
measure the mass of a reacting system in an open cup and in a sealed bag, and use the difference to support the claim that atoms, and therefore mass, are conserved in a chemical reaction.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. When you pour vinegar on baking soda, it fizzes and the cup seems lighter afterward. Write where you think the “missing” mass went, and how you could catch it.
What will happen to the balance reading of a sealed bag while baking soda and vinegar react inside it?
The investigation question. If atoms are conserved, mass should be conserved. But when you pour vinegar on baking soda, it fizzes, and the leftover liquid seems lighter. Has mass disappeared? Today you test the conservation claim with two setups: an open system, where matter can enter or leave, and a closed system, where it cannot. This lab runs two 50-minute periods.
The reaction. Baking soda is sodium hydrogen carbonate. Vinegar is about 5% acetic acid in water. They react: NaHCO3 + CH3COOH → NaCH3COO + H2O + CO2. Count the atoms: left, 1 Na, 5 H, 3 C, 5 O; right, 1 Na, 3 + 2 = 5 H, 2 + 1 = 3 C, 2 + 1 + 2 = 5 O. Balanced as written. The fizz is carbon dioxide gas.
Worked example 1: the equation predicts no change. Using molar masses (NaHCO3 84.01, CH3COOH 60.05, NaCH3COO 82.03, H2O 18.02, CO2 44.01 g/mol), the reactants total 84.01 + 60.05 = 144.06 g per mole of reaction and the products total 82.03 + 18.02 + 44.01 = 144.06 g. The equation itself predicts no change in mass. You will learn what a “mole” is in 3.05; for now, read it as a fixed, very large count of particles.
What to expect. In the open cup, the carbon dioxide escapes into the room, so the balance reading drops. How much? In Lesson 3.05 you will learn to calculate that 2.0 g of baking soda can make at most about 1.05 g of CO2. So the open cup should lose about a gram. In the sealed bag, the gas is trapped, so the reading should stay the same, within the uncertainty of the balance.
A subtle source of error. As the gas fills the bag, the bag puffs up. An inflated bag pushes aside more air, and the air pushes up on it slightly (the same buoyancy that lifts a helium balloon). About 0.58 L of CO2 from 2.0 g of baking soda displaces about 0.7 g of air, so a very puffy bag can read a few tenths of a gram lighter even though no matter left. That is not a failure of conservation; it is a measurement effect you should name in your analysis. Leaks are the other main error: press the sealed bag gently before reacting to check.
Reading a balance well. A 0.1 g balance has an uncertainty of about ±0.1 g. Two readings that differ by 0.1 g are effectively the same. Zero (tare) the balance with nothing on it, and never tare with the bag on it, because you need the total mass. Weigh everything, cup of vinegar and baking soda paper included, before mixing.
Procedure. Open trial: (1) Place a 250 mL cup holding 30 mL of vinegar and the paper holding 2.0 g of baking soda on the balance together; record the total. (2) Tip the baking soda into the vinegar, leaving the paper on the balance. When fizzing stops (about 2 minutes), record the final mass. Closed trial: (3) Put 2.0 g of baking soda in the corner of a zip-top bag. Stand a small cup with 30 mL of vinegar upright inside, press out extra air and seal; check for leaks by pressing gently. (4) Record the mass of the whole sealed bag. Without opening it, tip the cup so the vinegar mixes with the baking soda. When fizzing stops, record the final mass. (5) Calculate the change (final minus initial) for each trial and add your results to the class table. (6) Calculate the class average change for open and for closed trials.
| Trial | Initial mass (g) | Final mass (g) | Change (g) | Observations (fizzing, inflation, leaks) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Open cup | ||||
| Sealed bag | ||||
| Class average, open (n = ___) | ||||
| Class average, closed (n = ___) |
Worked example 2: class data are stronger than one trial (sample data). Eight groups ran both setups. Open changes: −0.9, −1.0, −0.8, −1.0, −0.9, −0.7, −1.0, −0.9 g; average −0.90 g. Closed changes: 0.0, −0.1, 0.0, −0.2, 0.0, −0.1, 0.0, −0.1 g; average −0.06 g. The open average is close to, but below, the 1.05 g maximum (some CO2 stays dissolved); the closed average is within the balance’s uncertainty of zero. HS-PS1-7 asks for a mathematical representation: you support the claim both with the atom count and with these numbers.
Answer as you collect data; return to the cards after clean-up.
Lab analysis, in your Corrosion Notebook.
The theoretical maximum CO2 from 2.0 g of baking soda is about 1.05 g. Compare your open-cup loss with this number and suggest why it might be smaller. Then name two sources of error in the closed trial and the direction each would push the result.
Predict whether a rusting nail in a sealed jar would gain, lose or keep the same total mass, and whether the nail itself would gain or lose mass. Explain both with atoms.
Mass is conserved when every atom is counted. Next class: where does the energy of a reaction go?
Exit ticket: a bolt on the bridge gains 2 g as it rusts. Where did those 2 g come from, and why does that not break the law of conservation of mass?
Materials (per group): baking soda (2.0 g per trial on folded weighing paper), white vinegar (5%, 30 mL per trial), a small cup (about 60 mL) that fits inside a quart-size zip-top freezer bag, a 250 mL cup, a balance reading to 0.1 g, a 50 mL graduated cylinder, goggles, paper towels.
Two periods: day 1 both trials and the class table; day 2 analysis and the CER. No-lab alternative: a recorded demonstration with on-screen balance readings and the sample class data above, plus the PhET Reactants, Products and Leftovers sim (Molecules screen) for the atom count.
Listen for: “gas has no mass”; “the closed bag lost 0.1 g so conservation failed.”
Support / stretch: give a CER frame with the evidence column pre-labeled. Stretch: estimate the buoyancy error from the bag’s volume change (air is about 1.2 g/L at room temperature).