
extract DNA from strawberry cells, describe how DNA is organized into chromosomes and genes, and argue from evidence whether specialized cells keep their whole genome.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. A muscle cell and a skin cell from the same lizard look nothing alike. Write one reason you think they differ.
You mash a strawberry with soap and salt, then pour cold alcohol on top. What will you see at the boundary?
DNA, genes and chromosomes. DNA is a double helix: two strands of nucleotides twisted around each other. Each nucleotide carries one of four bases: adenine (A), thymine (T), guanine (G) or cytosine (C). The strands are held together by base pairs, and pairing follows a rule: A pairs with T, and G pairs with C.
Worked example 1: Chargaff’s rule. The pairing rule has a testable consequence, first measured by Erwin Chargaff: in double-stranded DNA the amount of A equals the amount of T, and G equals C. If 30% of the bases in a sample are A, then 30% are T, and the remaining 40% is split equally, so 20% are G and 20% are C. For a sample that is 22% A: T = 22%, and G = C = (100 − 44) ÷ 2 = 28%.
A gene is a stretch of DNA that carries the instructions for a product, usually a protein. A chromosome is one very long DNA molecule wound around proteins. The National Human Genome Research Institute describes the human genome as about 3 billion base pairs, carrying roughly 20,000 protein-coding genes, packaged into 23 pairs of chromosomes in almost every cell. Stretched out, the DNA in one human cell would be about 2 meters long, which gives you a sense of how tightly it is packed.
Why strawberries? Cultivated strawberries are octoploid: each cell has eight sets of chromosomes, so the fruit is rich in DNA. In the lab, you mash the fruit to break cell walls, add soap to dissolve the lipid membranes around the cell and the nucleus, add salt to help DNA strands clump, filter out the debris, and pour cold isopropyl alcohol on top. DNA does not dissolve in alcohol, so it comes out of solution as white strands at the boundary. You are seeing millions of DNA molecules clumped together, not a single strand and not individual genes. Every plant, animal, fungus and bacterial cell you could put through these steps would give DNA, because all cells carry it.
The argument: do specialized cells keep all their genes? Claim A: each cell type keeps only the genes it needs and loses the rest. Claim B: almost every cell keeps the whole genome, and cell types differ because they switch different genes on and off. Consider the evidence.
Worked example 2: handling exceptions. A strong argument handles the exceptions honestly. Mammalian red blood cells lose their nucleus as they mature, and some immune cells cut and rejoin segments of their antibody genes. These are real exceptions, and they do not overturn the general pattern. Evidence decides: a single cell’s DNA must still hold the instructions for a whole organism if a whole organism can grow from it. A rebuttal names the best evidence for the other side and explains why it does not win.
Back to the lizard. If Claim B is right, the cells at the tail stump carry the genes for skin, muscle, cartilage and nerve. That raises the next question for the model: how does a cell switch a gene on, and how does the gene’s code become a protein?
Lab procedure: extracting DNA from strawberries. Question: can we isolate DNA from plant cells, and what does each step do?
| Step | What we did | What we observed | Purpose of the step (our explanation) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mashing | |||
| Soap and salt buffer | |||
| Filtering | |||
| Cold alcohol |
No lab? Watch the teacher’s recorded demonstration, complete the observation table from the video, and write the same argument.
Reading: OpenStax Biology 2e, chapter 14, DNA Structure and Function, and section 16.1, Regulation of Gene Expression; NHGRI Talking Glossary entries for chromosome and gene (public domain).
Use your observation table and the evidence list.
Write your full argument.
Write your argument for Claim A or Claim B with at least three pieces of evidence, and rebut one piece of evidence for the other claim. Name each source (your lab, Gurdon, Dolly, OpenStax) and say why you trust it.
Identify two variables that could change how much DNA you collect, and describe how you would test one of them.
Every cell carries the full code. Next phase, we read the code: from gene to protein.
Exit ticket: give two pieces of evidence that all cells contain DNA, and one piece of evidence that specialized cells keep the whole genome.
How confident are you that you can explain how DNA is organized into genes and chromosomes and argue why specialized cells keep their whole genome.
Materials: one fresh or thawed strawberry per student in a zip-top bag, premixed extraction buffer, coffee filters, funnels, clear cups or tubes, ice-cold 70–91% isopropyl alcohol in a dropper bottle (keep it in the teacher’s freezer), wooden stirrers, goggles.
Timing: this lab spans two 50-minute periods: extraction and observations on day 1, argument writing on day 2.
Listen for: “we can see the double helix” (we see a clump); “cells lose genes they don’t need” (address with the cloning evidence).
Support / stretch: give an argument frame (claim, three evidence boxes, reasoning, rebuttal). Stretch: research how an organism with many chromosome sets differs from one with two, and ask a testable question about it.