
Holding Water in Dry Soil: A Materials Brief for a Farm Co-op
Why do some substances hold together, dissolve or hold water better than others, and which soil additive should a farm co-op in a hot, dry valley choose to keep water near its crops’ roots?
The mystery: At salt-evaporation ponds along a coastal bay, shallow ponds turn green, orange and red, and the last ponds dry to white crystals of salt, many of them nearly perfect cubes. The water leaves; the salt stays behind.
describe ionic, covalent and metallic bonding as electrical attractions, predict the bond type between two elements, and ask questions about how particle forces explain the properties of salt and water.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Look at the aerial image of salt-evaporation ponds along a coastal bay: green, orange, red and white patches. Write two things you notice and one thing you wonder about why the last ponds are white.
When all the water in a salt pond evaporates, what do you predict remains, and why doesn't it evaporate too?
The phenomenon. Fly over certain coastal bays and you see a patchwork of ponds colored green, orange, red and purple. These are salt-evaporation ponds. Bay water is let into a chain of shallow ponds; the sun evaporates the water, and as the brine gets saltier, salt-loving algae and microbes tint each pond a different color. In the last ponds the water is gone and white crystals of sodium chloride remain, many of them nearly perfect cubes. Two questions organize this unit. Why does salt stay behind as a hard crystal when the water leaves? And why is water, a tiny molecule, a liquid at all at room temperature?
All bonding is electrical. Every bond and every attraction between particles comes from the same force you met in Unit 1: opposite charges attract, like charges repel. The force is stronger when the charges are larger and when they are closer together. What differs between substances is which charged particles attract which.
Ionic bonding. Sodium loses its one valence electron easily and chlorine gains one readily. When they meet, an electron transfers and the resulting Na+ and Cl− ions attract each other in every direction. Each Na+ ends up surrounded by six Cl− ions, and each Cl− by six Na+, in a repeating cubic lattice. That is why salt crystals are cubes. Pulling the lattice apart means overcoming many strong attractions at once, so salt melts only at 801 °C.
Covalent bonding. Two nonmetals both hold their electrons tightly, so neither gives one up. Instead they share a pair of electrons, and both nuclei are attracted to the shared pair between them. A water molecule has two O–H covalent bonds. The bonds inside a molecule are strong, but the attractions between separate molecules (intermolecular forces) are much weaker. Melting or boiling a molecular substance breaks only those weaker attractions, which is why sugar melts near 186 °C and wax near 60 °C, far below salt.
Metallic bonding. In a metal, the atoms give their valence electrons to a shared “sea” that moves through a lattice of positive ions. The mobile electrons explain why metals conduct electricity, the result you measured in Lesson 1.03.
Predicting the bond type. Electronegativity measures how strongly an atom pulls on shared electrons (Pauling scale: fluorine 3.98 is highest; sodium 0.93 is low). The difference between two atoms predicts the bond. As a guideline used in OpenStax Chemistry 2e: a difference below about 0.4 gives a nonpolar covalent bond; from 0.4 to about 1.8, a polar covalent bond, with the shared electrons pulled toward one atom; above about 1.8, an ionic bond. Worked examples: Na and Cl, 3.16 − 0.93 = 2.23, ionic. O and H, 3.44 − 2.20 = 1.24, polar covalent. C and H, 2.55 − 2.20 = 0.35, nonpolar covalent. These cut-offs are a continuum, not sharp walls.
Structure explains properties. The big idea for the unit is a crosscutting one: structure determines function. If we know how strongly the particles of a substance attract each other, we can predict its melting point, whether it dissolves, and whether it conducts. In the investigations you run that logic backward: you measure the properties and infer the forces.
Reading. OpenStax Chemistry 2e, chapters 7 and 10, CC BY 4.0.
Use the electronegativity values: Na 0.93, Mg 1.31, C 2.55, H 2.20, N 3.04, O 3.44, Cl 3.16, K 0.82.
Complete the bond-type prediction table for eight pairs.
| Pair | EN difference | Bond type | One property you predict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Na–Cl | |||
| K–Cl | |||
| Mg–O | |||
| O–H | |||
| N–H | |||
| C–H | |||
| C–O | |||
| Cl–Cl |
Pick the pair with the biggest difference and the pair with zero difference. Explain how each bond holds the atoms together as an electrical attraction.
Salt stays because its ions grip each other hard. Next class, you meet the client who needs water to stay put too.
Exit ticket: in two sentences, explain why water evaporates from the pond but salt does not, using the words ionic and intermolecular.
Materials: a generic aerial image of salt-evaporation ponds, a hand lens and table salt for each pair, electronegativity table, chart paper for the question board.
Listen for: “salt is heavier so it stays”; bonds described as tiny sticks instead of attractions; covalent bonds confused with intermolecular forces.
Support / stretch: give a three-column bonding organizer (who gives, who takes, who shares). Stretch: explain why the pond colors come from living things, not from the salt, and what that says about salinity tolerance.