
revise my model of tail regrowth so it connects genes, proteins, cell division and differentiation, judge where the model matches the real process and where it falls short, and brainstorm exhibit ideas from it.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Take out your initial tail model from 3.01. Circle one thing you now know is wrong or missing, and write what you would change.
A good scientific model has to look exactly like the real thing.
Pulling the unit together. In three investigations you gathered evidence at three levels. The root tips showed where and how fast cells divide. The strawberry argument showed that specialized cells keep the whole genome. The protein model showed how a gene’s sequence becomes a protein that does a job. Today you join the levels into one revised, multi-level model of tail regrowth.
The four links.
Worked example 1: a model-revision log. Diego’s first model showed a stump with “new tail cells” and an arrow to a tail. His revision log reads: Added: a mitosis panel with one parent and two identical daughters (evidence: root tip slides). Added: three branches from the daughter cells to cartilage, muscle and skin, each labeled with the gene switched on (evidence: strawberry argument, cloning). Changed: “cells make new DNA” to “cells copy the same DNA”. Added: a zoom box showing one gene → mRNA → protein (evidence: bead model).
Worked example 2: where the model is accurate and where it is limited. Every model of cell division leaves things out. Compare a typical classroom model, four pipe-cleaner chromosomes split into two piles, with the real process.
| Feature | Classroom model | Real cell | Does it matter? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chromosome number | 4 | 16 in onion; dozens in many lizards | Not for the idea of identical copies |
| Timing | Separate, neat steps | A continuous process; stages blur into each other | Yes, when classifying cells on a slide |
| Control | Not shown | Checkpoints stop division if DNA is damaged | Yes, for explaining why regrowth stops |
| Differentiation | Not shown | Signals from neighbors switch genes on | Yes, for explaining the cartilage tube |
A strong statement of a model’s limits names the feature, says how reality differs, and says whether the difference changes the conclusions you draw from the model.
Why is the new tail different? The DNA is the same, so the difference must come from which genes are expressed. In an adult wound, the signals that guide cells differ from the signals in an embryo, so cartilage forms where bone once stood. Scientists are still working out exactly which signals are involved; good explanations say clearly what is known and what is not.
Ideate: from model to exhibit. Our client needs visitors to grasp these four links in four minutes. Brainstorm at least five exhibit ideas, each tied to one link: a flip-panel mitosis wheel, a “same DNA, different switches” light-board, a codon decoder visitors spin, a magnetic tail visitors rebuild cell by cell, or a before-and-after cross-section of old and new tails. Wild ideas are welcome; we judge them in 3.07.
Revise your model with your team, then answer.
Model limits and Ideate.
Name two ways your revised model differs from real tail regrowth. For each, explain whether the difference changes what a visitor would conclude from the model.
Ideate: list five exhibit ideas for the museum. Tag each with the link it teaches (division, more cells, differentiation or function) and star the two your team likes best.
Our science is ready. Next phase, we design the exhibit.
Exit ticket: in three sentences, explain how a tail stump becomes a tail, from gene to tissue.
How confident are you that you can use a multi-level model to explain growth and differentiation and judge where the model is accurate and where it is limited.
Materials: students’ 3.01 initial models, chart paper, colored markers, sticky notes for the Ideate wall, the class Wonder Board.
Setup: before revising, revisit the Wonder Board and mark the questions the unit has now answered.
Listen for: revisions without evidence; “a model is wrong if it is simplified”; “differentiated cells lost genes”.
Support / stretch: give a four-box model frame (division, more cells, differentiation, function). Stretch: add a cell-cycle checkpoint to the model and explain what would happen to the tail if it failed.