
use a carbon model and a weighted decision matrix to compare green-waste and planting plans for the park, and set up a decomposition test as evidence.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. One fallen branch, four fates: burned, chipped, composted, or left as a log. Rank them from fastest to slowest return of its carbon to the air.
Three jars hold damp, dry and waterlogged leaf litter, each with a small cup of bromothymol blue (BTB). BTB turns from blue to yellow as CO2 builds up. Which jar turns yellow first?
Scientists, the brief. The parks department needs a plan for its green waste and new plantings that keeps more carbon out of the air for at least 10 years, fits its budget and space, and keeps the park healthy and safe. Your prototype is a carbon plan: a carbon-flow model of the park, a carbon ledger with calculations, and a recommendation.
Class criteria and constraints. The plan must (1) keep more carbon stored after 10 years than the current practice (open burning), (2) cost no more than 12 budget points per tonne handled plus new plantings, (3) fit the park’s space, and (4) do no harm to people or wildlife (no smoke near paths, no blocked trails).
Worked example 1: comparing options with a ledger.
| Option for one tonne of dry green waste (sample planning numbers) | Carbon still stored after 10 years (kg) | Cost (budget points) | Space needed | Other effects |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. Burn in an open pile | 0 | 1 | small | smoke; all carbon released at once |
| B. Chip and spread as mulch | 50 | 3 | beds and paths | improves soil; slow aerobic decay |
| C. Compost and add to soil | 100 | 4 | compost yard | richer soil for new trees |
| D. Keep large logs as benches and habitat | 250 | 2 | wooded edges | habitat; slowest decay |
These are invented planning numbers for practice, not measured values. Option D stores the most carbon per tonne and costs little, but only large logs work, and space is limited. Most plans combine options: logs where they fit, compost for leaves and small branches.
Adding photosynthesis. New trees pull carbon from the air as they grow. Sample planning figure: a young shade tree adds about 10 kg of dry wood a year in its first decade. That is about 5 kg of carbon, or 5 × 3.664 ≈ 18 kg of CO2 a year per tree. Twenty new trees: about 366 kg of CO2 a year.
Worked example 2: a weighted decision matrix. Score each team plan 1–3 on each criterion and multiply by the weight: carbon stored (3), cost (2), space (1), park health and safety (2). A plan with the most carbon but a safety problem can lose to a balanced plan. Show the totals and name the trade-offs.
Where the model and reality differ. Our ledger treats all leaves alike and uses one decay rate per option. Real decay depends on temperature, moisture, wood type and the decomposers present, and some compost carbon stays in the soil for decades while some leaves in months. Say this in your plan.
Decomposition test setup (read results in 2.08).
| Jar | BTB color at start | BTB color after ~24 h | Inferred CO2 release (none, low, high) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dry litter | |||
| Damp litter | |||
| Waterlogged litter | |||
| Control (no litter) |
Build your ledger and matrix as a team.
Finish version 1 of your plan.
Complete your weighted decision matrix for at least two plans. State which plan wins, name its biggest trade-off, and predict what the decomposition jars will show.
Version 1 plans are drafted and the jars are running. Next lesson: critique, jar results and version 2.
Exit ticket: explain how photosynthesis and respiration together decide whether the park is adding carbon to the air or removing it.
Materials: four clear jars with lids per class group, leaf litter, small cups, dilute bromothymol blue, gloves, scales, graduated cylinders, goggles, calculators, matrix and ledger templates.
Setup: jars need about 24 hours; keep them at room temperature out of direct sun. Ledger numbers are invented for practice; tell students so and invite them to look up real figures as a stretch.
Listen for: “composting destroys carbon”; plans that ignore cost or safety.
Support / stretch: give a partly filled ledger. Stretch: add landfill as option E and research why buried waste can release methane.