
evaluate the evidence that human activities are the main cause of recent warming, and analyze sea-level data from Gulf Coast tide gauges and globally to argue about the rate of rise.
Instruction
A question of evidence. Scientists concluded that human activity is the main cause of recent warming not from one graph but from many independent lines of evidence that point the same way. The IPCC’s 2021 assessment stated that it is unequivocal that human influence has warmed the atmosphere, ocean and land. Here is some of the evidence behind that conclusion.
1. The carbon is from fossil fuels. Fossil fuels formed from plants and plankton millions of years ago, so they contain no carbon-14 (its half-life is 5,730 years; Earth Science A, Unit 2) and, like all plant carbon, they are slightly low in carbon-13. As carbon dioxide has risen, the proportion of carbon-13 in the air has fallen, and carbon-14 was diluted even before nuclear-bomb testing added more. Oxygen in the air is also declining slightly, as expected when carbon fuels burn. Volcanoes cannot explain the rise: they emit well under 1 GtC per year, and their carbon has a different isotopic signature.
2. Physics and fingerprints. Carbon dioxide absorbs infrared energy (Unit 2). Satellites measure less infrared escaping at exactly the wavelengths carbon dioxide absorbs, the lower atmosphere is warming while the stratosphere cools, and Earth is now gaining energy, most of it stored in the ocean. Natural drivers, the Sun and volcanoes, would have produced slight cooling since the mid-1900s.
3. Sea level rises for two reasons. Seawater expands as it warms (thermal expansion), and water from melting glaciers and ice sheets on land flows into the ocean. Melting sea ice, which already floats, adds almost nothing, because floating ice displaces its own weight of water. You will test this in the lab. The IPCC reports that global mean sea level rose about 0.20 m between 1901 and 2018; the average rate was about 1.3 mm per year from 1901 to 1971 and about 3.7 mm per year from 2006 to 2018. The rise is accelerating.
Worked example: the Gulf Coast. Missouri has no coast, but the Missouri and Mississippi Rivers carry its water to the Gulf of Mexico. NOAA’s tide gauge at Pensacola, Florida, has operated since 1923, one of the longest records on the Gulf Coast. NOAA publishes its monthly mean sea level with the seasonal cycle removed. A least-squares fit to the whole record, 1923-2025, gives about 2.7 mm per year (2.73), the trend NOAA reports. Fitting only 1923-1992 gives about 2.2 mm per year, and fitting 1993-2025 gives about 6.5 mm per year. At 2.73 mm per year, the sea at Pensacola rose about 0.00273 × 102 ≈ 0.28 m, about 28 cm, between 1923 and 2025. Why is Pensacola’s recent rate faster than the recent global rate? Over 20 or 30 years, local sea level also moves with winds, currents and ocean heat, so a short window carries natural swings as well as the long-term rise. Place matters too: a tide gauge measures relative sea level, the sea compared with the land. At Grand Isle, Louisiana, on the sinking Mississippi River delta, relative sea level has risen about 9.1 mm per year since 1947, because the land is going down as well as the sea coming up. Choosing the period and the place matters, and a strong argument says which it used and why.
Arguing well. A strong argument about causes weighs alternative explanations with evidence, not by who makes them. When you rebut a claim such as “The climate has always changed, so this is natural,” agree with what is true (it has changed before, for reasons you studied in Unit 2) and then show with evidence why those causes do not fit the present change.
📖 Read for this lesson
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were. The checks below draw on it.
Lab: Land Ice, Sea Ice and Sea Level
Question. Does melting ice raise the water level when the ice floats in the water, when it rests on land, or both?
Materials
- Two identical clear plastic cups or small containers
- Modeling clay or a flat rock to make a ‘continent’ that rises above the water in one cup
- Ice cubes of equal size (four)
- Water at room temperature
- A fine permanent marker and a ruler with mm marks
- Work on a towel or tray and wipe up spills at once so no one slips; wear safety glasses if younger children are nearby.
- Do not drink the water, and clean the clay off the cups when you finish.
Procedure
- In cup A, press clay against one side to make a ‘continent’ whose top stays above the water. Leave cup B empty of clay.
- Add water to both cups to the same level, well below the rim. Mark the level on each cup.
- Place two ice cubes on the clay continent in cup A (land ice). Place two ice cubes floating in the water of cup B (sea ice). Mark the new water level in cup B immediately.
- Wait until all the ice has melted (about 30-40 minutes). Mark the final water level in both cups.
- Measure the rise in water level, in mm, in each cup from the first mark.
Data
| Cup | Ice position | Level before ice (mm) | Level with ice (mm) | Level after melting (mm) | Rise from start (mm) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | On land (clay) | ||||
| B | Floating (sea ice) |
Analysis
- Claim: which kind of melting ice raises sea level? Use your level measurements as evidence and explain why floating ice does not add water as it melts.
- Name one real example of land ice (the Greenland ice sheet, Alaska’s mountain glaciers) and one of sea ice (Arctic Ocean sea ice), and state which affects sea level.
- Your model leaves out thermal expansion. Explain what it is and describe a change to the lab that could show it.
- Sources of error: how might evaporation, water on the outside of the cup and uneven ice sizes affect your measured rises?
If you cannot do this lab in person: Carry out the same test with two drinking glasses and a stone as the continent, or analyze the sample measurements in the reading rlp-esb-sea-level-fingerprints-record (Table 4) and answer every analysis question from them.
Formative check
Work through these before moving on. They are not graded — they tell you whether the standard below has landed yet.
Simulation & tools
Sea-level trend on the Gulf Coast
Open NOAA’s relative sea-level trend page for Pensacola, FL (8729840). Record the trend NOAA reports, its 95% confidence interval, and the years it covers. Convert the trend to millimeters per year if needed (1 inch per decade = 2.54 mm per year) and then to centimeters per century. Then open the page for Grand Isle, LA (8761724) and record its trend. Grand Isle’s sea level has risen more than three times as fast as Pensacola’s: suggest one reason, using what you know about river deltas and the meaning of relative sea level.
No device? Use the Pensacola and Grand Isle rates in this lesson and Tables 1-2 of the reading rlp-esb-sea-level-fingerprints-record.
Open NOAA ↗ · NOAA · Public domain (U.S. federal)
At 2.73 mm per year, how much would sea level at Pensacola rise between 2025 and 2050?
The melting of floating Arctic sea ice is a major direct cause of global sea-level rise.
Which observation shows that the added carbon dioxide comes mainly from fossil fuels?
Write a CER argument rebutting one claim: (a) ‘The climate has always changed, so current warming is natural’; (b) ‘The extra CO₂ comes from volcanoes’; or (c) ‘Melting Arctic sea ice will flood the Gulf Coast.’ Use at least two pieces of evidence from this lesson, including one calculation or your lab data. Then write the strongest question a skeptical reader could ask about your argument and answer it, in writing or on a recording.
How confident are you that you can evaluate the evidence for human-caused warming and analyze sea-level rates at Gulf Coast tide gauges?
Practice
Work these on paper or in your notebook, then open Check your answer. Aim for all of Fluency and Application; try at least one Challenge.
Printable version: this unit’s practice workbook (PDF)
Fluency
Build speed and accuracy with the core skill.
- Use technology to find the least-squares line and the correlation coefficient for (4, -1), (5, -2), (8, -7), (9, -7), (11, -13), (13, -10).
Check your answer
Answer: ŷ = 3.539 − 1.225x; r = −0.919Interpret the slope in context: the predicted change in y for each one-unit increase in x. - Sea level at Pensacola rose about 2.73 mm per year from 1923 to 2025. How much is that per century, in cm?
Check your answer
Answer: about 27 cm per century - At 6.54 mm per year (the 1993-2025 Pensacola rate), how much would the sea rise from 2025 to 2050?
Check your answer
Answer: about 16 cm - At the IPCC’s 2006-2018 global rate of 3.7 mm per year, how much would the sea rise in 25 years?
Check your answer
Answer: about 9.2 cm
Application
Use the skill in context. Show your reasoning.
- In the ice lab, cup A (ice on clay ‘land’) rose 4 mm after melting and cup B (floating ice) rose 0 mm. Explain both results and name a real example of each kind of ice.
Check your answer
Answer: Land ice adds new water to the ocean when it melts (Greenland ice sheet); floating ice already displaces its own weight of water, so melting it barely changes the level (Arctic sea ice). - Give two independent lines of evidence that the added CO2 comes mainly from fossil fuels.
Check your answer
Answer: The carbon-13 fraction of atmospheric CO2 has fallen (fossil carbon is low in carbon-13); fossil carbon has no carbon-14; atmospheric oxygen is declining as fuels burn; emissions inventories account for the increase. - Global sea level rose about 0.20 m from 1901 to 2018. What average rate is that, and how does it compare with the 2006-2018 rate of 3.7 mm/yr?
Check your answer
Answer: about 1.7 mm/yr; the recent rate is about 2.2 times the long-term average
Challenge
Stretch problems. Expect to think before you write.
- The top 700 m of the ocean warms by 0.5 °C. Seawater expands by about 0.0002 of its volume per °C (an approximate value). How much would sea level rise from thermal expansion alone?
Check your answer
Answer: about 7 cm700 m × 0.0002 × 0.5.
Review
Keep earlier skills sharp.
- Review (Unit 2): 3,000 J warms 0.250 kg of water by how much?
Check your answer
Answer: 2.87 °C
Fingerprints of a Human Cause, and Two Gulf Coast Tide Gauges
NOAA CO-OPS sea level trends and monthly means, Pensacola FL 8729840 and Grand Isle LA 8761724; NASA Earth Indicators: Ice Sheets; USGS SIM 3164; IPCC AR6 WGI SPM, cited for its findings; all retrieved November 6, 2026 · Public domain (works of the United States government), with SLS original arithmetic; IPCC findings cited
Why this reading. Missouri has no coastline, but its rivers end in the Gulf of Mexico, and sea level is one of the three quantities in your Lesson 3.5 forecast. This reading hosts two long Gulf Coast tide-gauge records for anyone who cannot reach NOAA’s live tool, the isotope evidence for the CER argument, and a satellite check on your land-ice lab. The point it makes concrete: the period you choose, and the place, change the answer.
Table 1. Pensacola, Florida (station 8729840): relative sea level by fitting period
| Fitting period | Trend (mm/yr) | Rise implied over the period |
|---|---|---|
| Whole record, 1923–2025 | 2.73 | ≈28 cm over 102 years |
| 1923–1992 | 2.17 | ≈15 cm over 70 years |
| 1993–2025 (satellite era) | 6.54 | ≈22 cm over 33 years |
| 2006–2025 | 9.58 | a 20-year window; least certain |
| NOAA’s published trend, May 1923–Dec 2025 | 1.07 ± 0.05 in/decade = 2.72 ± 0.13 mm/yr | NOAA CO-OPS trend table |
Rows 1–4 are SLS least-squares fits to NOAA’s monthly mean sea level with the seasonal cycle removed; row 1 agrees with NOAA’s own published trend in row 5. Pensacola has one of the longest records on the Gulf Coast, and the land there is fairly stable. Its long-term rate is somewhat faster than the IPCC’s global average for 1901–2018 (0.20 m in 117 years, about 1.7 mm/yr), and since 1993 it has risen more than twice as fast as its long-term average, and faster than the recent global rate. A rate fitted over 20 or 30 years includes natural swings in winds, currents and ocean heat as well as the long-term rise, so the shorter the window, the wider its uncertainty. A strong argument reports which period it used, and why.
Table 2. Grand Isle, Louisiana (station 8761724), for the sim task
| Station | Trend | Record |
|---|---|---|
| Grand Isle, LA | 9.15 mm/yr (SLS fit); NOAA: 3.59 ± 0.07 in/decade = 9.12 ± 0.18 mm/yr | 1947–2025 |
| Pensacola, FL, same period | 2.91 mm/yr (SLS fit, 1947–2025) | for a fair comparison |
Grand Isle is about 300 km west of Pensacola on the same Gulf, yet its relative sea level rose about 6.2 mm/yr faster over the same years. The ocean surface cannot be 6 mm a year higher in one place for decades; the difference is the land. A tide gauge measures relative sea level, the sea compared with the land the gauge stands on. Grand Isle sits on the Mississippi River delta, built of river mud that compacts and sinks over time. The U.S. Geological Survey measured a net loss of about 1,883 square miles of coastal Louisiana land from 1932 to 2010, about 25% of the 1932 land area. The Missouri River, which joins the Mississippi just north of St. Louis, is part of the river system that carried that mud to the Gulf.
The isotopic fingerprint, worked
Fossil fuels formed from organic matter tens to hundreds of millions of years old. They contain essentially no carbon-14, whose 5,730-year half-life means any carbon that old has none left; burning them adds carbon-14-free carbon to the air and dilutes the atmosphere’s carbon-14 (the Suess effect). Photosynthesis also discriminates against the heavier carbon-13, so plant-derived carbon, including the ancient plants that became coal, oil and gas, carries less carbon-13. As fossil carbon has entered the air, the atmosphere’s carbon-13 fraction has fallen alongside the rising CO2. Volcanoes emit well under 1 GtC per year, about a tenth of human emissions or less, with a different isotopic signature, so they cannot explain either the size of the rise or the isotopic trend.
Land ice versus sea ice, with a satellite check on your lab
Floating ice displaces its own weight of water and adds almost nothing when it melts; ice resting on land adds new water to the ocean. NASA’s GRACE and GRACE Follow-On satellites, which weigh the ice sheets by measuring Earth’s gravity, show that from 2002 to 2025 Greenland lost about 264 gigatons of ice per year, raising global sea level about 0.8 mm per year, and Antarctica about 135 gigatons per year, about 0.4 mm per year. Together that is 1.2 mm per year, about a third of the IPCC’s 2006–2018 rate of 3.7 mm per year; thermal expansion and mountain glaciers, such as Alaska’s, supply much of the rest.
Table 3. Global mean sea level, IPCC AR6 (cited for its findings)
| Period | Average rate |
|---|---|
| 1901–1971 | 1.3 mm/yr |
| 1971–2006 | 1.9 mm/yr |
| 2006–2018 | 3.7 mm/yr |
| Total, 1901–2018 | 0.20 m |
The IPCC finds that human influence was very likely the main driver of these increases since at least 1971. The rate itself has increased, not just the total, at Pensacola and globally; that acceleration, more than any single year’s height, is the strongest sea-level evidence of a changing climate.
Table 4. Sample results from the land-ice and sea-ice lab (SLS illustrative values)
| Cup | Ice position | Level before ice (mm) | With ice (mm) | After melting (mm) | Rise from start (mm) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | On land (clay) | 50 | 50 | 54 | 4 |
| B | Floating | 50 | 53 | 53 | 3 (all of it when the ice was added; 0 from melting) |
Illustrative values chosen to match what the lab typically shows, for students who cannot run it. In cup B the water rose as soon as the floating ice was added and did not change as it melted; in cup A the water rose only as the land ice melted and ran in.
Sources: NOAA CO-OPS sea level trends, Pensacola, FL (8729840): trend and monthly means with seasonal cycle removed (api.tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov); NOAA CO-OPS sea level trends, Grand Isle, LA (8761724): trend and monthly means with seasonal cycle removed (api.tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov); NOAA CO-OPS sea level trends, all U.S. stations (published trends and record spans) (api.tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov); USGS Scientific Investigations Map 3164, Land Area Change in Coastal Louisiana from 1932 to 2010 (Couvillion and others, 2011) (pubs.usgs.gov); NASA Earth Indicators: Ice Sheets (GRACE and GRACE-FO, 2002-2025) (science.nasa.gov); IPCC AR6 Working Group I, Summary for Policymakers (A.1, A.1.7, B.1.1, Table SPM.1) (ipcc.ch)