Park Design Pitch
How do designers use transformations, distance and volume to build public spaces?
The mystery: Is it faster to walk around a rectangular park or cut across the diagonal, and by how much?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
use a scale drawing to estimate how much shorter it is to cut across a rectangular park than to walk around it, and explain why a scale drawing has the same shape as the real park.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. A sample rectangular park is 400 meters long and 300 meters wide. You are at one corner and want to reach the opposite corner. You can walk along two sides, or cut straight across on a diagonal path.
About how much shorter is the diagonal path than walking along two sides?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Welcome, Park Designers. In this unit you will create a Park Design Pitch for a local park and present it to the borough or township council and its parks board. Our driving question: How do designers use transformations, distance and volume to build public spaces? In Part 1 you will design a park logo or mural panel by moving and resizing shapes. In Part 2 you will add path distances and planter volumes.
Our puzzle. L’Enfant laid diagonal avenues across a grid so people could travel more directly. Is cutting across a rectangular park really faster than walking around it, and by how much? We cannot measure a real park with a ruler, so we measure a scale drawing of it.
Scale drawings. In a scale drawing every length is multiplied by the same number, called the scale factor. The angles do not change. So the drawing is the same shape as the park, only smaller. A scale of 1 cm : 100 m means each centimeter on paper stands for 100 meters of park.
Worked example 1: measure the diagonal. Keisha draws the 400 m by 300 m sample park at 1 cm : 100 m. Step 1: the long side is 400 ÷ 100 = 4 cm and the short side is 300 ÷ 100 = 3 cm. Step 2: she draws a 4 cm by 3 cm rectangle with square corners. Step 3: she measures corner to corner and gets 5 cm. Step 4: 5 cm stands for 5 × 100 = 500 m. Step 5: around is 400 + 300 = 700 m, so the diagonal saves 700 − 500 = 200 m.
Worked example 2: how much time? Tomás uses a sample walking rate of 80 meters per minute. Step 1: around takes 700 ÷ 80 = 8.75 minutes. Step 2: across takes 500 ÷ 80 = 6.25 minutes. Step 3: the shortcut saves 8.75 − 6.25 = 2.5 minutes. Check: 200 m ÷ 80 m per minute = 2.5 minutes. It matches.
Why the drawing can be trusted. 1 cm : 100 m is the same as 1 cm : 10,000 cm, so every length on paper is 1/10,000 of the real length. Because one scale factor is used for every length, the drawing is a shrunken copy with the same angles. Later in this part we will call this kind of shrinking a dilation.
Starting our Wonder Board. A ruler gives an estimate. Is the diagonal exactly 500 m? Is there a way to know without measuring? Post your questions. We will answer the exact-distance question in Part 2.
Use a ruler and grid paper. The scale is 1 cm : 100 m unless a problem says otherwise.
Start your Park Designer notebook. Use grid paper and a ruler.
A sample park is 240 m long and 100 m wide. Draw it at 1 cm : 20 m. Measure the diagonal, change it to meters, and find how much the shortcut saves compared with walking along two sides.
Which is a correct scale drawing of the 400 m by 300 m park at 1 cm : 100 m?
Write one question about parks, paths or park design that you could answer with math. Put it on a sticky note for the Wonder Board.
We met our puzzle and our project. Next time we meet our audience and look at the four ways a designer can move or resize a shape.
Exit ticket: in one or two sentences, explain how a scale drawing helped you estimate the shortcut, and what you still wonder about it.
Pacing: Do Now 5 min, reading 7, mini lesson 12, drawing and guided practice 11, Wonder Board and exit ticket 5.
Accuracy: the park sizes and the 80 m per minute walking rate are sample data. The 400 by 300 and 240 by 100 parks are chosen so the measured diagonal is exactly 500 m and 260 m; the 300 by 300 park’s diagonal is about 424 m (4.2 cm). Do not introduce the Pythagorean Theorem yet; it is developed in Part 2 (CC.2.3.8.A.3). The reading details come from the NPS article (it gives no year in the summary; see 2.14); it does not give the canal’s length, so do not quote one.
Likely misconceptions: using the full perimeter (1,400 m) instead of two sides; thinking the diagonal is drawn full size; using different scales for different sides. Ask: “Would the drawing still be the same shape?”
Supports: pre-drawn 1 cm grid with the 4 by 3 rectangle. Stretch: what scale would make the 400 m side 10 cm long? (1 cm : 40 m.)
Answer guide: 240 m by 100 m at 1 cm : 20 m is 12 cm by 5 cm; the diagonal measures 13 cm = 260 m; two sides = 340 m; savings = 80 m. The scale explanation should say the shape would be stretched or squished, so the measured diagonal would not match the real park.
National Park Service, The L'Enfant Plan · U.S. government work, public domain
When the United States chose a site for its capital city, a planner named Pierre L’Enfant drew the city’s layout. A National Park Service article by Charles LeeDecker describes his plan.
The article calls a pattern of streets that run east-west and north-south the more traditional pattern. We call it a grid: its streets meet at right angles. L’Enfant kept a grid, but he laid a network of broad diagonal avenues over it. A diagonal street cuts across the grid at a slant.
The most important diagonal is Pennsylvania Avenue. It gives a direct link between the Capitol, where Congress meets, and the President’s House. In other words, a traveler on it does not have to zigzag along grid streets to get from one to the other.
L’Enfant also planned two broad strips of public land. One ran south from the President’s House, and the other ran west from the Capitol. These lands are now the heart of the parks in the city’s Monumental Core.
He even planned a canal to give boats a shorter route from the Georgetown wharves to the deep-water ports on the Anacostia River. River travel there was hard because the tides rose and fell. So shorter routes and open public space were both part of his plan.
Source: National Park Service, The L'Enfant Plan (nps.gov)