present our Community Data Dashboard, explain how we know each number is right, and answer audience questions with math.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Leaders plan with data all the time. Read how the Census Bureau describes the way communities use its biggest yearly survey.
According to the reading, who uses American Community Survey data to plan the future?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Tonight the audience is real. Board members, council members and families will walk the dashboard. Each team has three minutes to present and two minutes for questions.
A strong presentation has four moves. (1) The question your panel asked. (2) The display and what it shows, in one sentence with numbers. (3) How you checked it. (4) What the data cannot tell us, and what we would study next.
Worked example 1: Lena’s 30-second finding. “We asked whether late screen time goes with less sleep. In our sample of 8 students, sleep tended to drop about 1 hour for each extra hour of screen time after 8 p.m.; our model is y = −x + 10 for 0.5 to 3.5 hours. We checked the slope with two points on the line. This is an association, not proof of a cause.”
Worked example 2: Raj answers a question with math. A board member asks, “If more students left phones out of their bedrooms, how many more would get 8 hours?” Raj answers: “Our sample can’t tell you that for sure, because it shows an association, not a cause. We can say that 30% of phone students and 60% of no-phone students got 8 hours. A study that changes one thing at a time could test it.” He uses the data without claiming more than it shows.
Speak to be understood. Point to the axis or cell you are talking about, say the units, and define any math word your audience may not know.
Rehearse with your team before guests arrive.
Present and listen.
After presenting, write down one question a guest asked and how your team answered. Would you change your answer now? Why?
Listen to another team. Write one thing they did well and one question you would ask them about their data.
Data matter most when they help people decide well.
Exit ticket: what is one decision a school board member could make better because of our dashboard? What would you tell them to be careful about?
Pacing: warm-up and reading 5 minutes, mini lecture 5, rehearsal 8, presentations and questions 18, independent reflection 2, closure 2. If guests come in the evening, use this lesson as rehearsal and present at the event.
Likely misconceptions: reading the slope as a count; promising a result the data cannot support; skipping units when speaking.
Supports: sentence starters for each of the four moves; a role card for each team member (presenter, pointer, question answerer, timekeeper). Invite board and council members through the principal; no student personal data appears on any panel.
Answer guide: warm-up: public officials and planners; “In our sample, more sleep went with higher scores”; each extra hour went with about 6 more points; true; 60; about 432 ppm (2.6 × 12 + 401 = 432.2). Lena’s model comes from 1.18 (line through (0.5, 9.5) and (3.5, 6.5)).
U.S. Census Bureau, About the American Community Survey · U.S. government work, public domain
Most people know the U.S. Census Bureau for its count of every person once every ten years. The bureau also runs the American Community Survey, or ACS. The ACS is an ongoing survey that gives information about the nation and its people every year, and the bureau releases new ACS data every year.
The bureau’s page explains why the survey matters. The answers people give help decide how trillions of dollars in federal funds are shared out each year.
The page lists ways communities use the data. Residents’ answers help communities plan for hospitals and schools, support school lunch programs, improve emergency services and build bridges. Public officials and planners use the information to understand the past and plan for the future. Businesses use it to decide whether to add jobs or expand into new markets.
All of that depends on trust. A planner can only make a good decision if the numbers are collected carefully and reported honestly. That is the same promise our dashboard makes to the East Allegheny School Board and borough councils: here are our numbers, here is how we checked them, and here is what they can and cannot tell you.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, About the American Community Survey (census.gov)