
use peer critique and visitor test data to improve the exhibit, evaluate how well it models the real process of growth and differentiation, and judge the sources behind its science.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Look at your version 1 checklist. Write one criterion you are sure you met and one you are not, and say why.
Visitors averaged 1.8 out of 4 before and 2.6 after using an exhibit (sample data). What does this most suggest?
Gallery critique. Teams set out their exhibits, matrices and visitor checks. Visitors leave sticky notes in three colors: I like… (a strength backed by evidence), I wonder… (a question about the science or the visitor experience), and What if… (a specific change). Critique the design, not the designer.
Class criteria (set in 3.07). The Regrowth Exhibit must (1) fit on a 60 cm × 90 cm table, (2) show all four levels, gene, protein, cell and tissue, and both mitosis and differentiation, (3) take a visitor no more than 4 minutes to finish, (4) cost no more than 10 sample budget points, and (5) raise a test group’s average score on a 4-question visitor check by at least 2 points, with zero science errors found in peer review.
Worked example 1: reading visitor data (sample data). Jamal’s team tested version 1 with six visitors. Average before: 1.5 of 4; after: 2.8; gain 1.3 points. Item by item, almost every visitor got What does mitosis make? right afterward, but only two of six got Why are muscle and skin cells different? right. The exhibit taught division well and differentiation poorly. Their fix: a lift-flap on each switch card showing the same DNA strip with a different gene highlighted.
Worked example 2: version 2 (sample data). With the lift-flaps and one label rewritten, six new visitors averaged 1.7 before and 3.8 after, a gain of 2.1 points. The differentiation item rose to five of six correct. Average time grew from 3.1 to 3.6 minutes, still under 4. Version 2 met criteria 3 and 5. Six visitors is a small sample, so the team noted that a larger test at the museum would make the result more trustworthy.
Worked example 3: judging sources. The exhibit’s backing text must be accurate, so every science statement needs a reliable source. Rank them: a peer-reviewed article or a textbook such as OpenStax (reviewed by experts); a government science agency such as NHGRI or the National Cancer Institute; your own class data (real but small and illustrative); a simulation such as PhET (built from accepted science, but simplified). A random video or post with no author is not enough. For any claim, ask: who says so, how do they know, and does another reliable source agree?
| Version | Before (avg of 4) | After (avg of 4) | Gain | Avg time (min) | Errors found | Criteria met (1-5) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ||||||
| 2 |
Use your critique notes and both versions’ data.
Evaluate your exhibit as a model.
Write the exhibit's “About this model” label (60 words or fewer): two things it shows accurately, one thing it leaves out, and two sources a visitor could trust to learn more.
In the 1970s, researchers learned how to grow human skin cells (keratinocytes) in the lab, spreading them over a layer of supporting cells so they kept dividing. By the early 1980s, burn centers had begun using this method for patients who had lost too much skin for ordinary grafts. Doctors take a small piece of the patient’s own healthy skin, separate the cells, and let them divide by mitosis in culture for a few weeks until they form thin sheets large enough to cover wounds. Because the new cells come from the patient, they carry the patient’s own DNA, so the body does not reject them. The method has limits: the sheets are fragile, they form only the outer layer of skin, and they do not grow hair follicles or sweat glands, so the result is not identical to the original skin, much like a lizard’s regrown tail.
Think about it: Which ideas from this unit explain why cultured skin works, and why it is not an exact copy? How could your exhibit use this example?
Exhibit version 2 and your visitor data feed straight into the performance task.
Exit ticket: which change from version 1 to version 2 made the biggest difference, and what evidence shows it?
How confident are you that you can use critique and test data to improve a model and judge its accuracy, limits and sources.
Materials: version 1 exhibits, sticky notes in three colors, extra building materials, printed visitor checks, timers.
Timing: about 15 minutes of gallery critique, 25 minutes to revise and re-test with visitors from another team, 10 minutes to log and evaluate.
Listen for: revisions with no data behind them; treating a small visitor sample as proof; “cultured skin is a perfect copy”.
Support / stretch: give a revision-log template and a source-reliability checklist. Stretch: graph each item’s before and after scores and decide which item the exhibit still teaches least.