answer the unit’s driving question with evidence, explain what a scatter plot can and cannot show, and reflect on our growth.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Back on the first day of the unit, we asked: do students who sleep more get better grades? Read how NCES explains independent and dependent variables. Then answer.
In the NCES example, which variable is the dependent variable?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Our answer, with evidence. In our sample, students who slept more tended to have higher quiz scores: a positive linear association, modeled by y = 6x + 34 for 6 to 9.5 hours. The CDC recommends 8 to 10 hours for teens, and our phone table showed students with phones in the bedroom were less likely to reach 8 hours (30% vs 60%).
What a scatter plot can show. Direction, form and strength of a pattern; clusters; outliers; and a model we can use for predictions inside the data. It is a powerful first step.
What it cannot show. It cannot prove a cause. Scores depend on many things, as the NCES page says: studying, sleep, even hunger. A lurking variable, such as a busy schedule, might affect both sleep and scores. To test a cause, scientists design studies that change one thing on purpose and keep everything else the same.
Worked example 1: Imani writes a claim with limits. “Our sample suggests that more sleep is associated with higher scores, about 6 points per hour. Because many factors affect scores, we can’t say sleep caused the higher scores. Our sample of 10 students is small, so a larger survey is a good next step.”
Worked example 2: Caleb looks back at functions. Caleb notices that the unit started and ended with functions. The cricket rule T = c + 40 is an exact linear function. The rating curve y = 25x2 is a nonlinear function. The sleep data are not a function at all, but the line of best fit we drew through them is. “A model turns messy data into a function we can use,” he writes, “as long as we remember it is a summary.”
Reflect on growth. Think about where you started this unit and what you can do now.
Gather your evidence before you write.
Write your reflection.
Reflection: what is one math skill from this unit you can now use outside school? Give a real example.
Look at your work from the first week of the unit and from the unit check. Describe one way your thinking about data changed.
Use the reading. Name three factors besides sleep that might affect a quiz score. Which one would you study next, and how?
Good data stories are true stories, told with care.
Exit ticket: finish this sentence: “A scatter plot can show ___, but it cannot show ___.”
How confident are you that you can I can use functions and data to tell an honest story about my community.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 6 minutes, mini lecture 8, guided practice 13, reflection writing 10, closure 3.
Likely misconceptions: turning “associated” back into “causes” in the final paragraph; thinking a bigger sample proves a cause; reading the NCES sentence test as proof that a cause exists (it only helps name the variables).
Supports: a paragraph frame (finding, two numbers, a limit, a next step). Stretch: design an ethical study that could test the effect of sleep on quiz scores, and explain what you would keep the same. Sleep logs are optional and stay private.
Answer guide: warm-up: the test score; hours of sleep, then quiz score; false; busy schedule; y = 25x2; 85 (6 × 8.5 = 51, 51 + 34 = 85); a study where sleep changes on purpose. Sample paragraph: “In our sample, students who slept more tended to score higher, about 6 points per extra hour, and students without phones in their bedrooms were twice as likely to get 8 hours (60% vs 30%). We can predict scores for 6 to 9.5 hours of sleep, but not far outside that range, and we cannot say sleep caused the scores.” The challenge quotation is copied exactly from the NCES page.
National Center for Education Statistics, NCES Kids' Zone: What are Independent and Dependent Variables? · U.S. government work, public domain
The NCES graph guide explains that a variable is anything you are trying to measure: an object, an event, an idea, a feeling, a time period or another kind of category. There are two kinds.
An independent variable stands alone and is not changed by the other variables being measured. The guide’s example is a person’s age. What they eat or how much television they watch will not change how old they are.
A dependent variable depends on other factors. The guide’s example is a test score. It could change depending on how much you studied, how much sleep you got the night before or even how hungry you were during the test.
The guide offers a sentence test to tell them apart: “(Independent variable) causes a change in (dependent variable), and it isn’t possible that (dependent variable) could cause a change in (independent variable).” For example, time spent studying can change a test score, but a test score cannot go back and change the time you already spent studying.
Notice that the test score has several possible factors. That is why a scatter plot of sleep and scores, by itself, cannot tell us that sleep is the reason.
“Usually when you are looking for a relationship between two things you are trying to find out what makes the dependent variable change the way it does.”
Source: National Center for Education Statistics, NCES Kids' Zone: What are Independent and Dependent Variables? (nces.ed.gov)