find, explain and fix the most common errors with translations, reflections, rotations and dilations, including adding instead of multiplying in a dilation.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. A sample design drawn on a 30-inch stop sign has a line 10 inches long. A student enlarges the design for a 36-inch sign. She says, “The sign grew by 6 inches, so the line is 16 inches now.”
Is the student right?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Mistakes are clues. Most transformation errors come from a few habits. If you know them, you can check your own work fast. Each error below is shown with the wrong answer it really produces.
Error 1: adding in a dilation. A dilation multiplies every length by the scale factor. Adding the same amount to every length changes the shape.
Worked example 1: fix the sign design. Deshawn checks the Do Now. Step 1: scale factor from the 30-inch sign to the 36-inch sign = 36 ÷ 30 = 1.2. Step 2: the 10-inch line becomes 10 × 1.2 = 12 inches. Step 3: the wrong answer came from adding: 10 + 6 = 16. Step 4: test the shape: the whole sign width went from 30 to 36, which is ×1.2, so every part must also be ×1.2.
Error 2: changing the wrong sign in a reflection. Over the x-axis, y changes sign. A student who reflects (2, 5) over the x-axis but changes x writes (−2, 5), which is really the reflection over the y-axis. The correct image is (2, −5).
Worked example 2: fix a rotation. Tariq rotates (3, 1) 90° counterclockwise and writes (1, −3). Step 1: test the rule he used: (y, −x) gives (1, −3), which is the clockwise rule. Step 2: the counterclockwise rule is (−y, x). Step 3: (−1, 3). Step 4: check the quadrant: (3, 1) is in quadrant I, and a quarter turn counterclockwise should land in quadrant II, where x is negative. (−1, 3) is in quadrant II.
Error 3: swapping a translation. “3 right, 2 down” is (x + 3, y − 2). A student who swaps the numbers uses (x + 2, y − 3) and moves (4, −1) to (6, −4) instead of the correct (7, −3).
For each item, decide what is right and why the wrong answers happen.
Write the error, the reason, and the fix for each.
Leo translated (4, −1) “3 units right and 2 units down” and got (6, −4). Find his mistake, explain it, and give the correct image.
A 48-inch sign is a dilation of a 36-inch sign. What is the scale factor from the 48-inch sign back to the 36-inch sign?
A 30-inch sign drawing dilated by scale factor 1.6 is inches wide. (Write the number only.)
We know the common traps. Next we compare different sequences that reach the same image and decide which to show our audience.
Exit ticket: which mistake from today do you think you are most likely to make? Write one check you will use to catch it.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 7, mini lesson 11, guided practice 12, exit ticket 5.
Accuracy: the octagon rule, the colors and the STOP sizes from Table 2B-1 (30 by 30 single lane and minimum, 36 by 36 multi-lane and expressway, 48 by 48 oversized), and the two 36-inch minimum rules are from the MUTCD 2009 edition page. FHWA’s site says the current edition is the 11th Edition (December 2023, with Revision 1 dated December 2025), available only as a PDF; we did not check its table, so present these as the 2009 edition sizes. The 10-inch and 5-inch design lines are sample data, not MUTCD letter sizes.
Likely misconceptions: the four errors in the mini lecture; also multiplying only one coordinate in a dilation (Mia). Every wrong answer shown was re-derived from the error described: 10 + 6 = 16; (2, 5) with x negated is (−2, 5); (y, −x) on (3, 1) is (1, −3); (x + 2, y − 3) on (4, −1) is (6, −4); halving only x gives (1, 4), (3, 4), (1, 8).
Supports: an error checklist: multiply, not add; which sign changes; quadrant check; right/left is x. Stretch: write your own wrong answer for a classmate to diagnose.
Answer guide: Mia halved only the x-coordinates; correct image (1, 2), (3, 2), (1, 4). Leo swapped the numbers, using (x + 2, y − 3); correct (x + 3, y − 2) gives (7, −3).
Federal Highway Administration, Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices, 2009 Edition, Chapter 2B: Regulatory Signs · U.S. government work, public domain
Traffic signs across the United States follow a federal guide called the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices, or MUTCD. Uniform means the same everywhere, so drivers in any state see the same shapes and colors. This page is Chapter 2B of the 2009 edition, which covers regulatory signs, the signs that tell drivers what they must do.
The manual says a STOP sign shall be an octagon, an eight-sided shape, with a white word and border on a red background.
Table 2B-1 lists the sizes, in inches. For a STOP sign, the size for a single-lane conventional road is 30 by 30, the size for a multi-lane road is 36 by 36, the expressway size is 36 by 36, and the oversized sign is 48 by 48. The minimum size is 30 by 30.
The manual also sets rules for when the bigger size is needed. STOP signs that face multi-lane approaches must be at least 36 by 36 inches. So do STOP signs on side roads that meet a multi-lane highway with a speed limit of 45 mph or higher.
Source: Federal Highway Administration, Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices, 2009 Edition, Chapter 2B: Regulatory Signs (mutcd.fhwa.dot.gov)