cobalt | 7.88 eV | combined, as sulfides (siegenite) and arsenide-sulfides (cobaltite) |
| Nickel | 7.64 eV | combined, as sulfides (millerite, siegenite) |
| Gold | 9.23 eV | commonly native metal (USGS) |
The average atomic mass, worked: 0.0759 × 6.01512 + 0.9241 × 7.01600 = 0.4565 + 6.4835 = 6.940 u. NIST’s interval [6.938, 6.997] brackets it; 6.94 is the value to report.
The cathode formula, checked with charges: in LiCoO2, lithium is Li+ (+1) and the two oxide ions give 2 × (−2) = −4, so cobalt must carry +3 for the total to be zero: Co3+. By mass (Li 6.94, Co 58.933, O 15.999), LiCoO2 is 97.87 g/mol, of which cobalt is 58.933 ÷ 97.87 = 60.2% and lithium only 6.94 ÷ 97.87 = 7.1%. A cathode named for lithium is mostly cobalt by mass, which is why cobalt supply matters to lithium batteries.
Comparing two sources (RST.9-10.9)
NIST publishes two lithium pages that do not agree exactly. The older Handbook page lists an atomic weight of 6.941 and abundances of 7.5% Li-6 and 92.5% Li-7. The current Compositions table lists 7.59% and 92.41% and gives an interval instead of one number. The difference is not an error: lithium’s isotope ratio varies measurably between natural sources (some industrial lithium has had Li-6 removed), so the newer table reports a range. Your brief can say: the two NIST tables agree to three figures (6.94), and the newer one explains why a fourth figure cannot be promised. A second comparison: the Missouri Geological Survey’s 2020 fact sheet says the United States imports more than 70% of the cobalt it uses, and USGS’s 2026 summary gives 74% for 2024 and 79% for 2025. The sources describe different years and agree that most U.S. cobalt is imported.
Why lithium is Li+ and cobalt is in sulfides
Use the ionization energies and the shell model. Lithium’s one outer electron is easily lost (5.39 eV, far below gold’s 9.23 eV), and lithium metal reacts with water, so lithium in nature is always the ion, bonded in minerals or dissolved in brines. Cobalt holds its outer electrons more tightly than lithium but about as tightly as iron (7.88 eV against 7.90 eV), well below gold. Like Missouri’s iron, Missouri’s cobalt is found combined, here with sulfur, and has to be separated chemically from minerals that also hold nickel, iron, copper and lead.
Criteria and constraints: what the sources support
- Criterion, quantifiable: the share of the cobalt in the tailings that the process recovers, measured as cobalt out divided by cobalt in. No tailings grade is hosted here, so state how it would be measured, not what it is.
- Criterion, quantifiable: battery-grade purity of the cobalt product, which USGS names as the plant’s goal; measured as percent cobalt in the product.
- Constraint: cost, in light of the cobalt price row above (a factor of 1.84 between 2022 and 2024) and the shift toward cobalt-free cells.
- Constraint: lead. The tailings sit in a Superfund site where EPA cleaned soil at more than 1,900 homes; reprocessing must not raise lead in nearby air, soil or streams, which can be measured by soil and water sampling and by children’s blood-lead testing.
- Constraint: water and energy use, and consultation with Fredericktown and Madison County residents. No figures are hosted here, so state that limits are needed and how they would be measured (cubic meters of water or kilowatt-hours per ton of cobalt), not what they are.
Label any number you estimate as illustrative, and keep the sourced numbers above attached to their sources.
Sources: USGS, Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026: Lithium (February 2026) (pubs.usgs.gov); USGS, Mineral Commodity Summaries 2026: Cobalt (February 2026) (pubs.usgs.gov); Missouri Geological Survey, Cobalt (fact sheet PUB2893, 2020) (dnr.mo.gov); USGS, Mineral Industry Surveys: Cobalt in February 2022 (May 2022) (apps.usgs.gov); U.S. EPA news release, EPA Administrator Wheeler Recognizes Progress at Madison County Mines Superfund Site (April 1, 2019) (epa.gov); NIST Atomic Spectra Database (ver. 5.12), Ionization Energies Data: Li, Na, Mg, K, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Zn, Rb, Cs, Au, Pb (physics.nist.gov); NIST, Atomic Weights and Isotopic Compositions with Relative Atomic Masses (Physical Measurement Laboratory) (physics.nist.gov); NIST, Handbook of Basic Atomic Spectroscopic Data (ground states and first ionization energies) (physics.nist.gov)