
use peer critique and my data’s accuracy and precision to refine the investigation and the soil mix, then test version 2 against every criterion.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Weigh your version 1 cups. Compute the 24-hour water loss for each and mark whether it meets the 30 g limit.
A cup weighed 262.4 g yesterday and 239.8 g today. How much water was lost?
Gallery critique protocol. Each team posts its plan, matrix and version 1 data. Visitors leave three notes: I like… (a strength tied to a criterion), I wonder… (a question about the data’s accuracy or precision, or the particle explanation), and What if… (one specific change). Each note must cite a number or a particle idea.
Class criteria and constraints (sample values set by the class). Each test pours 100 mL of water onto 100 g of soil mix in a cup with drain holes and collects what drains in 10 minutes. A mix must (1) hold at least 50 mL of tap water; (2) hold at least 45 mL of salty water (5 g of table salt per liter, a stand-in for the co-op’s slightly salty irrigation water); (3) lose no more than 30 g of water in the next 24 hours; (4) cost no more than 10 sample budget points per cup; and (5) be at least half biodegradable additive by mass, a concern the co-op raised.
Worked example 1: judging the data. Malik’s team (concept D) had tap trials of 62, 49 and 71 mL: a range of 22 mL. The note read: “I wonder why trial 2 is so low.” Their notes showed trial 2 was poured in 10 seconds, not 30, so water rushed through before the mix could take it up. That is a method problem, not a property of the mix. Refinement: pour through a funnel with a fixed opening so every pour takes about 30 seconds, and add a fourth trial. Retest (sample data): 64, 66, 63, 65 mL, a range of 3 mL.
Worked example 2: a design change with a reason. Priya’s team (concept A, polymer only) failed the salty-water criterion (mean 44 mL, sample data). Their reasoning: dissolved ions screen the polymer’s charged groups, but compost holds water mostly in pores and polar groups that salt affects less. Version 2: 0.5% polymer plus 10% compost, with a mulch layer on top. Sample result: salty mean 51 mL, 24-hour loss 21 g, within budget. They wrote it up two ways: a bar graph comparing versions and a particle diagram of the mix.
| Criterion | Version 1 | Change made and why | Version 2 | Met? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tap water held ≥ 50 mL | ||||
| Salty water held ≥ 45 mL | ||||
| 24-hour loss ≤ 30 g | ||||
| Budget ≤ 10 points | ||||
| ≥ half biodegradable additive |
Accuracy, precision, limits. Precision is how closely your trials agree. Accuracy is how close they are to the true value, which you can check against a known: does your cylinder read 100.0 g of water as 100 mL? Limitation: a cup in a classroom is not a field in summer sun with real roots, so the co-op should run a field trial before buying in bulk.
Use your notes and data.
Run version 2 and report in two formats.
Make a bar graph of version 1 and version 2 (tap and salty means, with the range shown) and write a paragraph explaining the change from the particle structure of your mix.
Superabsorbent polymers were developed in the 20th century and became common in diapers and other absorbent products. Since then, agricultural researchers in many dry regions have tested hydrogels as soil additives that store irrigation water near roots. In some trials, especially in sandy soils, seedlings survived dry spells better and less irrigation was needed.
Other studies found smaller benefits. The gels absorb far less in water that carries dissolved salts or calcium and magnesium ions, they hold less after repeated wetting and drying, and many common types break down only slowly in soil, raising questions about what they leave behind. Researchers are now testing gels built from starch and cellulose, which break down more readily. The lesson: a designed material’s performance depends on the conditions it meets in the field.
Think about it: Which of these limits did our classroom test detect, which could it not detect, and what would you add to the co-op’s field trial?
Version 2 is tested and justified. Next phase: the materials brief for the co-op.
Exit ticket: name the change that improved your design most, and the piece of data that proves it.
Materials: version 1 cups (weighed at 24 hours), sticky notes, the same supplies as 2.07, funnels with a fixed opening.
Timing: 24-hour readings 5 minutes, critique 15, version 2 build and pour 20, graph and write-up 10. Version 2’s 24-hour reading happens at the start of 2.09.
Listen for: dropping inconvenient trials without a reason; “precise means correct.”
Support / stretch: give a precision checklist (range, outliers, cause). Stretch: estimate the uncertainty of the “water held” value from the cylinder’s smallest division.