
construct and defend an evidence-based explanation, with a labeled multi-level model, of how a lizard regrows its tail through cell division, differentiation and gene expression, for the museum’s exhibit text.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. The museum will print your explanation beside the exhibit. In one sentence, what is the most important idea a visitor should leave with?
Which sequence correctly traces how a gene affects a lizard's regrown tail?
The question. How does a lizard rebuild a tail from a small stump of cells, and why is the new tail different from the old one?
What a strong explanation contains. Your explanation must connect three levels, and the links between them matter as much as the levels themselves.
A worked example of one link. Claim: the stump regrows because cells near the wound divide rapidly. Evidence: in the root tip, the mitotic index in the meristem was far higher than 2 mm back, showing that growth is concentrated where cells divide. Reasoning: each division doubles the number of cells in a lineage, so a small group of dividing cells can supply the thousands of cells a new tail needs, and mitosis gives each new cell the same chromosomes. Every link in your explanation needs this structure.
Model and limits. Include your revised multi-level model from 3.06 or a photo of your exhibit version 2, and a short paragraph on where the model is accurate and where it is limited.
Sources. Your lab data, OpenStax Biology 2e chapters 10 and 15, and NHGRI or NCI pages. Cite every source, and say where a fact came from if you did not measure it.
Presentation. In four minutes, live or recorded, walk the museum’s education team (classmates, staff or family playing its members) through your model from gene to tissue and answer one question about your evidence.
Plan and check your draft with these prompts.
Work on the stage your teacher assigns.
Draft the “why the new tail is different” section: explain it with gene expression, say what is known and what is still being researched, and cite at least one source.
Task: Write an evidence-based explanation, for the museum’s exhibit text, of how a lizard regrows its tail. Include a labeled model that connects the gene, protein, cell and tissue levels; explain mitosis, differentiation and gene expression; trace one named protein from gene to function, including the effect of a mutation; explain why the new tail differs from the old one; and state where your model is accurate and where it is limited. Use evidence from the onion root tip lab, the strawberry DNA argument, the protein synthesis model and your exhibit’s visitor test. Hand-drawn models, photographed or scanned, are fully acceptable.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Cell division (HS-LS1-4) | Explains the cell cycle and mitosis accurately, identifies parent and daughter cells, and uses mitotic-index data as evidence of where growth happens. |
| Differentiation (HS-LS1-4) | Explains that specialized cells keep the whole genome and differ in gene expression, with evidence from cuttings or nuclear transfer. |
| DNA to protein (HS-LS1-1, HS-LS3-1) | Traces a named protein from gene sequence through transcription and translation to shape and function, including the effect of a mutation on the tissue. |
| Model and its limits | Model connects the gene, protein, cell and tissue levels with labeled links and states where it is accurate and where it is limited. |
| Use of evidence and sources | Claims tied to lab data and reliable, cited sources; calculations are correct; unknowns are stated honestly. |
| Communication | Clear for a museum visitor; the presentation answers a question about evidence accurately. |
Next: the unit checkpoint, then a 360° field trip.
Exit ticket: which question from our Wonder Board can you now answer? Write the question and your answer.
How confident are you that you can build and defend an explanation of regeneration that connects genes, proteins, cells and tissues.
Materials: Lab Notebooks with all unit data, exhibit version 2 and visitor data, rubric copies, a timer for presentations.
Timing: the task runs across about three sessions: plan and draft, peer review and revision, presentations. Writing can continue as homework.
Listen for: lists of facts with no causal links; “the new cells have new DNA”; certainty about regeneration signals that are still being researched.
Support / stretch: give a four-link organizer and sentence starters (“Because ___, the cells ___, so the tail ___”). Stretch: compare lizard tail regrowth with the cultured-skin case study and explain one similarity and one difference.