
explain the cold chain with collision theory and my lab data, refine the conditions of an ammonia plant to increase the amount of product at equilibrium while weighing the trade-offs, and answer the board’s irradiation question with a model of the nucleus.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. List the three strongest pieces of evidence you have collected this unit (an antacid ratio, a cooler temperature, a coin-model graph, an equilibrium observation). Next to each, write the claim it supports.
Which set of changes increases the amount of ammonia at equilibrium?
The context. Agriculture depends on two pieces of chemistry that most people never see. Before a crop is grown, nitrogen fertilizer made from ammonia feeds it. After it is picked, the cold chain slows the reactions that spoil it. The food bank sits at the end of that chain, and its board also hears donors ask about irradiated produce. Your brief explains all three, as a technical adviser to the food bank would.
Part A: The cold chain (HS-PS1-5). Explain, with collision theory, why cooling produce quickly slows ripening and decay. Use your antacid-lab data and your cooler data as evidence: report average times and relative rates at different temperatures, include a graph, and compare your warm-to-cold ratio with the “doubles every 10 °C” rule of thumb. Then use surface area to explain why damaged or cut produce spoils faster. Compare your lab findings with one published source on post-harvest cooling from a university extension service or a U.S. Department of Agriculture page: note where they agree and where they differ, and why a lab with tablets might differ from fruit.
Part B: Refining the ammonia system (HS-PS1-6). Start from N2 + 3H2 ⇌ 2NH3, energy change −92 kJ. Specify at least three changes in conditions that would increase the amount of ammonia produced: a pressure choice, a temperature choice, and product removal. For each, state the direction of the shift, the molecular-level reason (forward and reverse rates) and the evidence from the equation (gas-molecule count or energy change). Explain the role of the catalyst correctly: it speeds the approach to equilibrium but does not change the equilibrium amounts.
Part C: Trade-offs (HS-ETS1-3). Rank at least three criteria, such as amount of ammonia per hour, energy cost, equipment safety and cost, and emissions. Show in a criteria table how a very low temperature, a moderate temperature with a catalyst, and a very high pressure each score, and recommend conditions with the trade-off stated plainly. Producing the hydrogen for the process often uses natural gas, which releases carbon dioxide; a strong brief names this as a constraint. Add your cooler’s version 2 as a second, smaller example of refining by trade-off.
Part D: The donor question (HS-PS1-8). Explain irradiation with a model of the nucleus: write and check the nuclear equation for the beta-minus decay of cobalt-60 to nickel-60, say what the beta particle and the gamma rays are, and explain why the food does not become radioactive. Compare the energy of one nuclear change with one chemical change, and explain in two sentences how fission and fusion differ from the decay used in irradiation (including why alpha decay counts as a kind of fission and beta and gamma do not).
Worked example: a strong equilibrium sentence. “Removing ammonia by condensing it lowers its concentration, so the reverse reaction slows while the forward reaction continues, and more ammonia forms until the rates match again; the cost is the energy to refrigerate the outgoing gas.” Direction, mechanism, evidence and trade-off in one sentence.
Quality bar. Every rate claim names the particle-level cause. Every equilibrium claim names the direction of the shift and the reason. Every nuclear equation balances. No claim of real plant conditions or costs appears without a source; illustrative values are labeled.
Stages. Plan, draft, peer review, revise, and defend in four minutes (live or recorded), answering one question about your recommended conditions or your irradiation answer.
Plan and peer-review checks.
Write and revise the brief across the work sessions.
Write Part A with your graph and the source comparison (about 350 words).
Write Parts B, C and D: the three condition changes, the criteria table and recommendation, and the irradiation explanation with its nuclear equation, with sources cited.
Task: For the food bank’s board, Part A explains the cold chain with collision theory, your antacid and cooler data and a graph, compared with one published post-harvest source. Part B specifies at least three changes in conditions that increase ammonia at equilibrium, with the evidence for each and the correct role of the catalyst. Part C ranks criteria and recommends conditions with the trade-offs stated. Part D answers the irradiation question with a balanced nuclear equation and a comparison of nuclear processes. Cite at least three sources.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Rates explanation (HS-PS1-5) | Explains temperature and surface-area effects with collision theory and uses lab data and a graph accurately. |
| Refining equilibrium (HS-PS1-6) | Specifies at least three changes, each with the correct shift, mechanism and evidence; describes the catalyst correctly. |
| Trade-offs (HS-ETS1-3) | Ranks criteria with reasons and makes a recommendation that states its trade-offs. |
| Nuclear model (HS-PS1-8) | Balanced equation for cobalt-60 decay; correct account of beta and gamma radiation, why food is not made radioactive, and how fission, fusion and decay differ. |
| Sources and communication | Compares lab findings with a published source; clear explanation and a defense that answers a question with evidence. |
Your brief turns a unit of evidence into advice. Next: the unit checkpoint.
Exit ticket: what question did the board ask your team, and how did you answer it with evidence?
Timing: the brief runs across about three sessions: this lesson launches it and covers planning and peer review; drafting and the presentations need further work time.
Materials: peer-review checklist, the teams’ antacid and cooler data, links to a university extension post-harvest guide and a USDA page, rubric copies for visiting “board members.”
Listen for: “the catalyst increases yield”; “irradiated food is radioactive”; real plant figures with no source.
Support / stretch: give a paragraph frame for each part. Stretch: explain why fertilizer plants run the ammonia loop many times, using the idea of recycling unreacted gas.